Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up?

[14 Years Estranged]

Someone asked me a question two days ago that made me think about this: "If you could create your own line-up for Guns N' Roses keeping Axl Rose as the original remaining member of the 1987-1996 line-up... who would you pick for the line-up?"

Mine was this:

Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) - Vocals, Rhythm Guitar
Tim Skold (Marilyn Manson, KMFDM) - Lead Guitar
Christian O. Wolbers (Front Line Assembly, Fear Factory) - Lead Guitar
Robin Finck (Nine Inch Nails, Guns N' Roses) - Lead & Rhythm Guitar
Al Pitrelli (Suicidal Tendencies, Megadeth) - Lead & Rhythtm Guitar
Sean Yseult (White Zombie) - Bass
John Tempesta (White/Rob Zombie, Scum Of The Earth) - Drums
Dizzy Reed (Guns N' Roses) - Keyboards

[saint seiya]

Axl
Slash
Izzy Stradlin
Duff
Dizzy
Matt Sorum

[14 Years Estranged]

Bah... Mind you that Axl had to be the only original member of the 1987-1996 line up... 

[Evolution]

Is it too predictable to name the current line up? 

[KILLYOURIDOL]

Axl
Dimebag Darrell (Pantera,Damgeplan)Lead Guitar(R.I.P the man was a god)
Jerry Cantrell(AIC)Lead/Rythm Guitar
Angus Young(AC/DC)Lead Guitar
Jason Newsted(Metallica)Bass
Dave Grohl(Nirvana,Foo Fighters)Drums
Teddy Zig Zag Keyboard and a fucking kick ass harmonica

[bazgnr]

Is it too predictable to name the current line up??

Nope.  That'd be my choice.

[Niko]

Axl
Joe Perry
Gilby Clarke
Jason Newsted
Dave Grohl


(whoaaa this line-up would kick ass) !!

[EFISH]

the current line-up!

IF anything could change, slash gets in there instead of Bumble.

but, that'd be a little much.. finck is pretty much the new slash and i dont want finck to go.

[johnnythunders24]

Axl - Lead Vocals
Robin - Lead Guitar
Ron Thal- Guitar
Richard Fortus- Guitar
Tommy- Bass
Brain- Drums
Dizzy- Keyboards
Chris Pitman- Synth

 

[Niko]

Axl - Lead Vocals
Robin - Lead Guitar
Ron Thal- Guitar
Richard Fortus- Guitar
Tommy- Bass
Brain- Drums
Dizzy- Keyboards
Chris Pitman- Synth

 

come on guys!!!

the idea of the thread is for you to be creative, not to show that you like the new band or the old band, beacause
we are always getting back to that old dead horse

[Stonerose]

Sorry but.....

Axl Rose   Vocals
Izzy Stradlin   Rythem Guitar
Duff Mckagen   Bass
Slash   Lead
Steven Adler   Drums

[Mattattack]

Under the assumption that everybody is in their prime.
Vocals Axl Rose
Guitar Jimmy Page
Bass John Paul Jones
Drums John Bonham

Axl fronting Zeppelin would have been the best. I like Plants voice but I don't relate to his Lord of The Rings style lyrics.
The new Gnr's sound, especially on Madagascar, reminds me a lot of Zeppelin. The fact Axl is so willing to experiment with any style of music is something i'm sure he picked up from Zeppelin and other acts like Queen. 

[Carlos_f_Rose]

Sorry but.....

Axl Rose? ?Vocals
Izzy Stradlin? ?Rythem Guitar
Duff Mckagen? ?Bass
Slash? ?Lead
Steven Adler? ?Drums

Same here...

[mikepatton]

stupidest question ever.........the 1987 lineup..............axl, slash, izzy, steven and duff...miek clink as the producer..case closed.............

[SOH]

Axl - Vocals
Les Claypool - Bass
"Weird Al" Yankovic - Accordian

[AXL 20]

87 for sure
even 92

but if we have to (all living)

Axl- Vocals
Brian May- Lead/Rythm guitar
Jeff Beck- Lead Guitar
Joe Perry- Lead/Rythm guitar
Billy Sheehan- Bass
Roger Taylor- Drums
John Paul Jones- Keyboards, Piano

That would be a killer group. Joe Perry's bluesy tone combined with Brian May's unmistakable sound backing a Jeff Beck Solo with a Billy Sheehan bassline and Roger Taylor and John Paul Jones laying down some rythm and AXL fronting it all!!!!!

List 2 (deceased)

Axl- Vocals
Freddie Mercury- Vocals
Duane Allman- Lead Guitar
Jimi Hendrix- Rythm guitar
Randy Rhoads- Lead/Rythm guitar
Jaco Pastorious- Bass
John Bonham- Drums
Freddie Mercury- Keyboards, Piano

Axl and Freddie in one band together on stage is a dream of mine that will never come true. My 2 favorite singers. Duane Allman would but the blues into it with Randy Rhoads doing a rythm would almsot compensate for slash and Jimi Hendrix, well hes not as great as they say whihh is why i put him on rythm. And Jaco and John fuckin' Bonham? is there anything left to say?

[AXL 20]

Someone asked me a question two days ago that made me think about this: "If you could create your own line-up for Guns N' Roses keeping Axl Rose as the original remaining member of the 1987-1996 line-up... who would you pick for the line-up?"

Mine was this:

Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) - Vocals, Rhythm Guitar
Tim Skold (Marilyn Manson, KMFDM) - Lead Guitar
Christian O. Wolbers (Front Line Assembly, Fear Factory) - Lead Guitar
Robin Finck (Nine Inch Nails, Guns N' Roses) - Lead & Rhythm Guitar
Al Pitrelli (Suicidal Tendencies, Megadeth) - Lead & Rhythtm Guitar
Sean Yseult (White Zombie) - Bass
John Tempesta (White/Rob Zombie, Scum Of The Earth) - Drums
Dizzy Reed (Guns N' Roses) - Keyboards

you contradicted yourself. If Axl was the only remaining guy from 87-96, Dizzy shouldn't be in there

[Locomotive98]

Sorry but.....

Axl Rose? ?Vocals
Izzy Stradlin? ?Rythem Guitar
Duff Mckagen? ?Bass
Slash? ?Lead
Steven Adler? ?Drums

Same here...

Same again!!

[supaplex]

i'll play along

axl
ian scott (antrax) - guitar
dan donegan (disturbed) - guitar
dave grohl (foo fighters) - drums
jason newsted - bass

pianos and aditional guitars and effects you find someone

[gandra]

Axl - Lead Vocals
Robin - Lead Guitar
Ron Thal- Guitar
Richard Fortus- Guitar
Tommy- Bass
Brain- Drums
Dizzy- Keyboards
Chris Pitman- Synth

 

yes man,totally agree with you