CD and the Bad Reviews of European Shows

[G2N2R]

First off, don't even reply to that moronic child who keeps spamming on this thread.. no point, just fuels his stupidity..

Now to something important, the actual topic.. I've read more good reviews then bad, and I don't really care what some media outlet says about the show. We have plenty of people who are members of this site that attend the shows and I trust there judgement far more than that of some newswriter

I'd say that 90%+ have said the shows were really good, and the others who said they were bad had some biased against the band because they either were late to the show or because Slash isn't the one playing guitar.

[33]

Luckily in North America we don't care what the Spanish or anybody else thinks.

Lucky in north america (NOT AMERICA) only listen to trash like 50 cents and pseudohip-hop shit.


Now you are the ass of the world cocksucker, go away and start a new fucking war.


LONG LIFE TO BEN LADEN

Woah! How has this wanker not been banned? I dont like to be reading posts like that on a GnR board! Mike

[gandra]

Man i was in budapest show,and that was amazing show!!!
chemistry between members were great,axl was great,crowd was great,arena was full...
What the fuck you want!!!
Who cares for bad reviews some stupid journalist and people which didn't belong rnr

[holtzmn73]

all the bad reviews will be wash away in the time the CD is come.

Exactly, GNR got bad reviews on the UYI tour all the time, people don't look back and think those albums suck because some reviewer trashed them in a review.

[Disco Volante]

World politics/fashion views on a GNR forum.  Huh?

[.Seal]

Niko,

  Sorry, most of the reviews I've seen have been positive.  Alot of this can be attributed to the band's amazing chemistry, much better look than in '02, and Axl's amazingly good vocals and positive attitude.  I'm sorry, the current attitude we're seeing out of Axl wasn't there in '02.  The eye of the tiger is back!   

   

im talking about the media reviews

Just look @ the reviews from Hammersmith and come back..

[god of thunder]

Weren`t there already about 10 threads about this?

Anyways Guns got great reviews at least in Germany.....

[pilferk]

I've seen a pretty even split on the reviews. 

And I don't think they'll damage the cred of the band, much.  They got some bad reviews in the US press, too, during some of the UYI shows.  People have to remember that critics, largely, are snobby and/or artsy pricks.  My local paper has a "rock critic" who gives glowing reviews to Nickelback shows, but pans Ozzfest and Green Day.  And I think most people have had similar experiences.  I don't think they lend too much credence to the critics....

[Luigi]

I've seen a pretty even split on the reviews.

And I don't think they'll damage the cred of the band, much. They got some bad reviews in the US press, too, during some of the UYI shows. People have to remember that critics, largely, are snobby and/or artsy pricks. My local paper has a "rock critic" who gives glowing reviews to Nickelback shows, but pans Ozzfest and Green Day. And I think most people have had similar experiences. I don't think they lend too much credence to the critics....

That's why I hate the media. Got to see it for myself

[sjgotnitro]

Luckily in North America we don't care what the Spanish or anybody else thinks.

Lucky in north america (NOT AMERICA) only listen to trash like 50 cents and pseudohip-hop shit.


Now you are the ass of the world cocksucker, go away and start a new fucking war.

LONG LIFE TO BEN LADEN

I do not care if your kidding or not you can go fuck yourself asshole.? Anybody who sympanthizes with Laden is a vomit eating asshole regadless of what part of the world you are from.


PS I'm very sorry for replying to this but I just have to.

[oldgunsfan]

I haven't read any of the European reviews as they are in another language.....

all the reviews I've read were of the NYC shows which were generally very positive

[codenameninja]

delete this thread already, it's too negative. Look to the positive...[/b][/i][/size] 

...think Hammersmith/London/UK 
...think new GnR =  G o o D 

[Tyson]

To be honest, there really have been quite a few negative reviews.  You guys have to understand, the average person's perception of the band is going to be shaped through the media.  Most people will never either go to a GNR show or come to these forums, so if there is a negative review, that is all they will have to base their opinion on. 

[Shirell]

delete this thread already, it's too negative. Look to the positive...?
...think Hammersmith/London/UK?
...think new GnR =? G o o D?

Agreed. ?Who gives a shit was the hacks say. ?Its the fans that count at the end of the day. ?All at Hammersmith were rocking out! ?It was amazing.

[TrixAreForKids]

I have to agree. What is Axl waiting for? GnR's agenda is still unknown, and it appears that the European shows (according to the media) is mediocre at best.

Having said that, I think Axl's voice is better than in 2002. His appearance is not under a microscope, and he appears to be confident in his band.

I guess only time will tell.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

To be honest, there really have been quite a few negative reviews.? You guys have to understand, the average person's perception of the band is going to be shaped through the media.? Most people will never either go to a GNR show or come to these forums, so if there is a negative review, that is all they will have to base their opinion on.?

The negative reviews never talked about how the band sounded or how axl sounded they bitched about the time axl went on stage and bitched about slash nothing being in the band. Show me one bad review that talked about the band sounding or playing like shit. There are none, and if there are I m willing to bet that didnt even see the show. Some people have already been caughting writing reviews to shows they didnt even see

[2NaFish]

compared with how the media usually portray axl the reviews i've read have generally been great.

In the end any publicity is good, but good publicity, well, thats really good.

[pebbles]

Niko,

 ?Sorry, most of the reviews I've seen have been positive. ?Alot of this can be attributed to the band's amazing chemistry, much better look than in '02, and Axl's amazingly good vocals and positive attitude. ?I'm sorry, the current attitude we're seeing out of Axl wasn't there in '02. ?The eye of the tiger is back! ?

 ?

im talking about the media reviews

most people know the media sucks.

[nomandolphins]

nuthin can touch axl rose and thats a fact

[SWINGTRADER]

Attendance at these shows has been good  which means Reviews don't mean shit. When Reviews start hurting the band's ticket sells then we should worry.  These reviews mean nothing once the album is released and  most of the world doesn't read the shit on the internet anyway .