Use Your Illusion : The Fans Album - 1 Album Project.. Who is in?

[axls#2]

Well, this looks like its a thread about the existing songs on both albums, but I would have really liked to have seen a completely finished version of "Crash Diet". ?

1. ?Crash Diet
2. ?Civil War
3. ?You Could Be Mine
4. ?Coma
5. ?Don't Cry
6. ?Locomotive
7. ?Yesterdays
8. ?Estranged
9. ?Live and Let Die
10. Knockin On Heavens Door
11. November Rain
12. ?Dead Horse
13. ?Bad Obsession
14. ?Coma
15.  Don't Damn Me

[Eye Rool]

Here's my take

1. Perfect Crime
2. Bad Obsession
3. Back Off Bitch
4. November Rain
5. Bad Apples
6. Dead Horse
7. 14 Years
8. Knockin' On Heaven's Door
9. You Could Be Mine
10. Estranged

I think this album would be about an hour long; roughly the same length as AFD.? I tried to cut off as much of the fat as I could, and I know there are even some hits missing (i.e. Don't Cry and Live And Let Die), but you know the saying about making an omelette.

[Mobenrad]

I seriously believe there is no Use Your Illusion I without Coma. I seriously believe there is no Use Your Illusion 2 without Civil War.

[COMAMOTIVE]

First off, I think that KOHD and LALD have no business on a cumulative Use Your Illiusions album or in the current live set.

My Use Your Illusions album would be the following (including the song order):

1. Right Next Door To Hell
2. You Could Be Mine
3. Perfect Crime
4. Civil War
5. Don't Damn Me
6. November Rain
7. Breakdown
8. 14 Years
9. Don't Cry
10. Double Talkin Jive
11. Estranged
12. Coma

The problem with this exercise though, and always has been, as much as people say that the illusions have filler everyone has different ideas about what songs actually constitute the "filler".

I absolutely agree about LALD and KOHD - Boot em!

Secondly, why is everyone listing their " Dream Illusion Album " here? That is not what the original thread was trying to get from people

[badintentions]

oh shit, you're right!

BAD APPLES - 6/10

this is a cool idea.

[axls#2]

Here's my take

1. Perfect Crime
2. Bad Obsession
3. Back Off Bitch
4. November Rain
5. Bad Apples
6. Dead Horse
7. 14 Years
8. Knockin' On Heaven's Door
9. You Could Be Mine
10. Estranged

I think this album would be about an hour long; roughly the same length as AFD.? I tried to cut off as much of the fat as I could, and I know there are even some hits missing (i.e. Don't Cry and Live And Let Die), but you know the saying about making an omelette.

I know that it's all subjective, but I can't believe you left off "Civil War".   

[Eye Rool]

you're right COMAMOTIVE, my bad...anyway as far as Bad Apples goes 8/10

[Bostonrose]

Ok, Here is my UYI best of: (no particular order)

1.  Live and Let Die
2. Don't Cry
3. Nov. Rain
4.  Dead Horse
5. You Could Be Mine
6. Knockin on Heavens Door
7. Estranged
8. Breakdown
9. Locomotive
10. Coma

Man was that tough

[badintentions]

UYI should have been

1   Dust N' Bones   04:58
2   Civil War   07:42
3   14 Years   04:21
4   Breakdown   07:04
5   Locomotive   08:42
6   Estranged   09:23
7   You Could Be Mine   05:43
8   Don't Cry (Original)   04:44
9   November Rain   08:57
10   The Garden   05:22
11   Dead Horse   04:17
12   Coma   10:14

That is like the Worst of UYI.....  The Garden?  14 years? Dust N' Bones?

and I am sorry, but I am going on record and saying that Civil War is the most overrated GNR song

once again i will state that everyone has their own idea about what is "filler".....so where is your list there slugger?

[Bostonrose]

I seriously believe there is no Use Your Illusion I without Coma. I seriously believe there is no Use Your Illusion 2 without Civil War.

Can I just go on record and say that Civil War is the most overrated Guns N Roses song ever, perhaps in musical history...that song fucking blows....

[COMAMOTIVE]

UYI should have been

1   Dust N' Bones   04:58
2   Civil War   07:42
3   14 Years   04:21
4   Breakdown   07:04
5   Locomotive   08:42
6   Estranged   09:23
7   You Could Be Mine   05:43
8   Don't Cry (Original)   04:44
9   November Rain   08:57
10   The Garden   05:22
11   Dead Horse   04:17
12   Coma   10:14

I personally love his list with the exception of Dead Horse

[imsorry]

Back Off Bitch
Dont Damn Me
Perfect Crime
Locomotive
Dont Cry
Estranged
Coma
Double Talkin' Jive
Get In The Ring
You Could Be Mine
November Rain
Civil War

Dunno if its fits on cd size... 

[Eclipsed107]

Bad Apples - 4 / 10.

----
my list
----
1. You Could Be Mine (without that final drum ending)
2. Back Off Bitch
3. 14 Years
4. Coma (without that final drum ending)
5. Right Next Door to Hell
6. Yesterdays
7. November Rain
8. Garden of Eden
9. Don't Damn Me
10. Pretty Tied Up
11. Estranged
12. Don't Cry
13. Civil War

^^ That album flows so well.  It starts off strong, and ends even stronger.. I love it.  I don't think it's an AFD killer, but it's a great album none the less.

[Mobenrad]

Bad Apples - 4 / 10.

----
my list
----
1. You Could Be Mine (without that final drum ending)
2. Back Off Bitch
3. 14 Years
4. Coma (without that final drum ending)
5. Right Next Door to Hell
6. Yesterdays
7. November Rain
8. Garden of Eden
9. Don't Damn Me
10. Pretty Tied Up
11. Estranged
12. Don't Cry
13. Civil War

^^ That album flows so well.  It starts off strong, and ends even stronger.. I love it.  I don't think it's an AFD killer, but it's a great album none the less.

I agree. Civil War as the closer sounds great to me.

[zrose27]

heres mine

1. Get In The Ring
2. Civil War
3. Right Next Door To Hell
4. Perfect Crime
5. Shotgun Blues
6. Bad Obsession
7. Don't Damn Me
8.  Back Off Bitch
9. Garden Of Eden
10. Double Talkin Jive
11. Dead Horse
12. Dust In Bones
13. Coma
14. Locomotive
15. You Could Be Mine

Thats 78min. and the best UYI in IMO

[sahasastar]

oi!!! knobs!!.. the fans album.. kapiche!
The general consensus from hardcore fans of the best album.... remember.....

Now back to Bad Apples if you will....?

[Continental Drift]

Bad Apples (6/10) is a fun little song... but ultimately it ends up on the cutting room floor if you're really trying to come up with an album better than AFD.

Next track?

[KOK]

I have noticed a lot of people on here say that the Illusions were no-where near the
strength of Appetite.

They are wrong. Illusions are masterpieces just the way they are. Ok perhaps there are 5 or 6 weaker songs on there, but there is certainly more than 1 CD of Appetite(and better) quality songs on there.

[misterID]

1 Right Next Door To Hell
2 Live and Let Die
3 Don't Cry
4 Perfect Crime
5 Double Talkin Jive
6 November Rain
7 Garden Of Eden
8 Coma
9 Civil War
10 Yesterdays
11 Pretty Tied Up
12 Locomotive
13 You Could Be Mine
14 Knockin On Heavens Door
15 Estranged

That would have been a masterpiece

[The Dog]

heres mine

1. Get In The Ring
2. Civil War
3. Right Next Door To Hell
4. Perfect Crime
5. Shotgun Blues
6. Bad Obsession
7. Don't Damn Me
8.  Back Off Bitch
9. Garden Of Eden
10. Double Talkin Jive
11. Dead Horse
12. Dust In Bones
13. Coma
14. Locomotive
15. You Could Be Mine

Thats 78min. and the best UYI in IMO

with the exception of 3 or 4 songs on there, thats a list of songs that SHOULDN'T be on a best of UYI right??     Shotgun Blues?  You're joking right?