The Third Guitarist Question (should Buckethead rejoin or maybe even Slash?)

[dangnr]

Brian May perhaps

[dangnr]

How would everyone feel if Brian May from Queen ended up the guitarist?
or Zack Wylde? both of them did some guitar work?
i just wanna get the feel of peoples opinion

[BLS-Pride]

No. Zakk Wylde makes kick ass mother fuckin smash mouth metal and I enjoy it. And From What Zakk said about Axl on tour.. That won't happen.

And Brian May is Queen.. I can't see it, and personally do not want too.

[Axl8302]

may is a great guitarist but i think that the fact he was in queen would be weird for gn'r, like he wouldn't fit in or something..zakk would be good.

[DunkinDave]

Brian May is still in Queen - they are touring right now.

[Hoosier]

i think whatever decison they have made it has been done. surley they wouldnt schedule these concerts without a 3rd guitarist. os if they have decided to keep Finck and Fortus, they must be ready.

Batio is NOT all speed and no "emotion" he can actualy play pretty well. he just chooses not to most of the time and would rather wank off with his speed licks. im going to beleive you guys who say its just BS about him being in the band and i really hope it is. like i said, hes a good player but he is NOT for GNR. BOOOOOOOOOOO Batio!! fuck off! and fuck your crappy Tradition guitars!

[dangnr]

but Brian May did do guitar work with Axl and soo did Zack
Personally I think either of them are awsome, but id rather Zack hed fit in perfect, prolly the best possible guy to fill the job except for maybe IZZY STRADLIN or SLASH

[Timmy]

He'd be a fine addition to the band!

[BLS-Pride]

Zakk doesn't fit the new GnR sound.. Perfect? You are not a Zakk fan eh? Cause his style DOES NOT fit GnR's new direction.. It didn't really fit their own sound.

[boston]

since we are gonna all the sudden think that any guitarist that Axl ever thought of trying out is suddenly back in the band,

why not go with the Bands first choice, way back in '91

Navaro should have replaced Izzy in the first place, he was AXL's first choice, Navaro admits in his new book that the only reason he didn't join was being the guiatrist for an alternative band like 'janes addiction' , he thought people would label him a sellout,
years later he still took part in recording OH MY GOD, and he is currettly doing nothing.......


DAVE NAVARO should join GNR now !!!!

[McDuff]

Well I don't know if he would join,but who knows

[Loaded NightraiN]

Well I don't know if he would join,but who knows

He's pretty rock n' roll.. plus alot more ppl would accept him over a guy with a bucket on his dome(not me tho)

[boston]

Well I don't know if he would join,but who knows

He's pretty rock n' roll.. plus alot more ppl would accept him over a guy with a bucket on his dome(not me tho)

the girls do seem to love Dave

and he can fuckin play guitar with the best of 'em ( janes addiction - nothings shocking - anyone)

[oneway23]

Great guitarist, but he's never really done much for me outside the magic of JA

[The Dog]

Navaro should have replaced Izzy in the first place, he was AXL's first choice, Navaro admits in his new book that the only reason he didn't join was being the guiatrist for an alternative band like 'janes addiction' , he thought people would label him a sellout,

hes right, they would have.  I think he would have wanted more of a spot light too - and while Izzy is loved by most GNR fans, its Slash's guitar playing that stands out.  i dont think those two egos would have survived.

As for now, yeah it'd be cool if he was in the band.  i think hes pretty well liked by most people, hes got a hot wife and he is def 'rock n roll' as someone else said.  Be nice to have someone else take some of the attention off axl as well.

[Axl4Prez2004]

Navaro did some time on that INXS tv show, which would draw in a couple extra fans...plus the Carmen Electra connection helps with free publicity. ?I still think Axl, Tommy, Robin, and Richard will figure it out. ?We're in for some good times.
 

[Kaybee]

and he is currettly doing nothing.......

....besides Camen Electra ?

[boston]

and he is currettly doing nothing.......

....besides Camen Electra?

[oneway23]

Brian May was a very innovative guitarist in his day, but I think the generation gap is a bit much...He's too busy trading machismo with Paul Rodgers nowadays anyhow

[Shoeboy]

He was worried about people labeling him a sellout, now he's a fucking gameshow host. Go figure.

I think bringing Dave back to play with Robin would almost be duplication.  The balance with Bucket was Bucket's ludicrous speed.  Dave's no shredder. He and Robin are bouth melodic players.

But I'll pose the question again; why do there have to be three guitarists?