Who else would like to hear Axl Sing Slither ??

[Krispy Kreme]

I think it would be great if Axl sang Slither. I also think it would be great if he sang Big Machine and Sucker Train Blues. In fact, it would rock if the new GNR did a cover of the VR set list from 2005!!

[mrlee]

I wouldn't.

All the new GN'R songs (the live ones and the leaked demos) are better than that VR song.

highly disagree.

i can barely remember them and id listened to them a number of times so they didnt really stick in my mind so they wernt that good.

[-Jack-]

Who eles wants this topic in dead horse?

[judgesmf]

Who eles wants this topic in dead horse?

Silence is Golden!!!

[Steel_Angel]

IMHO axl would make the song sound a lot better 

[HungerForChaos]

I wouldn't.

All the new GN'R songs (the live ones and the leaked demos) are better than that VR song.

highly disagree.

i can barely remember them and id listened to them a number of times so they didnt really stick in my mind so they wernt that good.

Yeah drugs can do that to a brain... But seriously I have to laugh at that..

[AxlsMainMan]

i'd like to see Axl replace scott, stinson replace duff, fink/fortus replace Slash and that other jackass, brain can replace matt sorum, then lets throw dizzy in there..... then replace the music of slither with a better song like TWAT........... yeah that would be cool.

And then, what will you do with Pittman??

Oh, there's always room for Pittman as long as Axl is ridin' his Suburban..

But, anways..

If Axl were to cover any VR songs Id want to hear Superhuman or You Got No Right more than any of the others.

And to whoever said Fall to Pieces is "brilliant", well, the majority of the guitarwork is very reminiscent of Sweet Child O' Mines' main riff, so it's no real wonder..

[Negleyjj]

I think it'd be cool to hear GNR do a VR song, but don't hold your breath.

I'm not big on Slither, it's a good song and all, but I'd much prefer Fall to Pieces or You Got No Right (by far the best song on the album in my opinion).

[darkmonth]

Since Weiland fucked up in commenting guns n roses. I despise everything labeled VR.
This is a guns n roses forum.
Velvet Revolver is lightyears from gnr.

conclusion: no Slither.

Wow... what a very narrowminded and small minded view ...

[KeVoRkIaN]

DEAD HORSE
I'd rather hear Axl sing My Favorite Pillow

[Origen]

Since Weiland fucked up in commenting guns n roses. I despise everything labeled VR.
This is a guns n roses forum.
Velvet Revolver is lightyears from gnr.

conclusion: no Slither.

Wow... what a very narrowminded and small minded view ...

That's one way of putting it or you could just call him a wanker.


Would Axl sound as good as Weiland singing a STP song? No, does Scott sound as good as Axl singing a GnR song? No. People suit there own songs that they write.

And this has been discussed before and to the topic creator since you dissed Scott in your post I'm guessing you posted this to be awkward instead of debating it.

[jimb0]

I hate old GN'R Haters.  There would be no current Gn'R Without the origional Gn'R

[Steel_Angel]

Is there such thing as an old gnr hater?

[Origen]

Is there such thing as an old gnr hater?

Yes.

[younggunner]

I hate old GN'R Haters.  There would be no current Gn'R Without the origional Gn'R

agreed

but i hate people who think this band cant be successful because its not the old band.

[Steel_Angel]

Is there such thing as an old gnr hater?

Yes.

What kind of a sick world do we live in 

[TOPGUNner]

I couldn't picture Axl singing any VR songs, nor would i want him to do so. I think Scott does an excellent job when he covers Guns and Roses "It's so Easy", "Used to Love Her", and "Mr. Brownstone." But then again, those aren't songs where you need an "axl" voice. For instance, i would never want Scott to cover November Rain or Estranged

[GNRkid]

Eh, doesn't seem like Axl's shindig

[CocaineTongue22]

....However, Weiland did "belt out" It's So Easy at a bar in NY or whatever the story was without VR.

So, I think it would be funny to watch Ax play around with an STP classic like Plush or Interstate Love Song. Friendly fun, and nobody gets hurt except for a fragile ego or two.

[troccoli]

IMHO, Contraband is a good album.  As good as AFD or the UYI albums?  Course not.  But it is a good rock album - much better than a ton of the shit being released today.  Personally I wouldn't mind Axl singing Fall to Pieces.  However, I think it would be AWESOME to hear him sing Neither Can I.  That song, to me, sounds like it would have fit right in with the UYI albums, along with some other Snakepit tunes.  Just my 2 cents.