Former Guns n' Roses manager Alan Niven speaks!

[Sukie]

interesting - I wonder why after all this time, he chosse to get involved in this??

I agree entirely regarding his words relating to thr original Guns - one of the greats for sure...
Scott statements are a little harsh... the plot thickens ?

I was wondering the same thing myself.  He's no longer affiliated with the band.  Is this statement for attention?  To get in Axl's good graces?   

[misterID]

Metal sludge?

it's actually true.

How do you know its true? MS has lied before and posted fake interviews. And why would he take shots at his 'friends' band, even if he hated Scott? It makes no sense. Sounds like the writing of just another old line up fan boy to me.

Its not an interview man, it was an email Alan sent to Sludge.

I didn't say it was an interview, I'm telling you about MS past. Remember when they posted the letter sent in by Earl?

You really think Alan Niven just out of the blue gets a wild hair up his ass to write a letter like this to some cumsponge site like metalsludge?

[da_pope]

Name one fuckin thing Josh Todd has ever done.

I don't fucking care what Scotts done... Josh is the better singer by leaps and bounds. Scott is like any Post-Gruge, Alternitive singer. Josh has that unique tone to him.

"Stupid Bitch" yeah thats a real winner of a song, Buckcherry are soooooo fuckin lame seriously.
Scott's worst song is better than that piece of garbage.

First off, it's called "Crazy Bitch". Secondly, that song is better then any Stone Temple Pilots song I have heard.

[chineseblues]

Metal sludge?

it's actually true.

How do you know its true? MS has lied before and posted fake interviews. And why would he take shots at his 'friends' band, even if he hated Scott? It makes no sense. Sounds like the writing of just another old line up fan boy to me.

Its not an interview man, it was an email Alan sent to Sludge.

I didn't say it was an interview, I'm telling you about MS past. Remember when they posted the letter sent in by Earl?

You really think Alan Niven just out of the blue gets a wild hair up his ass to write a letter like this to some cumsponge site like metalsludge?

Im pretty sure Alan has something to do With Stevie Rachelle the owner of metal sludge.

[the dirt]

Please for the love of all that is holy, lets not turn this into another rip Scott thread.

Or a rip Josh Todd thread..

But you can show the toddster some love if you so desire.

Niven, ah, it's been so long since he's been involved with Axl.

[Sukie]

Let's keep this on topic, guys and gals. ?This is the GN'R section so the posts should be GN'R related...not who is/would have been the better frontman for VR. ?

[da_pope]

Let's keep this on topic, guys and gals. ?This is the GN'R section so the posts should be GN'R related...not who is/would have been the better frontman for VR. ?

Sorry... Josh should have fronted Guns.
 

[Sukie]

Let's keep this on topic, guys and gals. ?This is the GN'R section so the posts should be GN'R related...not who is/would have been the better frontman for VR. ?

Sorry... Josh should have fronted Guns.
 

   Pretty funny!  But stay on topic!   

[misterID]

If this letter is true, Slash shouldn't have anything to do with him; he is a complete tool and has made Slash look bad in the process. With friends like that who needs and enema?

But that doesn't matter because the letter has FAKE written all over it to me.

[D]

Crazy Bitch is better than anything STP has ever done?

Dude u need to stop suckin on that crack pipe honestly.


Ok on topic

I think Alan NIven is seeing dollar signs and wants to be involved in a GNR reunion so maybe he can get a piece of the pie.
money usually is what drives parasites like this guy.

[Minneapolisnewsman]

Alan managed Izzy, when Izzy left GNR.  I also know he likes the new demo leaks

[chineseblues]

Crazy Bitch is better than anything STP has ever done?

Dude u need to stop suckin on that crack pipe honestly.


Ok on topic

I think Alan NIven is seeing dollar signs and wants to be involved in a GNR reunion so maybe he can get a piece of the pie.
money usually is what drives parasites like this guy.

so because he disses scott he is a parasite? 

[da_pope]

so because he disses scott he is a parasite??

 
I don't this dude should get involved... It's obviously some kind of ploy for attention. The guy hasn't had anything to do with Guns for a long ass time.

[misterID]

Crazy Bitch is better than anything STP has ever done?

Dude u need to stop suckin on that crack pipe honestly.


Ok on topic

I think Alan NIven is seeing dollar signs and wants to be involved in a GNR reunion so maybe he can get a piece of the pie.
money usually is what drives parasites like this guy.

so because he disses scott he is a parasite?

D is right. Slamming the band of someone who's supposed to be your friend and trying to stir shit up and cause problems within that band because you can't stop living in the past, and you want to see a band reunite that will never reunite, for your own pathetic reasons ?= Parasite

[Goddamn_Electric]

He better write the majority of the lyrics and melodies... Thats what a singer is suppose to fucking do. I don't get why he's trying to make it look like Axl preformed some great duty. Scott is a fucking homo though... I love Velvet but they should have gone with Buckcherry's singer.

Scott Weiland shits all over Sebastian Bach.

Incorrect.  Slave to the Grind is one of the greatest rock albums ever, whereas Weiland hasnt been involved in an album thats in the top 1,000,000,000 albums ever.

[D]

A parasite is someone who lives off someone else.

Band managers dont record albums, they dont do concerts, they dont make any money, they ?parasite and suck their cash out of their clients.

Niven probably thinks he can do like Motley Crue'smanager has done, get the band back together and make a couple more million for himself.

why else would he say the things he is saying?

[D]

He better write the majority of the lyrics and melodies... Thats what a singer is suppose to fucking do. I don't get why he's trying to make it look like Axl preformed some great duty. Scott is a fucking homo though... I love Velvet but they should have gone with Buckcherry's singer.

Scott Weiland shits all over Sebastian Bach.

Incorrect.? Slave to the Grind is one of the greatest rock albums ever, whereas Weiland hasnt been involved in an album thats in the top 1,000,000,000 albums ever.

Im guessin u have never heard of Core or Purple.  also how many songs did Bach write on Slave to the grind?

he cowrote what 2 or 3?

Great frontman has to do better than that unless u want slash and duff writing the lyrics, and i for one dont want that.

[chineseblues]

He probably wants to set the record straight aboutwhat Scott said about Axl not writing lyrics or melodies. He knows Axl doesn't want to have anything to do with him as far as managing the band.

[metallex78]

Name one fuckin thing Josh Todd has ever done.

I don't fucking care what Scotts done... Josh is the better singer by leaps and bounds. Scott is like any Post-Gruge, Alternitive singer. Josh has that unique tone to him.

Josh sounds like a wannabe Axl Rose, there's nothing unique about him.

[D]

He probably wants to set the record straight aboutwhat Scott said about Axl not writing lyrics or melodies. He knows Axl doesn't want to have anything to do with him as far as managing the band.

thats fine but to turn around and act like Scott didnt write his own lyrics and melodies makes him look like a bigger idiot than scott.