Downer

[oldgunsfan]

from the 10 songs I've heard I'd agree w/ this person

but I also liked the leaked tracks
imagine how I felt before them

[Mikkamakka]

It's interesting... if a critic says the Nu-GN'R songs are great, than he is a model professional, who knows what good music is. If a critic says the new songs are mediocre (or suck) then he's a fuckin' loser, who hasn't even heard the songs, he's a hater, I-dont-care-what-he-says. People are strange. 


Grow up.

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

what i was tryin to say at the beginning of this thread is that theses so called journalists DONT DO THERE JOB PROPERLY.for example

a. they dont do any research
b. when they do they get their info of the internet
c. they dont explain why they dont like these songs

lets say this was the article
http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/3792/artcle2pf.png

that would of been more proffesional and not like they wouldnt like the songs if they were fukin awsome anyway.their just out to do harm coz they dont like axls way of things.

[ppbebe]

MR W,AXL ROSE you're right but do people still take those pseudo journalists seriously? 

if a critic says the Nu-GN'R songs are great, than he is a model professional, who knows what good music is. If a critic says the new songs are mediocre (or suck) then he's a fuckin' loser, who hasn't even heard the songs, he's a hater, I-dont-care-what-he-says.

I'm afraid the idea will become general.
The world of music critics as well as the music scene needs new blood. Or no one will buy what they say.
Where things have been stagnant for long, there will be a time for the old to give way to the new.
Mark my words.

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

MR W,AXL ROSE you're right but do people still take those pseudo journalists seriously??

if a critic says the Nu-GN'R songs are great, than he is a model professional, who knows what good music is. If a critic says the new songs are mediocre (or suck) then he's a fuckin' loser, who hasn't even heard the songs, he's a hater, I-dont-care-what-he-says.

I'm afraid the idea will become general.
The world of music critics as well as the music scene needs new blood. Or no one will buy what they say.
Where things have been stagnant for long, there will be a time for the old to give way to the new.
Mark my words.

maybe poeple dont take them seriously but does that give them a right to print what i can only describe as bad journalism.its poeple like these that bury good music and promote such crap in an industry that just puts out anything these days,hence all these wanna be shows that clog up the mainstream tv nowadays

[oldgunsfan]

It's interesting... if a critic says the Nu-GN'R songs are great, than he is a model professional, who knows what good music is. If a critic says the new songs are mediocre (or suck) then he's a fuckin' loser, who hasn't even heard the songs, he's a hater, I-dont-care-what-he-says. People are strange.?

Grow up.

there's alot of that here, I find it quite amusing

[oldgunsfan]

what i was tryin to say at the beginning of this thread is that theses so called journalists DONT DO THERE JOB PROPERLY.for example

a. they dont do any research
b. when they do they get their info of the internet
c. they dont explain why they dont like these songs

lets say this was the article
http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/3792/artcle2pf.png

that would of been more proffesional and not like they wouldnt like the songs if they were fukin awsome anyway.their just out to do harm coz they dont like axls way of things.

a. what research do you have to do to listen to a song
b. where else is the leaked tracks available
c. why do they have to explain why they don't like something

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

what i was tryin to say at the beginning of this thread is that theses so called journalists DONT DO THERE JOB PROPERLY.for example

a. they dont do any research
b. when they do they get their info of the internet
c. they dont explain why they dont like these songs

lets say this was the article
http://img127.imageshack.us/img127/3792/artcle2pf.png

that would of been more proffesional and not like they wouldnt like the songs if they were fukin awsome anyway.their just out to do harm coz they dont like axls way of things.

a. what research do you have to do to listen to a song
b. where else is the leaked tracks available
c. why do they have to explain why they don't like something

A.they didnt explain that although the songs only just leaked,they might be up to 6 years old
B.i wasnt just talkin bout this article.any article in these mags is usually internet tripe all mashed up
C.because explaining why they dont like the songs would justify what they say about the song.they couldnt explain why they didnt like the songs because they would of had to say "there demos,there not definetly on the album"and that would have made them look stupid.

[oldgunsfan]

so if I think, for example,  the blues (I know it wasn't leaked) sucks balls, you'd want to know I think Axl's voice  reminds me of someone scratching their nails down a chalkboard for 6 minutes straight, and it plain hurts my ears to listen to it

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

are you sayin that its gonna be on the album and are you gonna publish it for others to read

[CAFC Nick]

so if I think, for example,? the blues (I know it wasn't leaked) sucks balls, you'd want to know I think Axl's voice? reminds me of someone scratching their nails down a chalkboard for 6 minutes straight, and it plain hurts my ears to listen to it

I suppose. Everyone has their opinions and peoples views and opinions change over time. If you were an adult when AFD came out etc then you might find it hard to accept the new way GNR has come. I wasn't even born when AFD came out so I can actually accept the new GNR.

[oldgunsfan]

I could care less what on-line journalists think of the leaks
the only opinion that matters to me is mine
most of my freinds hate Axl, mock me, and rip on him all the time

[oldgunsfan]

so if I think, for example,? the blues (I know it wasn't leaked) sucks balls, you'd want to know I think Axl's voice? reminds me of someone scratching their nails down a chalkboard for 6 minutes straight, and it plain hurts my ears to listen to it

I suppose. Everyone has their opinions and peoples views and opinions change over time. If you were an adult when AFD came out etc then you might find it hard to accept the new way GNR has come. I wasn't even born when AFD came out so I can actually accept the new GNR.

I was 14-15 when AFD came out
18 when the Illusions came out

Going on 33 now and Chinese Democracy still hasn't come out

And I never thought it possible in my wildest dreams, and I do have some wild ones , that I'd be in my early to mid 30's before I heard new music from GnR, who was my favorite band up till 12/6/2002

Since than Zeppelin, VR, and some of Ozzy's earlier solo work(think Randy Rhoades era)  has replaced them

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

all im sayin is if your gonna publish a comment like they did then you should explain that although you dont like the songs,they are only demos at the end of the day.poeple who read the article could make up their minds wheter they like the album on the facts in the article.pre-concieced view i think the word is.

[oldgunsfan]

they did say they were leaked tracks, thats all we know about them.  they could be finished demos for all we know.  do you know when they were recorded?  they could have been done any time over the last 15 years

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

exactly.they made out that these songs are ready for the album hence the comment about waiting longer to finish the album.thats what got up my nose.

id say these songs were no more than 6 years old except maybe CITR.

[oldgunsfan]

exactly.they made out that these songs are ready for the album hence the comment about waiting longer to finish the album.thats what got up my nose.

id say these songs were no more than 6 years old except maybe CITR.

what this person said was "on the evidence of the tracks leaked on the web"

thats exactly what they are

[Sparksry]

I dont see why people dont like the tracks leaked there incredible..... but i think themagazine should stop harassing ax and just friken listen to the leaks again

[oldgunsfan]

think of a band you don't like, and I'm sure their fans would say the same about you

[Sparksry]

ya ur right w/e i was talking about GNR fans srry