What do you guys think?

[SWINGTRADER]

do you guys think these albums are better than AFD???  Be objective



1) Heaven And Hell....Black Sabbath
2) The Mob Rules....Black Sabbath
3) Born Again....Black Sabbath
4) Creatures Of The Night...KISS
5) Lick It Up....KISS
6) Revenge...KISS
7) Holy Diver....Dio
The Last In Line....Dio
9) Dream Evil....Dio
10) Menance to Society....Lizzy Borden
11) 5150....Van Halen
12) OU812....Van Halen
13) F.U.C.K....Van Halen
14) Eat Em And Smile...DLR
15) The Last Command....WASP
16) The Crimson Idol....WASP
17) Pyromania...Def Leppard
18) Tooth And Nail....Dokken
19) Back For The Attack....Dokken
20) Reign in Blood....Slayer
21) South of Heaven....Slayer
22) Invasion Of Your Privacy....Ratt
23) Operation Mindcrime....Queensryche
24) Empire....Queensryche
25) You Can't Stop Rock N Roll....Twisted Sister
26) Stay Hungry....Twisted Sister
27) Metal Health....Quiet Riot
28) Number Of The Beast....Iron Maiden
29) Piece Of Mind....Iron Maiden
30) Seventh Son....Iron Maiden
31) Somewhere in Time....Iron Maiden
32) Screaming for Vengence....Judas Priest
33) Defenders Of The Faith....Judas Priest
34) Ram It Down....Judas Priest
35) Painkiller....Judas Priest
36) Trashed....Alice Cooper
37) The Last Temptation....Alice Cooper
38) Spreading the Disease....Anthrax
39) Persistence Of Time....Anthrax
40) Armored Saint...March Of The Saint
41) Ride The Lightning....Metallica
42) Kill Em All....Metallica
43) Master Of Puppets....Metallica
44) Killins My Business....Megadeth
45) Peace Sells....Megadeth
46)Rust in Peace....Megadeth
47) Stormrider...Iced Earth
48) Cocked & Loaded....LA Guns
49) Skid Row....Skid Row
50) Slave to The Grind....Skid Row


Some guy at Metalsludge posted these albums as being better.  He's calling anybody that disagrees with him a GNR nutswinger.     I think this list is a joke   what do you guys think??
 

[FlashFlood]

april fools?
<checks date>

nope just a moron

[Christos AG]

Well, he probably has something AGAINST GN'R if he only posts albums to prove they're better than AFD.

I guess it depends on your taste. Some people would find a lot of these albums better than AFD and some would disagree...

You can never be objective when it comes to music.

[FlashFlood]

taste? come on...THREE DIO ALBUMS IN A ROW

nuff said.

[Skeletor]

what do you guys think??

I'm sure most people here think all those albums are better than AFD Come on...

[art vandalay]

van halen F.U.C.K i havent heard of that one

[Christos AG]

taste? come on...THREE DIO ALBUMS IN A ROW

nuff said.

I like Dio. And your post proves my point about taste... In the worst way...

[FlashFlood]

well, your taste is wrong

[avesia]

well, some of these albums are really good, but can't compare them to GnR because I might be a little ...ok, maybe more ...subjective

[Christos AG]

well, your taste is wrong

Well, I love Guns N' Roses... 

[Thorazine Shuffle]

van halen F.U.C.K i havent heard of that one

For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge.

[Sparksry]

I havent herd of that one either .... Then again im not that big of a van halen fan .

[oldgunsfan]

do you guys think these albums are better than AFD? Be objective



1) Heaven And Hell....Black Sabbath
2) The Mob Rules....Black Sabbath
3) Born Again....Black Sabbath
4) Creatures Of The Night...KISS
5) Lick It Up....KISS
6) Revenge...KISS
7) Holy Diver....Dio
The Last In Line....Dio
9) Dream Evil....Dio
10) Menance to Society....Lizzy Borden
11) 5150....Van Halen
12) OU812....Van Halen
13) F.U.C.K....Van Halen
14) Eat Em And Smile...DLR
15) The Last Command....WASP
16) The Crimson Idol....WASP
17) Pyromania...Def Leppard
18) Tooth And Nail....Dokken
19) Back For The Attack....Dokken
20) Reign in Blood....Slayer
21) South of Heaven....Slayer
22) Invasion Of Your Privacy....Ratt
23) Operation Mindcrime....Queensryche
24) Empire....Queensryche
25) You Can't Stop Rock N Roll....Twisted Sister
26) Stay Hungry....Twisted Sister
27) Metal Health....Quiet Riot
28) Number Of The Beast....Iron Maiden
29) Piece Of Mind....Iron Maiden
30) Seventh Son....Iron Maiden
31) Somewhere in Time....Iron Maiden
32) Screaming for Vengence....Judas Priest
33) Defenders Of The Faith....Judas Priest
34) Ram It Down....Judas Priest
35) Painkiller....Judas Priest
36) Trashed....Alice Cooper
37) The Last Temptation....Alice Cooper
38) Spreading the Disease....Anthrax
39) Persistence Of Time....Anthrax
40) Armored Saint...March Of The Saint
41) Ride The Lightning....Metallica
42) Kill Em All....Metallica
43) Master Of Puppets....Metallica
44) Killins My Business....Megadeth
45) Peace Sells....Megadeth
46)Rust in Peace....Megadeth
47) Stormrider...Iced Earth
48) Cocked & Loaded....LA Guns
49) Skid Row....Skid Row
50) Slave to The Grind....Skid Row


Some guy at Metalsludge posted these albums as being better.? He's calling anybody that disagrees with him a GNR nutswinger.? ? ?I think this list is a joke? ?what do you guys think??
 

personally, i dont think any of these come close to AFD; some I think you can make a better argument for are:
Blizzard of Ozz
Led Zeppelin IV
Houses of the Holy
Tribute-Ozzy

[Sparksry]

I like them all but they dont compae in my opinion

[FlashFlood]

well, your taste is wrong

Well, I love Guns N' Roses... 

rock on bro! 

[St_Jimmyuk]

youve listed some very great albums there but gnr are different from those sorts of music

gnr is my fav band has been for a great number of years and will be for a very long time but i love iron maiden as well and metallica are great you can't compare those sorts of albums they all have their unique touches id listen to all of them endless times and never get bored but im not going to say they are better than AFD and im also not going to say AFD is better than them (if it is, not by much) they are equal in my minds i say AFD is at the top along with (or very closely followed by) NOTB - Iron Maiden and MP - metallica

[McDuff]

there is no album better than AFD,well the equal would be AC/DC's Back In Black,well for me anyway 

[Backslash]

None of those albums...

Some albums are better, though they're not necessarily metal (I'm assuming that since it's metalsludge, the guy wants metal albums listed, but who cares)

Michael Jackson's Thriller is better than AFD
So are Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, Abbey Road, Rubber Soul, and The Beatles by The Beatles.
Led Zeppelin's untitled album is better than AFD.
I really like Jethro Tull's Aqualung and The Eagles' Hotel California.  I'd probably rank those above AFD.
If I think, I'll probably come up with more

Those that are probably equal to AFD?
Metallica by Metallica
Back in Black by AC/DC
Operation: Mindcrime by Queensryche
Purple Rain by Prince

But yeah, the guy from metalsludge is pretty much an idiot... how can a post-Ozzy Sabbath come close to AFD??? seriously.  I like almost each of those albums, but none of them kicked the music industry's ass like AFD.

[Throatrake]

The only albums that come close on that list are;
Rust In Peace
Master Of Puppets.

[Axlfreek]

do you guys think these albums are better than AFD? Be objective



1) Heaven And Hell....Black Sabbath
2) The Mob Rules....Black Sabbath
3) Born Again....Black Sabbath
4) Creatures Of The Night...KISS
5) Lick It Up....KISS
6) Revenge...KISS
7) Holy Diver....Dio
The Last In Line....Dio
9) Dream Evil....Dio
10) Menance to Society....Lizzy Borden
11) 5150....Van Halen
12) OU812....Van Halen
13) F.U.C.K....Van Halen
14) Eat Em And Smile...DLR
15) The Last Command....WASP
16) The Crimson Idol....WASP
17) Pyromania...Def Leppard
18) Tooth And Nail....Dokken
19) Back For The Attack....Dokken
20) Reign in Blood....Slayer
21) South of Heaven....Slayer
22) Invasion Of Your Privacy....Ratt
23) Operation Mindcrime....Queensryche
24) Empire....Queensryche
25) You Can't Stop Rock N Roll....Twisted Sister
26) Stay Hungry....Twisted Sister
27) Metal Health....Quiet Riot
28) Number Of The Beast....Iron Maiden
29) Piece Of Mind....Iron Maiden
30) Seventh Son....Iron Maiden
31) Somewhere in Time....Iron Maiden
32) Screaming for Vengence....Judas Priest
33) Defenders Of The Faith....Judas Priest
34) Ram It Down....Judas Priest
35) Painkiller....Judas Priest
36) Trashed....Alice Cooper
37) The Last Temptation....Alice Cooper
38) Spreading the Disease....Anthrax
39) Persistence Of Time....Anthrax
40) Armored Saint...March Of The Saint
41) Ride The Lightning....Metallica
42) Kill Em All....Metallica
43) Master Of Puppets....Metallica
44) Killins My Business....Megadeth
45) Peace Sells....Megadeth
46)Rust in Peace....Megadeth
47) Stormrider...Iced Earth
48) Cocked & Loaded....LA Guns
49) Skid Row....Skid Row
50) Slave to The Grind....Skid Row


Some guy at Metalsludge posted these albums as being better.? He's calling anybody that disagrees with him a GNR nutswinger.? ? ?I think this list is a joke? ?what do you guys think??
 

where the FUCK is led zeppelin in this ridiculous list ?