I.R.S. lnstrumental discussion (NO LINKS, REQUESTS

[oneway23]

If, by some chance, the source of the Trunk CD leak is identical to the source of the newer leaks, why intentionally remove Prostitute and replace it with Better?  I would imagine the Trunk CD, including prostitute, would have been presented, followed by Better...I don't see the logic in substituting a song

i think management was really worried about prostitute... so not releasing it again might have been a concession made to management, an attempt to not REALLY piss them off. hence, replace prostitute with a similar song that won't anger axl/merck AS much...

just my thoughts.

If we follow through with your theory, it could be entirely possible that Prostitute was/is being slated as the lead off single, hence 
the guarded attitude.  The  point of dissension I have with this is that, if anything, I would imagine TWAT being held in that regard, considering it's long been thought of as one of the "big guns" and is obviously a very personal song to Axl, which is not to say that Prostitute isn't.

[Dr. Blutarsky]

i dont want a link or a discussion concerning an IRS Instrumental. La la la la la la la la la la.....................

do I pass the test??

[killingvector]

It is neither from the trunk CD  nor from the trunk himself, if I told you I would have to kill you

I see lawsuits are trying to start...  LOL


Gunsguy

P.S> YES there are newier songs that you have not heard, "Soon" is the word folks!

There were rumors of an unauthorized internal leak. I guess I would not be out of line saying that this rumor was looking closer to becoming fact.

[Sukie]

C'mon guys.? Promotion wheels are a spinnin away.? CITR was placed into a board member's hands by none other than Sanctuary.


Do you really believe that German girl story??


We'll get TWAT instrumental next...........then when we think the leaks have finished...........

BAM!!!!!? Another new song is eh-hmm...........leaked?!?

Who says that Sanctuary gave CITR to a board member? ?How do you know this is true? ?I'm off topic, and I'm a mod...
but I'm curious. ?

On topic...haven't heard any of the instrumentals. ?

[leesixxrose]

Because I aquired it not from trunk, my sources will never be reveiled, however I can tell you they are NOT FROM TRUNK, you must believe this, you have to understand that this is delicate, and timed to perfection


Gunsguy

your full of shit.... you didnt leak anything.. stop trying to take credit for something you didnt have jack squat to do with...

[Steel_Angel]

even tho its an instrumental we still cant post links to it?

[Sukie]

Nope.  No links.   

[Z]

Who says that Sanctuary gave CITR to a board member? ?How do you know this is true? ?I'm off topic, and I'm a mod...
but I'm curious. ?

On topic...haven't heard any of the instrumentals. ?

The board member will be more than happy to share his story once the "leak drama" is over and Chinese Democracy drops.


There is a plan to get this cd talked about prior to its release and it has worked wonders so far. ?Rolling Stones even wrote about the demos.


The GNR VR fued will also work wonders.


There's some definate talent in Sanctuary as far as I'm concerned.


Gunsguy is probably another Sanctuary contact. ?I'm guessing each contact has no idea who the other one is.

[Sukie]

I'm skeptical of all these leak theories. 

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Because I aquired it not from trunk, my sources will never be reveiled, however I can tell you they are NOT FROM TRUNK, you must believe this, you have to understand that this is delicate, and timed to perfection


Gunsguy

your full of shit.... you didnt leak anything.. stop trying to take credit for something you didnt have jack squat to do with...

Havent you learned your lesson, why call him names when he might actually be a leaker, yeah real smart give the guy a reason to hold the tracks back. People like you never learn. Just shut up and if you think he is full of shit, keep it to yourself, people like you are the reason that it took IRS so long to come out with the clean version

[saint seiya]

gunsguy knows as much as me. only track left is TWAT instrumental. he does not have anything else nor will anything else get leaked.

[oneway23]

Let it be shown

[killingvector]

gunsguy knows as much as me. only track left is TWAT instrumental. he does not have anything else nor will anything else get leaked.

if true, I really believe it fuels the Trunk CD theory. Another full unheard track would of course supprt gunsguy.

[kyrie]

Because I aquired it not from trunk, my sources will never be reveiled, however I can tell you they are NOT FROM TRUNK, you must believe this, you have to understand that this is delicate, and timed to perfection
Gunsguy

No one really thinks Trunk was a source, the idea is, your source could very well be the SAME as Trunk/Piazza's source.

Aka, the shit that went to Trunk came from the same place you got yours. Which means there is ONE source. Unless you can say different.

[oneway23]

Because I aquired it not from trunk, my sources will never be reveiled, however I can tell you they are NOT FROM TRUNK, you must believe this, you have to understand that this is delicate, and timed to perfection
Gunsguy

No one really thinks Trunk was a source, the idea is, your source could very well be the SAME as Trunk/Piazza's source.

Aka, the shit that went to Trunk came from the same place you got yours. Which means there is ONE source. Unless you can say different.

Again, if there is one source, why did the individual choose to replace prostitute with better, unless better was mislabelled?

[kyrie]

These specific rips are NOT from the Trunk CD.? Eddie Trunk himself confirmed Better was not on the disc he received.

-darknemus

Not this again... discussed to death.

[Steel_Angel]

could better be prostitute? 

[kyrie]

looks like the source for these songs is almost definetly the trunk cd.but didnt they say there was only 3 songs and 3 instrumentals.but we have 4 songs leaked so where did the fourth song come from

He said 3 songs in addition to IRS, and that he couldn't remember exactly what the other songs were. He also didn't know the names of the other songs.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Better was from a diff source and so was citr. Better is much further along than IRS and TWAT and CITR is from cassette not cd.

[kyrie]

could better be prostitute??

I don't know. Where did this mislabeled track theory come from?

Has anyone considered that this leak did not occur until AFTER Axl said the track name in the press? Maybe someone had the track for a while and simply wasn't sure of the name until Axl said it in the Rolling Stone interview?