help with some new gnr trivia (when each guy joined/left

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Dont forget Josh Freese and Billy H left to join APC around 98/99

Billy H was a sound engineer or whatever... not a regular member. about Josh, I'm not sure if he was regular member or just session musician

oh, I nearly forgot about Chris Vrenna who was a member for a short time after Matt Sorum left and before Josh Freese joined... as far as I remember

Billy was the Chris Pittman of the band when he was in it.

[Nytunz]

Dont forget Josh Freese and Billy H left to join APC around 98/99

Billy H was a sound engineer or whatever... not a regular member. about Josh, I'm not sure if he was regular member or just session musician

oh, I nearly forgot about Chris Vrenna who was a member for a short time after Matt Sorum left and before Josh Freese joined... as far as I remember

Billy was the Chris Pittman of the band when he was in it.

Vrenna was apart of GNR? I dident know that, more interesting NIN info..
Anyway. Billy was guitar engineer. Dont know if he did more then that, but some says he played on the
early verson of Chinese Democracy. dont know if thats bullshit...

[Neemo]

Dont forget Josh Freese and Billy H left to join APC around 98/99

Billy H was a sound engineer or whatever... not a regular member. about Josh, I'm not sure if he was regular member or just session musician

oh, I nearly forgot about Chris Vrenna who was a member for a short time after Matt Sorum left and before Josh Freese joined... as far as I remember

Billy was the Chris Pittman of the band when he was in it.

Vrenna was apart of GNR? I dident know that, more interesting NIN info..
Anyway. Billy was guitar engineer. Dont know if he did more then that, but some says he played on the
early verson of Chinese Democracy. dont know if thats bullshit...

Didn't Billy Howerdell write Mer De Noms, in his spare time with GnR? Billy formed APC, he didn't 'Join" them

[Nytunz]

Dont forget Josh Freese and Billy H left to join APC around 98/99

Billy H was a sound engineer or whatever... not a regular member. about Josh, I'm not sure if he was regular member or just session musician

oh, I nearly forgot about Chris Vrenna who was a member for a short time after Matt Sorum left and before Josh Freese joined... as far as I remember

Billy was the Chris Pittman of the band when he was in it.

Vrenna was apart of GNR? I dident know that, more interesting NIN info..
Anyway. Billy was guitar engineer. Dont know if he did more then that, but some says he played on the
early verson of Chinese Democracy. dont know if thats bullshit...

Didn't Billy Howerdell write Mer De Noms, in his spare time with GnR? Billy formed APC, he didn't 'Join" them

ye! That is true, Maynard gets more credits from APC then he deserves.. Billy is the main man behind that project 

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Billy wrote stuff for gnr but axl did not use it, so he took it to APC. That is why Axl is thanked in the liner notes of APCs first album.

[Neemo]

ye! That is true, Maynard gets more credits from APC then he deserves.. Billy is the main man behind that project?

I even have an interview somewhere with Billy and Maynard and Maynard explicitly says that it is Billy's project not his, but people seem to ignore those kinds of things.

For some reason, in the eyes of the general populace, a band always is constructed and ran by the singer. but that's not necessarily true

Billy wrote stuff for gnr but axl did not use it, so he took it to APC. That is why Axl is thanked in the liner notes of APCs first album.

really?! I did not know that. that's cool

I just assumed it was because they were allowed to use Axl's studio to record it (I think that's true, I'm not 100% though), or they learned a shitload about writing/recording from Axl or that they were able to fund the project cuz of what Axl's paid them or something

[zombux]

it's amazing what kind of stuff was written and then used because Axl didn't want it... first Snakepit album, first APC album, first Black Label Society album...