Catcher in the Rye clip-Discuss

[jameslofton29]

I agree with Dave. This he/she needs to stop fucking around.

[Neemo]

Should get some words from the band. This is getting stupid

A-Fucking-MEN

IRS leaked feb 15th that was 10 days ago and 3 full songs and still no official word fomr Interscope, Sanctuary or Axl himself. ?WTF!!!!

speak, damn you! speak to us....your fans

[pilferk]

Whoever leaked that is really fucking up the operation.

Catcher in The Rye just lost some of its trade value.

Are you fucking serious? ?Really?

What kinda bullshit attitude is that? Oh, right...hoarder.....

Look, if that's the way you wanna "control" your stuff, hey, go for it.  Personally, I think the ego trip of having stuff nobody else does ain't worth crap, but, hey...whatever gets you through the night.

But don't bitch when others decide to actually share their stuff with everyone.

[Dr. Blutarsky]

I think the leaks are a reward for us who have been hanging in there for so long. But I'd be happy if the leaks stopped at this pont. I dont want a demo version of CD before it comes out.

However, if more leaks come I wont hesitate to check them out. Imaging if Christmas came once every 13 years and the presents just were put under the tree. Would you be curious??

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Whoever leaked that is really fucking up the operation.

Catcher in The Rye just lost some of its trade value.

Are you fucking serious? ?Really?

What kinda bullshit attitude is that? Oh, right...hoarder.....

Look, if that's the way you wanna "control" your stuff, hey, go for it.? Personally, I think the ego trip of having stuff nobody else does ain't worth crap, but, hey...whatever gets you through the night.

But don't bitch when others decide to actually share their stuff with everyone.

That is just wrong. If CITR was to leak out the the other leaked songs would have less value since CITR is one less song they would trade for it. And its even dumber these hoarders are trying to trade these leaks. If both hoardes that had Prost and CITR would share their songs everyone wins but those two are very selfish. If they dont want the songs out there then dont leak  out clips, lyrics or tell people you have them. They just love the attention of get off on us wanting  them. Its like giving a starving person a breadcrum in stead of a loaf of bread and teasing that starving person that you might give them the whole loaf but you dont know when.

[MikeFrett]

Here's an idea. Find out who's screwing with us and we'll all go beat his ass with an amp chord. I'm game for that. 

[Mandy.]

The clip is boring as hell.

[SLCPUNK]

Did I say the whole song was bad?  All I'm saying is that I don't like what I've heard so far.

all I'm saying is that you've only heard 9 seconds

how can you possibly make a judgment based on 9 seconds?

People are saying it's great based on those 9 seconds too, which is kind of funny.

It is too short, but doesn't sound too hot IMO. But neither did Better and now I love the entire new song.

[ARC]

The leaker made this clip to simply prove that the song was out there and real - i.e. cutting a clip where Axl sings "...catcher in the rye..."

He cut this clip so we knew which song it is, not because it's the most exciting part of the song.

Anyway, we will have the full tune in less than 24 hours. I guess.

[Timmy]

The leaker made this clip to simply prove that the song was out there and real - i.e. cutting a clip where Axl sings "...catcher in the rye..."

He cut this clip so we knew which song it is, not because it's the most exciting part of the song.

Anyway, we will have the full tune in less than 24 hours. I guess.

Once again dude, I hope, from my deepest core, you're right...

[Z]

The clip is boring as hell.

Yep.


Anybody holding on to stuff is spinning endlessly into the illusion of self importance.


BUT, funny thing is we can't be missin what we don't be hearin.


I'm satisfied, I've got plenty. ?I'm kicking it right now with my own cd......fuckin rocks........


1. ?Better (version without the middle part)
2. ?Madigascar (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
3. ?IRS
4. ?The Blues (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
5. ?Better (Full version)
6. ?Rhiad (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
7. ?TWAT
8. ?Chinese Democracy (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
9. ?Better (kick ass version consisting of the middle section only)
10. Just Another Sunday ?(I love this thing....kick ass way to wind down this cd that just kicks my fuckin ass)
11. Crash Diet


One week ago, I didn't have any of this............so keep strokin yourself while you, MAY OR MAY NOT, be holding on to more.


Blah, you borin me with your ego trippin "you aint got shit anyway" act.

[Steel_Angel]

The clip is boring as hell.

Yep.


Anybody holding on to stuff is spinning endlessly into the illusion of self importance.


BUT, funny thing is we can't be missin what we don't be hearin.


I'm satisfied, I've got plenty. ?I'm kicking it right now with my own cd......fuckin rocks........


1. ?Better (version without the middle part)
2. ?Madigascar (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
3. ?IRS
4. ?The Blues (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
5. ?Better (Full version)
6. ?Rhiad (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
7. ?TWAT
8. ?Chinese Democracy (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
9. ?Better (kick ass version consisting of the middle section only)
10. Just Another Sunday ?(I love this thing....kick ass way to wind down this cd that just kicks my fuckin ass)
11. Crash Diet


One week ago, I didn't have any of this............so keep strokin yourself while you, MAY OR MAY NOT, be holding on to more.


Blah, you borin me with your ego trippin "you aint got shit anyway" act.

crash diet is an old ass track.

[1badapple]

how the hell is a 9 sec clip gonna affect trade value? that's just stupid. i hope the people that are just hoarding this shit are really getting their kicks. i myself, get my kicks out of getting laid, so i'm gonna go join my wife in the shower and "get my kicks".

[Z]

crash diet is an old ass track.

And?!?!?!?

I didn't say it was new. ?Nor is Just Another Sunday. ?Just some old school GN'R I chose to put on the back end.

[plasmabeam]

Crash Diet should've been a sort of bonus track on GH.

[hogg2500x]

come on kids, it's just 9 seconds....

[Z]

how the hell is a 9 sec clip gonna affect trade value? that's just stupid. i hope the people that are just hoarding this shit are really getting their kicks. i myself, get my kicks out of getting laid, so i'm gonna go join my wife in the shower and "get my kicks".

CITR is not a clip that these clowns have. ?They're waiting for the back end to drop on this one just like everybody else.


I do believe the Prostitute demo is out there.......maybe another......but shit who cares.


Man this fuckin cd rocks!!!!

[Disco Volante]

oh and great no mods around to deal with this.?

If you're not interested, dont listen, and dont whine for mods. You have your own forum, go mod over there.

fuck you man.

What we've got here is failure to communicate...

[Eclipsed107]

1. ?Better (version without the middle part)
2. ?Madigascar (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
3. ?IRS
4. ?The Blues (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
5. ?Better (Full version)
6. ?Rhiad (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
7. ?TWAT
8. ?Chinese Democracy (live, remaster by Bloody Roses)
9. ?Better (kick ass version consisting of the middle section only)
10. Just Another Sunday ?(I love this thing....kick ass way to wind down this cd that just kicks my fuckin ass)
11. Crash Diet

My cd...

1. Chinese Democracy
2. Better
3. I.R.S.
4. The Blues
5. Madagascar
6. TWAT
7. Oh My God
8. Rhaid
9. Silkworms

(obviously IRS Better and TWAT are demos... OMG is studio, and the rest are remastered live tracks)

[Rocket_queen125]

9 seconds?

thats what my girlfriend said