Catcher in the Rye clip-Discuss

[HoldenCaulfield]

Moreso than hearing them, I'd love to know WHERE these people are getting the songs. This stuff's been under lock and key, and don't gimme the crap about Axl playing it at a club or anything...

[Axl_owns_dexter]

Wait...wasn't the guy trying to trade for more unreleased stuff?  Therefore, allowing us to hear MORE music. 

[Exnavymike]

Whoever leaked that is really fucking up the operation.

Catcher in The Rye just lost some of its trade value.

I'm going on a rant here. Don't take this personally. But you know what:

FUCK THIS SHIT.

Fuck off to the pathetic little shits hoarding tracks like Smaug over gold. Piss off, get lost, and don't waste our time. Release shit or don't.

Trade value?

I've got some experience in this area, and fuck the trade value. If people who aren't worth jack didn't get a blowjob for their egos and their online personas/trade circle reps for having this shit, this wouldn't be an issue. But they get off on it and people pony up to them.

I've had all sorts of shit before stores, before theatres, before retail. More shit than most people will ever see. I've had lots of unreleased tracks - and I've NEVER held back for a trade.

I'm not stroking some lameass's cock in a virtual circle-jerk amongst the trading community so they can have the honor of leaking shit.

IF YOU CAN'T DO IT WITHOUT A TRADE, DON'T WASTE PEOPLE'S TIME.

I'm sure some mod will delete this (or me), but it needs to be said.

Amen Brother.  Preach on.  Either Leak or dont. 

[Mr.Intensity]

No, keep it, now that the people who are hoarding "This I Love" will know that CITR is legit and be willing to trade.
If Catcher in the rye is leaked it loses its trade value.

People should just be patient.

[GNFNR_UK]

Is no one gonna say this is fake?! ?

It sounds legit but damn 9 seconds???!
Again like i said in other thread, that DJ in the club spun 2 discs for Axl both containing 10 tracks! Of course more shit is gonna leak!

[Howard2k]

Fake

[badapple81]

Wait...wasn't the guy trying to trade for more unreleased stuff?? Therefore, allowing us to hear MORE music.?

That's what buying the album is for. It's coming.

Fake

No it's real unfortunately.

[DunkinDave]

I'm grateful for anything we get at this point - the 3 demos were more than I would have thought we'd ever hear from the album.

[jameslofton29]

Its real.

[irgspice]

Whoever leaked that is really fucking up the operation.

Catcher in The Rye just lost some of its trade value.

I'm going on a rant here. Don't take this personally. But you know what:

FUCK THIS SHIT.

Fuck off to the pathetic little shits hoarding tracks like Smaug over gold. Piss off, get lost, and don't waste our time. Release shit or don't.

Trade value?

I've got some experience in this area, and fuck the trade value. If people who aren't worth jack didn't get a blowjob for their egos and their online personas/trade circle reps for having this shit, this wouldn't be an issue. But they get off on it and people pony up to them.

I've had all sorts of shit before stores, before theatres, before retail. More shit than most people will ever see. I've had lots of unreleased tracks - and I've NEVER held back for a trade.

I'm not stroking some lameass's cock in a virtual circle-jerk amongst the trading community so they can have the honor of leaking shit.

IF YOU CAN'T DO IT WITHOUT A TRADE, DON'T WASTE PEOPLE'S TIME.

I'm sure some mod will delete this (or me), but it needs to be said.

Now don't get me wrong, I'm enjoying the new music. ?I've been a huge fan since 87 and am more into Guns than ever. ?But . . . .

People who trade / sell / barter stolen property are scum. ?It's a shame humans have the ability to behave this way.

If you have the tracks, I'm sure most fans would appreciate you sharing them.  If you can't play nice in the sandbox with the rest of us, get the fuck out.

[GNFNR_UK]

Oh now we have these 9 seconds can anyone confirm if any of the CITR lyrics posted were real?

[DunkinDave]

Oh now we have these 9 seconds can anyone confirm if any of the CITR lyrics posted were real?

I have them saved from the other day - doesn't look like it.

"Catcher in the Rye" isn't even a phrase used in those lyrics.

[ILChief]

YOU KNOW WHAT.IM REALLY STARTING TO BELIEVE THAT THIS IS A PLANNED THING,ALL THESE LEAKS.WHY,BECAUSE THERE ISNT ONE FUKIN MOD ONLINE NOW.LOOKS LIKE THEY ARE ASKED TO STAND BACK AND LET ALL THIS LEAKING GO AHEAD.

I thought Axl/management was behind the leaks for the TWAT/IRS leaks, but then Better and Catcher of the Rye? ?That's a pretty big chunk of the album. ?I bet Geffen/Interscope steps in soon and forces a release before the whole thing leaks. ?Surely we'll hear something on Monday.

[kyrie]

No, keep it, now that the people who are hoarding "This I Love" will know that CITR is legit and be willing to trade.
If Catcher in the rye is leaked it loses its trade value.

People should just be patient.

My point is, people hoarding are the problem. There should be no value here.

You wanna know where I've seen hoarding, for trade value?

In Russians (and certain others) who sell silvers across europe before discs go to manufacture. In certain industries, they'll pay a lot of cash for items early. Greedy SOBS who make profit off others work.

This is the same minus actual cash value.

Real fans, people really interested in getting stuff out there, do it.

What good is it to "trade" CITR for Prostitue? Leak both public and you get both.

This ego strokefest is pathetic, a pissing contest between geeks.

Both these parties should just open up already. It's not hard to leak something if you have half a mind when it comes to security.

[kyrie]

Whoever leaked that is really fucking up the operation.

Catcher in The Rye just lost some of its trade value.

I'm going on a rant here. Don't take this personally. But you know what:

FUCK THIS SHIT.

Fuck off to the pathetic little shits hoarding tracks like Smaug over gold. Piss off, get lost, and don't waste our time. Release shit or don't.

Trade value?

I've got some experience in this area, and fuck the trade value. If people who aren't worth jack didn't get a blowjob for their egos and their online personas/trade circle reps for having this shit, this wouldn't be an issue. But they get off on it and people pony up to them.

I've had all sorts of shit before stores, before theatres, before retail. More shit than most people will ever see. I've had lots of unreleased tracks - and I've NEVER held back for a trade.

I'm not stroking some lameass's cock in a virtual circle-jerk amongst the trading community so they can have the honor of leaking shit.

IF YOU CAN'T DO IT WITHOUT A TRADE, DON'T WASTE PEOPLE'S TIME.

I'm sure some mod will delete this (or me), but it needs to be said.

People who trade / sell / barter stolen property are scum.  It's a shame humans have the ability to behave this way.

If you have the tracks, I'm sure most fans would appreciate you sharing them.  If you can't play nice in the sandbox with the rest of us, get the fuck out.

I'm not sure if I'm misreading you, but that's exactly what I said in the original post, if diff. words. Or were you just agreeing? Sorry if I misunderstood.

[Mr.Intensity]

Oh now we have these 9 seconds can anyone confirm if any of the CITR lyrics posted were real?

I have them saved from the other day - doesn't look like it.

"Catcher in the Rye" isn't even a phrase used in those lyrics.

The lyrics you have are wrong.

[Dr. Blutarsky]

Sounds cool, but 9 seconds doesnt give much to go on. may not even be GNR.

[DOASHK]

leak it up!!!

pleeeeeeeeease


is it fair that 2 club owners got to hear this before we did?

nooooooo

[ShotgunBlues1978]

Sounds cool, but 9 seconds doesnt give much to go on. may not even be GNR.

If it's a fake, they found a hell of an Axl impersonator to make it 

[Dr. Blutarsky]

If it is GNR, it sounds really good. Like the drum beat & piano in the background.