If only Slash and Axl where in GNR...

[GNRBABY]

Would some of you still say the band wasn't real GNR?

And what if only Izzy rejoined? Would you say they aren't GNR?

[plasmabeam]

Right now GN'R doesn't involve Slash or Izzy, so it doesn't matter.

[Sam]

theres a few other topics to this effect...

[Grouse]

The only "real" gnr are :

Axl
Slash
Steven
Izzy
Duff

It's as simple as that

[Cooker]

There was a GN'R before Slash, so its still GN'R after slash.

[Communist China]

Real GN'R needs Axl and Slash definitely, and Izzy certainly helps a lot too.

To Grouse: Steven?! Really? So UYI isn't real Guns except for Civil War?

[jmapelian]

There was a GN'R before Slash, so its still GN'R after slash.

that may be true...........as we all know you got that from an Axl quote...............but gnR wasnt GnR until Slash came around..........

or how bout this one, if Slash never came around, would we even be talking about Axl Rose

because i know nobody was talking about him b4 Slash

as valid as that statement is.......because it is true...............it's also extremely flimsy

[mikegiuliana]

Would some of you still say the band wasn't real GNR?

And what if only Izzy rejoined? Would you say they aren't GNR?

i don't know if i'd call it gnr but the two major faces of gnr that most people know woul be back