ROBINK FINK is not good enough...

[big_machine]

i`ve just saw the guitar solos he made....c`mon....hey gunners we need a good one in that position..    , someone with the skills, maybe not a virtuoso, but a guitar player with feeling...some who played with more technique than he does...sometimes he cofused the notes, and play some anoing sounds on the music.....

don`t kill me that`s just my opinion.....but i`m realistic...

let`s think who can be the next one, instead of bucket , slash or izzy and gilby...

just hear some gilby`s solos on the illusion....and he`s a pro...but robin.....c`mon he need to learn...

 ps: i`m sorry robin

[BLS-Pride]

pps: worthless topic

[electricmage]

First of all. I agree that Robin can't handle what Slash and Buckethead could. Although they are completely different guitar players. But learn your fucking facts before you go posting.

Gilby on the Illusion albums?

[Voodoochild]

Just download the song Fight Train from the movie Ghosts Of Mars. Gilby is shit.

[zombux]

go to hell with such stupid threads. who is Fink? I know only Finck

[Velvet Forever]

He 's got lot's of feeling , i'm amazed by his fucking feeling , he's not a poor photocopie , he puts lots of emotion in his solo , so please don't say that he has not any feeling , please

[parisrocks]

Ro b   i      n     r     o    c  ks!

[mikegiuliana]

I guess everyone is entitled to their opinion..  To me it's like not wanting scott for vr, the guy is who they want and that's all you can say.. When you have subs come in not everyone is going to be happy.. When you like a band and they change the lineup not everyone is going to be happy.

[W. Botaxl Rose]

Finck has always been a point of contention for me with fake GNR. I couldn't believe what I was hearing when he would solo on that 2002 tour. I know it's probably not true, but I almost got the feeling he was trying to sabotage GNR because deep down he was a alternative type person. Just from how bad his guitar playing was to how he moved onstage, I really felt he was like mocking what GNR was supposed to be about. Once again, JMHO, maybe he just is a ferry & really does suck that bad.

[mikegiuliana]

Finck has always been a point of contention for me with fake GNR. I couldn't believe what I was hearing when he would solo on that 2002 tour. I know it's probably not true, but I almost got the feeling he was trying to sabotage GNR because deep down he was a alternative type person. Just from how bad his guitar playing was to how he moved onstage, I really felt he was like mocking what GNR was supposed to be about. Once again, JMHO, maybe he just is a ferry & really does suck that bad.

I think he might have just been someone that was learning the songs and being they weren't his originally so to speak he wasn't as precise as one might want.. I will let hte second go around be the real judge of everyone's true talents on the older stuff

[W. Botaxl Rose]

I mean all solos. The solos between songs he would perform were an absolute joke. People around me were seriously dumbfounded by Finck's suckiness. It was chicken scratch. And to think Botaxl had Buckethead in his band & he's giving piece of shit finck soloing time? retarded. No wonder Buckethead left. It's like having Michael Jordan on your team & letting Dennis Rodman taking the last shot.

[jmapelian]

I thought from the video feed i saw in 2002 that he didn't really have much stage presence and he butchered some of the AFD solos.

As for the new stuff, power chords and solos?  Sounds like what was played before AFD

[Sakib]

He 's got lot's of feeling , i'm amazed by his fucking feeling , he's not a poor photocopie , he puts lots of emotion in his solo , so please don't say that he has not any feeling , please

i couldn't agree more. He could be even better than Slash. However, Slash is still very iconic.

[W. Botaxl Rose]

i couldn't agree more. He could be even better than Slash.

Sorry, but this really is the most ignorant thought I have ever seen posted on this website & that's saying a hell of alot.

[journey]

I like Robin. He has a unique style that's fresh.

Stop the hating. He's family now, so show some love.

[Grouse]

i couldn't agree more. He could be even better than Slash. However, Slash is still very iconic.

Anyone ever told you that you've got a great sense of humor

[chineseblues]

He 's got lot's of feeling , i'm amazed by his fucking feeling , he's not a poor photocopie , he puts lots of emotion in his solo , so please don't say that he has not any feeling , please

I agree, when Robin plays the scom solos you can totally feel he is into it with 100% of his being and soul. Not alot of guitarists can do that.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

His solo TWAT? was very good. Robin is? a great player he just bends his notes way too much sometimes. He cant suck that much since Axl and Trent both had/have them in their bands. If you listen to TWAT the shorter version ,that is all robin, all the solos. He is great.

[Sakib]

i couldn't agree more. He could be even better than Slash. However, Slash is still very iconic.

Anyone ever told you that you've got a great sense of humor

How am I ignorant? Slash is more of an icon and Finck is far more technically skilled that Slash. And i sed he could be NOT he is

[axlschild]

Ro bi  n k  il  l s


end of story!