I just don't miss the old band at all..Do you?

[shaun]

No i don't miss the old band (they've moved on) and this thread is pointless 

[asdorf]

Right now I don't miss the old band at all, but before the leaks started I always wanted them back..

[Elrothiel]

Thank you SG - now i can rest easy!! Anyhoo theres much better things to do with nuts than kick them young lady. But I shant go down that road......!!

Yes I'll agree with that... yummy! But the nuts of haters are fun to kick... too bad I lost my leg in that attempt to restrain myself! Ooh look it grew back!

[jmapelian]

I don't miss the old band, just their sound

as someone else said, they've all moved on

[Aero]

I just don't miss the old band at all..Do you?

I do. And to be honest, it's the only gnr band I know... newgnr performances has lots of changes... 2 shows with tobias, then comes fortus, then leaves bucket, now I don't know if there's a 3rd guitarrist !

I have no clue about that's the courrent lineup, I only got 3 good demos, Of course I fucking miss Slash doing SCOM solo ! ! !

[Krispy Kreme]

I miss the  old band  a lot.
Ask yourself: if the old and new band were coming to your town, who would you see ( I realize it a hypothetical situation, so just play along). In my mind, the answer  is clear.

[Elrothiel]

Both. I'd clone myself so I could go see both.

[tat2d1]

i miss the old band. i like what i've heard from the new band, and they do a good job on the old songs, but nothing beats the original. i'll continue to support axl because i think he's a great musician and his voice is one of a kind.

[jameslofton29]

I miss the? old band? a lot.
Ask yourself: if the old and new band were coming to your town, who would you see ( I realize it a hypothetical situation, so just play along). In my mind, the answer? is clear.

As much as I love the old band, I would have to choose the new one. I want to hear new material, not 20 year old songs.

[SWINGTRADER]

Of course i miss the old band      The old band is the reason why we want Axl to succeed.  We want to relive in someway  what we had with the old band  .  We want some real rock back .  If tomorrow Axl rose announced that he was going to reunite with the old members  and we never got a chance to listen to CD  i would not mind at all ( Actually i would be jumping up and down ) .  This current GNR is probably going to be very good  and the new album is going to be solid  and that is great   but for any of us to say we don't miss the old band  is just not true.

[Gunner17]

Of course i miss the old band? ? ? The old band is the reason why we want Axl to succeed.? We want to relive in someway? what we had with the old band? .? We want some real rock back .? If tomorrow Axl rose announced that he was going to reunite with the old members? and we never got a chance to listen to CD? i would not mind at all ( Actually i would be jumping up and down ) .? This current GNR is probably going to be very good? and the new album is going to be solid? and that is great? ?but for any of us to say we don't miss the old band? is just not true.

I agree with you 100%.....I will never get to see Slash on top of a piano while Axl sings and plays November Rain, ever...And yes, I am sad that I will never see this...I miss the old line up, I miss the old Guns, and I wish that they would get back together...But hey, maybe CD will erase most of that?

[lynn1961]

I miss the old band.  It's just not the same.

[Mikkamakka]

I'll always miss Guns N' Roses, but I'll support Axl's new band if the prove their worth.

[coolman78SLASH]

Everybody would love to have Guns N Roses like we used to (between 85-94), but since that is not possible we have Guns N Roses (without the GUNS) and Velvet Revolver (without the ROSES) , but still, two really cool and very talented bands, and that's not bad if we cant have the old line up if you ask me! Wish both bands all the luck, and Im fan of 'em both !!

[Carlos_f_Rose]

Excellent words, I couldnt have said it better...

But Im still after a reunion and a reunion album...

[Assman]

Yes and no!

I would never in my life want a comeback with the old line-up. But they were a great band and it was exciting to see how big they were. BUT

I do not want any compromises! Axl should do what he set out to do when they went separate ways. He and the others will be great with what they do now, just as VR is a good band with a couple of great songs.

With a compromise there would only be questions about money and "just another comeback", attention, and so on.

By the way; I haven?t heard the newly leaked songs...

[Carlos_f_Rose]

about the leaked songs... I havent listened to them either... Although I'm not that interested...

[jmapelian]

I miss the? old band? a lot.
Ask yourself: if the old and new band were coming to your town, who would you see ( I realize it a hypothetical situation, so just play along). In my mind, the answer? is clear.

As much as I love the old band, I would have to choose the new one. I want to hear new material, not 20 year old songs.

Apparantly you haven't seen the set lists from the 2002 tour

If your gonna get a heavy dose of AFD and UYI, I'd much rather see the originals

instead of a glorified cover band

[D]

Right now I dont give a shit about any other band.

Prince has a new CD comin next month, RHCP's have a new cd but right now this is all I care about.

Im glad there is a new GNR and I cannot wait till they become the biggest band around which they will have no problem doing.

[jmapelian]

I'm actually looking forward to hearing the music on Libertad more than CD......

Not a slight at Axl, I like the leaks I've heard


just not as much as I liked Contraband

but as I've ben waiting for new GnR material since I bought the Illusion albums, i'll happily buy it