IRS & Better-take the poll

[RichardNixon]

On a scale of 1-10, rate these songs.

[mikegiuliana]

irs 5 solo 8

better as a song 5 as a radio friendly tune in today's scene about an 8 as well it would do excellent

But those two are no maddy,blues, or cd

they are on the lower rung for me with slkworms rhiad omg

[RichardNixon]

IRS- I'd go with an 8. I think it could go even higher though once the finished product is released.

Better- 10. Even though we've only heard the first 90 seconds or so, great, great song. Edgy, melodic, pure ear-candy yet also rocks.

[nesquick]

IRS: 8 (with more aggressive guitars and a speed up tempo)
Better: I don't have a clue. Maybe 5. The intro sounds odd to me.

[Saboteur Cyb. Punk]

I.R.S - 2 (Buckethead Solo - 10 )
Better - 8

[jameslofton29]

IRS-4 or 5 ?Mike's right, the solo kicks ass, and is the only real highlight

Better-7 or 8 ?Not the greatest song ever, but a very catchy tune that is sure to go top 10

[audjon]

IRS - 8
Better - 10

[badapple81]

Axl described some of the songs as Queen style arrangements or something.. so the other tracks must be quite diverse as I can't hear much of that so far! We definately have a lot more to look forward to I think ?

Better 7-8

IRS 8-9 (yes solo is awesome)

Unlike most I actually like IRS better.. love the tempo.. my kinda song!

[metallex78]

IRS - 7
Buckets solo gets an 8

Better - 8
And thats from only hearing 1 minute of it!
I'd probably give it a 9 or 10 if the rest of it is as good.

[Eppe]

I.R.S.  9

Better  9?

[wadey]

IRS - 9/10
BETTER - 9.99999999/10
 

[CAFC Nick]

I.R.S 8/10
Better 8.1/10

[0001001]

Rating is relative. Compared to the shit that is out there on the radio, both songs get a 10.
But I think you mean compared to other GN'R songs:

IRS: 7
Better: 5

[Bongo]

IRS - 9
Better - 8 (only 1:20 minutes)

[mikegiuliana]

Rating is relative. Compared to the shit that is out there on the radio, both songs get a 10.
But I think you mean compared to other GN'R songs:

IRS: 7
Better: 5

if this is compared to other gnr material like wttj scom ,pc, CW, ycbm, NR estranged, coma, etc then this stuff is under 5...

people throw around 8 or better like it's nothing.. Stairway to heaven is a ten, freebird is a ten

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

IRS 7 - just a demo i guess
Better 5 - very radio friendly, sounds popish. intro is not my cup of tea.

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

irs 20 out of 10
better 22 out of 10

[badapple81]

What an ipod playlist I'll have now! IRS, Better clip, Rhiad live, The Blues live, Maddy live and Chinese Democracy live! 

[Luigi]

8-10 All songs rock, So fuckin what, did you think the music would suck? No way! This cd's gonna flat out kick your asses + supprises

[Mr.Intensity]

Better- 8.5
I.R.S- 6.5


To give you an idea where I rate some other gnr tracks

Estranged-10
Coma-10
November Rain-9
Its So Easy-8
Patience-8
Don't Damn Me-8.5
Oh my god-7.5