Axl and Slash rehearsing together?

[//JK75]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I agree with you, but Izzy to me is a key to the old GNR sound and lyrics. Believe me.

[Origen]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

John Freese should never of left.

[RichardNixon]

It would be a real shitty thing to do if the whole CD project was scrapped for a reunion. They need a new guitar player, so bring in Slash, but the rest of the guys deserve to stay.

[Neemo]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

John Freese should never of left.

He's amazing. A Perfect Circle Kicks. Check out "The Noose" the drums kick ass an that track

[Saul]

lol , management probably started this false rumor to take talk away from the "leaks" ... lmfao.

I'm kidding , I think. Thats what the MIB's tell me to say.

[//JK75]

Tommy is the only new member to have been with Axl unconditionally since 1998. Robin left for awhile. Tommy deserves to be involved. Slash is definitely very important to the brand and would be huge if he contributes to the final product and tours.

Tommy is my fav band member from the current line up, I agree with you. But I would prefer the 1991 line up over the current one 100%. If Duff doesn't want to come back then keep Tommy. ?

Well... but to be realistic I think this whole rumour is not possible now. And I say now, beacuse from the latest nice comments from Slash about Axl and viceversa, and that Axl's statement on the RS interview that he has been talkin' to Izzy, I think a reunion is closer now. It could happen but after CD release and tour... even after another two albums if Axl got that amount of material as he said.

About Slash re-recording lead guitar parts on CD. I seriously don't think so. ?If it would be possible, do you think Slash would be sayin' that CD will be out on march ?

And after all this time, I would prefer Slash keeps out of CD project. Just imagine that would be an excuse for another year delay... ?

[//JK75]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

John Freese should never of left.

I agree about Josh Freese he's an awesome drumer, one of the best right now, but he's busy with NIN right now, and I hope Trent keep him !!!   

[jmapelian]

sound like wishful thinking to me

[Lourenco]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

John Freese should never of left.

Exactly my thoughts! Josh Freese is the best drummer out there for GN'R

[Buddha_Master]

Wishful thinking? It would be fucked up! I want Axl to prove everyone worong. All the fucking doubters. I would be so fucking proud of Axl. I have followed him on this entire journey, and IRS and Better made me a believer again of Axl's genius. Slash better stay the fuck away from Chinese Democracy. I am serious. Axl should never let Slash come crawling back. He made his choice and he should have to live with it. This is Axl's time. And its high time he puts people in their place.

Release CD as is...fuck waiting longer for this non believer to weasel his way back into the fold.

But you know what? I will take this as rumor bullshit. It can't happen. It would be wrong.

[ARC]

You know, for nearly nine years there was never any chance of seeing Bret Hart back in the WWE. Now, he's coming to Wrestlemania...

I've said for a long time that we will see Axl, Duff and Slash back onstage together...

Hopefully sooner rather than later.

[WARose]

well if this is true then CD is indded coming in march

[Pdj79]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

Same here.  I want to hear You Could Be Mine played proper again, dammit.  Just once I'd like to hear the intro played with power AND precision.  Of course, if I had my druthers and millions of dollars, I'd say get Dave Grohl...that man turns anything to gold when he sits behind the kit.

Josh

[Neemo]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

Same here.? I want to hear You Could Be Mine played proper again, dammit.? Just once I'd like to hear the intro played with power AND precision.? Of course, if I had my druthers and millions of dollars, I'd say get Dave Grohl...that man turns anything to gold when he sits behind the kit.

Josh

LOLOL

that's funny, it'd be a cold day in hell before Mr.Grohl played for GnR i think

[Origen]

If they were rehearsing 2 questions I really wanna know:


1. What were they rehearsing for ? (Download Festival perhaps)

2. What were they rehearsing/jamming on ? (Imagine seeing a video of them rehearsing Jungle or Civil War together? )

[WARose]

If they were rehearsing 2 questions I really wanna know:

1. What were they rehearsing for ? (Download Festival perhaps)

2. What were they rehearsing/jamming on (Imagine seeing a video of them rehearsing Jungle or Civil War together  )

maybe axl is teaching slash how to play better.....

[damnthehaters]

Best Line-up, or who I would like to see play together.

Axl
Slash
Tommy
Richard
Brain
Dizzy

I don't get anything from Robin and Pittman.

[damnthehaters]

Duff instead of Tommy... Axl -Slash -Duff, the "magic three" should be reunited... with Richard, Robin, Dizzy and Brain of the new band, we would have the best GN'R line-up ever.

I would pick Matt over Brain, I have never really like him or his drum tone, even when he was with Primus

Are you serious?  With how Matt talked about Axl on the VH1 special, he's better off left alone.  And it show's he has no clue about good music when he ripped November Rain. 

[Thorazine Shuffle]

Best Line-up, or who I would like to see play together.

Axl
Slash
Tommy
Richard
Brain
Dizzy

I don't get anything from Robin and Pittman.

OK, Ill play

Axl
Slash
Duff
Izzy
Brain

Yea, I'm old school.  I would like to see the current incarnation of GNR to tour as The Axl Rose Band for support of CD.

[//JK75]

Best Line-up, or who I would like to see play together.

Axl
Slash
Tommy
Richard
Brain
Dizzy

I don't get anything from Robin and Pittman.

OK, Ill play

Axl
Slash
Duff
Izzy
Brain

Yea, I'm old school.? I would like to see the current incarnation of GNR to tour as The Axl Rose Band for support of CD.

I agree.. I can?t understand why some people put Richard Fortus (over Izzy) on their "dream line up" he was the last one in joining GNR, no one had heard a note he played (at least in the studio material) and his past as a musician is pop asshole music... why is he better than Slash, Izzy or even Gilby ? because they think he looks cool ? Fuck up !

For the drummer slot, I have no preference, I like Matt in the UYI era, and Adler on AFD (not now, he's fucked up) but I don't care about Brain either, I don't have anything against him but I would prefer Matt over him. I agree, like I said before, Josh is the better man out there... but again, he's busy !