Scott Weiland VS Sebastian Bach

[D]

Jesus Christ Im tired of this discussion.

Sebastian Bach has a one track voice, he isnt diverse and MOST IMPORTANTLY HE CANT FUCKIN WRITE A GOD DAMN ORIGINAL PIECE OF MUSIC OR LYRIC TO SAVE HIS FUCKING LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



bach has got to be one of the most overrated guys of all time.

[head-off elephant]

NO NO NO... you got that WRRONG MISTER....


If skid row hadnt have got rid of bach, they would have been one of the biggest rock groups around...

[Communist China]

NO NO NO... you got that WRRONG MISTER....


If skid row hadnt have got rid of bach, they would have been one of the biggest rock groups around...

They were even-chessier wannabes of Motley Crue. Very little credability, the grunge era would've killed them in an instant.

[metallex78]

They were even-chessier wannabes of Motley Crue.

You obviously haven't listened to songs like Wasted Time, In A Darkened Room or Qucksand Jesus if you think that.

[D]

Bach is dated as fuck. He can scream but he cant write songs.

thats what it comes down to.

with Scott VR were all over the radio and were a double platinum band.

With Bach they wouldve sold about 300,000 albums.


remember the Stripper Girl Dude?

thats bout the quality of songs Bach could write.

[head-off elephant]

if matt cant write songs does that make him a bad drummer???

whys it got to be the singer who writes the songs

[Carlos_f_Rose]

about Matt I remember that he wrote the riff for Set me free, and that year won the prize of the best riff...

[D]

if matt cant write songs does that make him a bad drummer???

whys it got to be the singer who writes the songs

A singer is the one delivering and singing the lines.

How can u buy what someone is singing if it isnt their words?

Here is a great example

take Creed vs Alter Bridge


Technically Myles Kennedy could sing Scott Stapp under the table, if u wanna talk about techincal ability,range etc He could blow Scott Stapp out of a room


But u listen to a Creed record, u listen to Alter Bridges CD and u tell me who is better.

same thing with Bach

Technically and range wise he can blow SCott out of the water but Scott is the better frontman, better lyricist and is an amazing melody writer.

[Butch Français]

I dunno if Ive replied in here before..but Scott > Baz.