matt sorum interview metal edge music fest 96

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

it seems that nothing much has changed in 10 years except the lineup.i love these old interviews,keep em coming.

[McDuff]

it's interesting to read the old interviews,thanks

[jimmythegent]

Should certain members of the HTGTH board form an alliance to make sure newbies to the board don't take over and insult the guys that have been her for a while?? ?? I'll take Mike and James.? ThatCertainSomeone can have AxlRoseVen and dave2kgnr however it ends.....

Nice post, and I'm sure you were joking with that last line, but give Davegnr2k a little respect. He's been here alot longer than I have, and even though he and I rarely agree, I have alot of respect for him. Sure, I'm one of the "realists" like Mike, Jimmythegent, Rob, D, etc., but without the "Axlites", "nutswingers"(whatever you want to call them) like Dave, ppbebe,nesquick, chineseblues,madagas,etc., this would be a boring place to be.

James, i was kidding.? Dave reminds me of an Alabama fan.? An Alabama football fan blindly sides with anything their team does even when the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.? I love Dave's passion.? I have been here for a long ass time.? Just don't post as much, but I am here everyday.? I love this board, 99% of what I say is sarcasm.? Whatever happened to Booker?

Thats one of the cool things about Dave. We were all once like him. Its like he's a fan from the past that was brought to the present day, and still has that mindset of 'GNR can do no wrong'. As far as Booker goes, Ocassionally I see him in The Jungle section. I also thought it was strange how he went from these constant debates about the past, to basically not even posting and hanging out in The Jungle. Maybe he's waiting for more bad news.

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

And I think Booker decided not to post here because some morons went too far in a debate and it got ridiculous, so perhaps he thought whats the point? - shame , cos his posts were always interesting

[jameslofton29]

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

And I think Booker decided not to post here because some morons went too far in a debate and it got ridiculous, so perhaps he thought whats the point? - shame , cos his posts were always interesting

Yeah, I think reality is setting in for Dave, about 10 years late. But he added something to the forum, and I missed that. I always liked debating him, and you could always tell you were winning the debate when he started insulting you. He's just taking a breather from posting I guess. Ocassionally, everyone takes a break.
 Jimmy, if we all went by Booker's reasons to not post, we would all leave. But I also enjoyed his discussions. He made his points very well, and it frustrated alot of people. He went overboard sometimes. I remember his Slash the Liar thread, and he basically destroyed his competition in that debate. But he kept on and on, and the valid points he made were basically a mute point because he gloated too much and started contradicting himself. But I'm sure we'll see the return of Booker in the near future.

[jimmythegent]

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

And I think Booker decided not to post here because some morons went too far in a debate and it got ridiculous, so perhaps he thought whats the point? - shame , cos his posts were always interesting

Yeah, I think reality is setting in for Dave, about 10 years late. But he added something to the forum, and I missed that. I always liked debating him, and you could always tell you were winning the debate when he started insulting you. He's just taking a breather from posting I guess. Ocassionally, everyone takes a break.
 Jimmy, if we all went by Booker's reasons to not post, we would all leave. But I also enjoyed his discussions. He made his points very well, and it frustrated alot of people. He went overboard sometimes. I remember his Slash the Liar thread, and he basically destroyed his competition in that debate. But he kept on and on, and the valid points he made were basically a mute point because he gloated too much and started contradicting himself. But I'm sure we'll see the return of Booker in the near future.

ah yes, I remember the Slash the Liar thread - I was involved in that one
I remember a particularly ridiculous suggestion that the fans were somehow to blame for Axls lateness and that people should accept Axls lateness/no shows/riot causing incidents, as part of the overall "performance" 

One of the more severe "battered wife syndrome" moments Ive witnessed on the boards

[jameslofton29]

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

And I think Booker decided not to post here because some morons went too far in a debate and it got ridiculous, so perhaps he thought whats the point? - shame , cos his posts were always interesting

Yeah, I think reality is setting in for Dave, about 10 years late. But he added something to the forum, and I missed that. I always liked debating him, and you could always tell you were winning the debate when he started insulting you. He's just taking a breather from posting I guess. Ocassionally, everyone takes a break.
 Jimmy, if we all went by Booker's reasons to not post, we would all leave. But I also enjoyed his discussions. He made his points very well, and it frustrated alot of people. He went overboard sometimes. I remember his Slash the Liar thread, and he basically destroyed his competition in that debate. But he kept on and on, and the valid points he made were basically a mute point because he gloated too much and started contradicting himself. But I'm sure we'll see the return of Booker in the near future.

ah yes, I remember the Slash the Liar thread - I was involved in that one
I remember a particularly ridiculous suggestion that the fans were somehow to blame for Axls lateness and that people should accept Axls lateness/no shows/riot causing incidents, as part of the overall "performance"?

One of the more severe "battered wife syndrome" moments Ive witnessed on the boards

Yeah, that thread had alot of wacky posts. Every now and then, we should resurrect it and let those who didn't see it experience a thread which consisted of a few realists against a gang of nutswingers, with Jarmo right in the middle of the discussion. I rarely posted in the thread, but I sure enjoyed reading it.

[jarmo]

Are you done with the off topic "discussion" about how realistic you are and how nobody else can see reality?




/jarmo

[highend88]

We've got a lot of ideas, four of five keepers...

 Any of those survived and were performed with the new band?

I think its safe to say that 'This I Love' is one of those songs. It was mentioned by Axl in the early 90's, and was rejected for a soundtrack in 1997. So some work must have been done on it with old members of GNR. Although he might have changed it by now, although I have a feeling he scrapped it. Someone made an excellent point in one of these threads how years ago, this was one of Axl's favorite songs, but he didn't mention it in his recent comments.

I did...
Link: http://www.sp1at.com/item.php?id=61
"Axl Rose himself when he described "This I Love" as "the heaviest thing I've ever done","

I hope it will see a daylight. Whether on CD or future recordings Or single, I will definitely buy it.

[jameslofton29]

 I also remember some article from like 96 or 97 where Duff says they had like 4 albums worth of music to work with. That vault is getting so full Axl might have to open up a 2nd one.

[Warren]

I also remember some article from like 96 or 97 where Duff says they had like 4 albums worth of music to work with. That vault is getting so full Axl might have to open up a 2nd one.

There's some kind of bluff going on...

Or perhaps not... If they are talking about songs like My World or Silkworms, anyone of us could write like 30 or 40 of these in 3 days.

[jameslofton29]

I also remember some article from like 96 or 97 where Duff says they had like 4 albums worth of music to work with. That vault is getting so full Axl might have to open up a 2nd one.

There's some kind of bluff going on...

Or perhaps not... If they are talking about songs like My World or Silkworms, anyone of us could write like 30 or 40 of these in 3 days.

It couldn't have all been that. As Mike pointed out, there's different articles from GNR members about the new album being similar to AFD. I cant imagine Axl going in the industrial/techno direction until Slash, Duff, and Matt were already gone. Sure, he probably toyed with the idea, but I cant imagine the old gunners recording NIN type shit. There might be a few demos of that type of stuff, but that cant be what they were working on pre-1998. Too many articles point to the AFD type record.

[badapple81]

I'm sure there are at least a few tracks from that era that were recorded. Whether they still exist is anyones guess.

[Warren]

I also remember some article from like 96 or 97 where Duff says they had like 4 albums worth of music to work with. That vault is getting so full Axl might have to open up a 2nd one.

There's some kind of bluff going on...

Or perhaps not... If they are talking about songs like My World or Silkworms, anyone of us could write like 30 or 40 of these in 3 days.

It couldn't have all been that. As Mike pointed out, there's different articles from GNR members about the new album being similar to AFD. I cant imagine Axl going in the industrial/techno direction until Slash, Duff, and Matt were already gone. Sure, he probably toyed with the idea, but I cant imagine the old gunners recording NIN type shit. There might be a few demos of that type of stuff, but that cant be what they were working on pre-1998. Too many articles point to the AFD type record.

I was talking about "bluff" in general terms... Like saying "we are working on 32 songs and 26 are nearly done"...

[Eugene Klein]

10 years or so are worth of lots of material. Someday a sort of Anthology should be released, obviously not in the near future.

[Brahman]

I love finding these old interviews in my mags..

Matt sorum confirmed that guns n roses was making progress "we're in the same room together...Axl's been at every rehearsal..So far it's going OK....We've got a lot of ideas, four of five keepers...I really respect where axl's coming from, he wants to make a great recordhe doesn't want to just throw something out there..We're trying to? make a record that will rock..The songs are going to be SHORT, axl is really into making them like 4 minutes.. No more epics, we're over the epics.. They'll be straight ahead rock n roll songs

later it says hopefully guns will be touring by the spring..

Goddamn how things can change....  i wonder what the hell happened, all those wasted years!
Who where the other 4 most angst singers?

[mikegiuliana]

I love finding these old interviews in my mags..

Matt sorum confirmed that guns n roses was making progress "we're in the same room together...Axl's been at every rehearsal..So far it's going OK....We've got a lot of ideas, four of five keepers...I really respect where axl's coming from, he wants to make a great recordhe doesn't want to just throw something out there..We're trying to? make a record that will rock..The songs are going to be SHORT, axl is really into making them like 4 minutes.. No more epics, we're over the epics.. They'll be straight ahead rock n roll songs

later it says hopefully guns will be touring by the spring..

Goddamn how things can change....? i wonder what the hell happened, all those wasted years!
Who where the other 4 most angst singers?

let me track the mag down

this is hit parader 1995 winners n losers

1) guns n roses breaking up...

top 5 angst riddled rockers

1) scott weiland
2)edie vedder
3)layne staley
4)trent reznor
5) axl rose

Top 5 missing in action 1)met
2)gnr
3)aero
4)STP
5)SG

Slash's snakepit was the top 2nd ovveryhyped

as was hole, plant page, green day mad season- fuck that was awesome..

the issue of metal edge wasvolume 41 num 7 1996 sterling mcfadden

[jameslofton29]

this is hit parader 1995 winners n losers

1) guns n roses breaking up...

top 5 angst riddled rockers

1) scott weiland
2)edie vedder
3)layne staley
4)trent reznor
5) axl rose

Top 5 missing in action 1)met
2)gnr
3)aero
4)STP
5)SG

Slash's snakepit was the top 2nd ovveryhyped

as was hole, plant page, green day mad season- fuck that was awesome..

the issue of metal edge wasvolume 41 num 7 1996 sterling mcfadden

Snakepit and Mad Season overhyped?? I dont think so. Wasn't Snakepit a little under the radar? Sure, Slash did quite a few mag interviews promoting Snakepit, but Snakepit wasn't in our faces constantly, and MTV and other media basically ignored them. How is Mad Season overhyped? That was one of the best albums of the 90's. Although I do agree with the rest of that overhyped list.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

Should certain members of the HTGTH board form an alliance to make sure newbies to the board don't take over and insult the guys that have been her for a while?? ?? I'll take Mike and James.? ThatCertainSomeone can have AxlRoseVen and dave2kgnr however it ends.....

Nice post, and I'm sure you were joking with that last line, but give Davegnr2k a little respect. He's been here alot longer than I have, and even though he and I rarely agree, I have alot of respect for him. Sure, I'm one of the "realists" like Mike, Jimmythegent, Rob, D, etc., but without the "Axlites", "nutswingers"(whatever you want to call them) like Dave, ppbebe,nesquick, chineseblues,madagas,etc., this would be a boring place to be.

James, i was kidding.? Dave reminds me of an Alabama fan.? An Alabama football fan blindly sides with anything their team does even when the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.? I love Dave's passion.? I have been here for a long ass time.? Just don't post as much, but I am here everyday.? I love this board, 99% of what I say is sarcasm.? Whatever happened to Booker?

See unlike some people I can think for myself and I don't follow what the popular thing to do is. Since its "in" to bash Axl right now people like you bash him but when Axl is "cool" again of course people like you will praise him again. Sorry that I am a real fan and I can separate the music from the bullshit. I don?t let CD run my life like it must do for you since you feel the need to complain about it.? Like I have always said, Axl does not owe us anything. I don?t care if he doesn?t speak and the album will come out when Axl think its ready. Id much rather have Axl take 10 years to make an album and have him think its great than Axl just put out albums to make money with only 1 or 2 good songs on it like most bands do. So learn to think for yourself and not follow the masses because that shows poorly on people like you not me.

Should certain members of the HTGTH board form an alliance to make sure newbies to the board don't take over and insult the guys that have been her for a while?? ?? I'll take Mike and James.? ThatCertainSomeone can have AxlRoseVen and dave2kgnr however it ends.....

Nice post, and I'm sure you were joking with that last line, but give Davegnr2k a little respect. He's been here alot longer than I have, and even though he and I rarely agree, I have alot of respect for him. Sure, I'm one of the "realists" like Mike, Jimmythegent, Rob, D, etc., but without the "Axlites", "nutswingers"(whatever you want to call them) like Dave, ppbebe,nesquick, chineseblues,madagas,etc., this would be a boring place to be.

James, i was kidding.? Dave reminds me of an Alabama fan.? An Alabama football fan blindly sides with anything their team does even when the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.? I love Dave's passion.? I have been here for a long ass time.? Just don't post as much, but I am here everyday.? I love this board, 99% of what I say is sarcasm.? Whatever happened to Booker?

Thats one of the cool things about Dave. We were all once like him. Its like he's a fan from the past that was brought to the present day, and still has that mindset of 'GNR can do no wrong'. As far as Booker goes, Ocassionally I see him in The Jungle section. I also thought it was strange how he went from these constant debates about the past, to basically not even posting and hanging out in The Jungle. Maybe he's waiting for more bad news.

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

I have not toned anything down really. I just got tired of the same old debates and decided to stop going in circles.

[jameslofton29]

I have not toned anything down really. I just got tired of the same old debates and decided to stop going in circles.

Whats wrong with circles? I love circles!

[WARose]

Should certain members of the HTGTH board form an alliance to make sure newbies to the board don't take over and insult the guys that have been her for a while?? ?? I'll take Mike and James.? ThatCertainSomeone can have AxlRoseVen and dave2kgnr however it ends.....

Nice post, and I'm sure you were joking with that last line, but give Davegnr2k a little respect. He's been here alot longer than I have, and even though he and I rarely agree, I have alot of respect for him. Sure, I'm one of the "realists" like Mike, Jimmythegent, Rob, D, etc., but without the "Axlites", "nutswingers"(whatever you want to call them) like Dave, ppbebe,nesquick, chineseblues,madagas,etc., this would be a boring place to be.

James, i was kidding.? Dave reminds me of an Alabama fan.? An Alabama football fan blindly sides with anything their team does even when the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.? I love Dave's passion.? I have been here for a long ass time.? Just don't post as much, but I am here everyday.? I love this board, 99% of what I say is sarcasm.? Whatever happened to Booker?

See unlike some people I can think for myself and I don't follow what the popular thing to do is. Since its "in" to bash Axl right now people like you bash him but when Axl is "cool" again of course people like you will praise him again. Sorry that I am a real fan and I can separate the music from the bullshit. I don’t let CD run my life like it must do for you since you feel the need to complain about it.? Like I have always said, Axl does not owe us anything. I don’t care if he doesn’t speak and the album will come out when Axl think its ready. Id much rather have Axl take 10 years to make an album and have him think its great than Axl just put out albums to make money with only 1 or 2 good songs on it like most bands do. So learn to think for yourself and not follow the masses because that shows poorly on people like you not me.

Should certain members of the HTGTH board form an alliance to make sure newbies to the board don't take over and insult the guys that have been her for a while?? ?? I'll take Mike and James.? ThatCertainSomeone can have AxlRoseVen and dave2kgnr however it ends.....

Nice post, and I'm sure you were joking with that last line, but give Davegnr2k a little respect. He's been here alot longer than I have, and even though he and I rarely agree, I have alot of respect for him. Sure, I'm one of the "realists" like Mike, Jimmythegent, Rob, D, etc., but without the "Axlites", "nutswingers"(whatever you want to call them) like Dave, ppbebe,nesquick, chineseblues,madagas,etc., this would be a boring place to be.

James, i was kidding.? Dave reminds me of an Alabama fan.? An Alabama football fan blindly sides with anything their team does even when the rest of the planet thinks otherwise.? I love Dave's passion.? I have been here for a long ass time.? Just don't post as much, but I am here everyday.? I love this board, 99% of what I say is sarcasm.? Whatever happened to Booker?

Thats one of the cool things about Dave. We were all once like him. Its like he's a fan from the past that was brought to the present day, and still has that mindset of 'GNR can do no wrong'. As far as Booker goes, Ocassionally I see him in The Jungle section. I also thought it was strange how he went from these constant debates about the past, to basically not even posting and hanging out in The Jungle. Maybe he's waiting for more bad news.

Daves toned it down alot recently though doncha think?

I have not toned anything down really. I just got tired of the same old debates and decided to stop going in circles.

i`m with you    axl`s cool   no matter if he`s releasing an album or not. some people have to realize he doesn`t live for their sake.....
he said that nobody should wait for it, because that way noone is dissapointed if it doesn`t come out...... i know he could treat his fans with a little more respect, but hey.....it?s axl rose....