People seem to bash finck and his playing, and talk about gnr without a lead

[Genesis]

And if you have a bad day and a concert just does't work you shoot yourself in the head, that's what you do when you don't play someone else solo note by note ...........if you really like good music regardless of gender and  labels try listen to Cirque du solei with robin's contribution, love slash to death but coul he play that? i don't think so, and still that doesen't make him any less taleted.

All right, a fuck up occasionally is ok. But Robin just loses it.

[Shoco]

and even if you hate Fincks playing live, in the studio setting he will get it perfect since he can redo parts Axl or he are not happy with.

dont do it in the studio if you cant do it live

[mikegiuliana]

being things have been redone many times from what we read over the last year or so, does anyone think that they might doctor up some of the people's playing making it seem they are more talented then they are..??
Makes me think of the simpsons episode with nsync where nelson bart milhouse and company are signed as a boy group for their look but they have that special machine that make's their voices n sound, sound great.. Computer enhancement posible..?

Axl did say he was going to introduce computers and mentioned how gnr fans might not be ready for it.. Maybe he changed his mind..
Dave of late you seem to need to convince us or reassuring yourself that the album will be good or finck can play...

[mikegiuliana]

Well, there was a 2002 tour you know...http://vitonen.net/ylimaaraiset/karri/novemberpain.mp3
Sure I will judge Robin after CD is released...but it seems that before, Slash solos are too hard for him.
To compare, It's like an average pupil trying to go to Harvard. The level requiered is too high.

your kiddin' me, dude Robin butches all his solo's, you have no idea what your taliin' about. Sure he was messy here n' there but Slash was just as, if not way worse then him.? ? Robin is a talented motherfucker man, what he does on November Rain is fucking incredible

it never shocked me when slash was off.. You are talking about  abnd filled with drunks and drug addicts.. Check out vr now slash sounds really good.. Everyone fucks up no one is perfect..

Want to hear some bad playing listen n watch rio 3.. Definetly some good points but also a lot of bad all around playing.. DOn't get me wrong they did get better

[dave-gnfnr2k]

being things have been redone many times from what we read over the last year or so, does anyone think that they might doctor up some of the people's playing making it seem they are more talented then they are..??
Makes me think of the simpsons episode with nsync where nelson bart milhouse and company are signed as a boy group for their look but they have that special machine that make's their voices n sound, sound great.. Computer enhancement posible..?

Axl did say he was going to introduce computers and mentioned how gnr fans might not be ready for it.. Maybe he changed his mind..
Dave of late you seem to need to convince us or reassuring yourself that the album will be good or finck can play...

Reassuring myself? How do you figure? With all the bullshit threads over the past weeks godforbid I post something postive about the new gnr and CD. Go figure someone talking good things about the band and  being postive. You should try it sometime

[WARose]

well ?i really like the way he plays on the old songs and he`s definitely not playing "clean", but that`s his style. it`s the same with art. you can draw something perfect and exactly the way it looks, or you concentrate on the important things and draw it in your style.

anyway i really dug his style. i think it`s just cool how he moves while he`s playing and how he`s playing and you should never take someone as lead guitarist only because you could allegedly sell more albums that way. if axl`s doing things not the way he wants just to become more popular or to be taken seriously , I won`t take him seriously anymore, but i`m quite confident that he`s doing what he wants and always will, because otherwise we`d allready have this fuckin album....

and we`ll see how robin`s doing when gnr tours again, because right now we judge him on the way he looked and played 3 years ago... ?i don`t want to say that his playing changed, but his look changed a lot as we all know... ? there was nothing wrong with his playing not changing anyway..

[younggunner]

It's Slash's solo. He can play it any fucking way he likes. But when u're playing someone else's solo, u either play it note for note or u improve upon it (which Robin can't do). You DON'T play it like Robin does.

Ok fine. Whether all you nutswingers think Robina nd or the new band butcher the old songs. WHo cares. Thats your opinion fine.

But then dont say RObin butchers the new songs. It would be like saying Slash butchers his VR songs. Their his fukin songs. RObin can do whatever he wants with them. If you dont like it move on.

[Genesis]

But then dont say RObin butchers the new songs.

We won't. 

If you dont like it move on.

And we already have. It's called VR.

[jemin]

It's Slash's solo. He can play it any fucking way he likes. But when u're playing someone else's solo, u either play it note for note or u improve upon it (which Robin can't do). You DON'T play it like Robin does.

Ok fine. Whether all you nutswingers think Robina nd or the new band butcher the old songs. WHo cares. Thats your opinion fine.

But then dont say RObin butchers the new songs. It would be like saying Slash butchers his VR songs. Their his fukin songs. RObin can do whatever he wants with them. If you dont like it move on.

I don't think anyone said he butchered the new songs at all!

[younggunner]

people on this board have said it in the past many times. And it just shows how peopel on this board always want their cake and eat it too...

[WARose]

If you dont like it move on.

And we already have. It's called VR.

and it sucks...     by the way you`re probably in the wrong section here

[Genesis]

If you dont like it move on.

And we already have. It's called VR.

and it sucks...

That's ur opinion, but it sure beats waiting infinitely for that dumbass Axl to put out an album. 

[Nytunz]

Bouth Robin and Richards are great guitarplayers! And i hope they bouth play solos!

[mikegiuliana]

being things have been redone many times from what we read over the last year or so, does anyone think that they might doctor up some of the people's playing making it seem they are more talented then they are..??
Makes me think of the simpsons episode with nsync where nelson bart milhouse and company are signed as a boy group for their look but they have that special machine that make's their voices n sound, sound great.. Computer enhancement posible..?

Axl did say he was going to introduce computers and mentioned how gnr fans might not be ready for it.. Maybe he changed his mind..
Dave of late you seem to need to convince us or reassuring yourself that the album will be good or finck can play...

Reassuring myself? How do you figure? With all the bullshit threads over the past weeks godforbid I post something postive about the new gnr and CD. Go figure someone talking good things about the band and? being postive. You should try it sometime

beside liking some of the songs and enjoying the live show I saw what can you say is positive? Failed tour, now news and it's been years since anything.. Sometimes being positive is different then being realistic..

all the threads are bullshit really, just people taking sides and being arm chair lawyers and making predictions

[phaseONE]

These threads are ALL pointless been as there is not technically speaking even a " new gnr " as nothing has been released, the so called bandmates are a revolving door and axl will deny that he did a nu-gnr 2002 tour.

So davegnfr2k and his lil` gnr clan buddies will still be convincing themselves and waiting for his hero to do something for another 20 years.
pretty sad really isnt it, all this over a band that does not exist as a band or as any other from of entity.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

These threads are ALL pointless been as there is not technically speaking even a " new gnr " as nothing has been released, the so called bandmates are a revolving door and axl will deny that he did a nu-gnr 2002 tour.

So davegnfr2k and his lil` gnr clan buddies will still be convincing themselves and waiting for his hero to do something for another 20 years.
pretty sad really isnt it, all this over a band that does not exist as a band or as any other from of entity.

The only pointless thing here is you. See me and my so called clan are FANS and are here because we want to talk about Axl and his new gnr, while  you come here just to keep saying we will waiting for 20 years and to bash Axl and the new band. Kind of pathetic when you really think aout it, dont you think?

[phaseONE]

So dave, you come here to talk about axl and his new gnr............

What exactly is going on with axl and his new gnr, because i swear time has stood still because going back a few years and nothing has changed .

Face it daveyboy the `band` is dead and buried without the people who made gnr what it is/was .

[dave-gnfnr2k]

So dave, you come here to talk about axl and his new gnr............

What exactly is going on with axl and his new gnr, because i swear time has stood still because going back a few years and nothing has changed .

Face it daveyboy the `band` is dead and buried without the people who made gnr what it is/was .

Yeah and you keep coming here to annoy people. Things never change do they? If what you said is true, why do you still post here?

[SADIS]

http://vitonen.net/ylimaaraiset/karri/novemberpain.mp3

That was horrible!

It's always hard to play someone else's solo's but here he just misses alot of notes....but still I'm curious what he's done on CD.

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

http://vitonen.net/ylimaaraiset/karri/novemberpain.mp3

That was horrible!

come it's rock n roll, drugs, alcohol .... my ears hurt....