Axl is doing the right thing

[Lord Kayoss]

The weakest moment on any GnR album was the abysmal 'My? World'.?

Yeah, "So Fine" was a great little ballad.? Not a classic, but a great listen.

"So Fine" is great until Duff ruins it with his horrible vocals.

[Rob]

I like Duff's vocals.  And I like So Fine.

[Lord Kayoss]

I like them on "Attitude" but nothing else.  His voice just annoys me.

"Yeah that made me haaaaaaaaaaaaaaapppppppppppppppppyyyyyyyyyyy!!!!"

Ugh.

[jameslofton29]

Its funny how 'So Fine' was always considered a little gem on the Illusions records until Axl started to dislike Duff. Now most GNR fans hate it. I've always loved the song, and no band members' opinion of another band member is going to change that. Some people need to stop being so fickle and enjoy GNR's albums without basing their opinion of it by what Axl says.

[Lord Kayoss]

Its funny how 'So Fine' was always considered a little gem on the Illusions records until Axl started to dislike Duff.

Right.  But I've always disliked Duff's vocals on that song.  Axl could move Duff into his L.A. home and I'd still skip over his lines on "So Fine."

[ppbebe]

Its funny how 'So Fine' was always considered a little gem on the Illusions records until Axl started to dislike Duff.

Right.  But I've always disliked Duff's vocals on that song.  Axl could move Duff into his L.A. home and I'd still skip over his lines on "So Fine."

I used to skip the whole song along with think about you and my michelle but I didn't know Duff was singing on it and Axl disliked the song?

[Bridge]

I don't necessarily think Duff can sing all that well, but his vocals suit the song well, I think.