If original GNR reformed and neither Sorum or Adler came back, who on drums?

[jarmo]

Yeah! A TR-808!

It's a techno band after all!

 



/jarmo

[Jim Bob]

keep brain.  in fact keep robin finck and tommy stinson too.     

Izzy coming back would be cool. but I'd still want Fortus in the band.  I"m happy with the band and i really dont even want the old band to reform.

[crthiel]

Stephen is a washed up junkie who isn't worthy of GnR anymore.

[hyperionmax2003]

How about one of the drummers from Spinal Tap?   

[Rock the jungle]

I'm sorry, someone would like to kill me when reads my opinion, but I think Steven Adler even though he did the appetite for destruction, he doesn't have enough level to play the Use your illusions, I think the drums from the UYI are a little bit more thecnical

I'm so sorry to say that 'cause I'm a "drummer" and I love the way he plays the drums but I think Brain has more level than Seteven.

[jameslofton29]

How about Don Henley??

[Saul]

how about this guy? He actually has the look and knows the material!

[Mama Kin]

I hate to point this out, but even if Sorum joined, it wouldn't really be the original Guns would it?

It would be the slightly-less-new Guns N' Roses..

Not to be nit-picky.

[usurper]

I'd personally go for Josh Freese, or at least Brain

[gandra]

i think that drummer from 2002 tour would be great solution.Man is great player and i like his style.
In rio Axl says Brian brain mantia,yes that is great solution.

but if they don't want members from axl inkarnation of gnr,i think that ex drummer of skid row would be great solution.

[usurper]

i think that drummer from 2002 tour would be great solution.Man is great player and i like his style.
In rio Axl says Brian brain mantia,yes that is great solution.

but if they don't want members from axl inkarnation of gnr,i think that ex drummer of skid row would be great solution.

The player from the 2002 is Brian Brain Mantia

[kaasupoltin]

Brain? Hahahahhaha. No! Stumpy Joe of course.. But does it matter anyway. Guns n' Roses is dead. All we have is some stupid fucking project that will never appear. Axl is beatin' a dead horse. The old band will never come back..

[Pandora]

The old band will never come back..

That you are right about. The rest has been beaten to death already, no need to repeat it in every thread. I think we get your point.

[Jamie]

Without one of the original drummers, it's not original GnR!

[Saul]

I was watching an allmans brothers video bootleg recently and upon seeing all those guys on stage what with two drummers I thought about how crazy it would be if every member of GNR past and present got up on stage for one show. 

So much talent between the different incarnations of the band .. wow. Adler AND Sorum back on drums , stinson and duff playing bass , ALL those guitar players. My lord. 

[ppbebe]

I was watching an allmans brothers video bootleg recently and upon seeing all those guys on stage what with two drummers I thought about how crazy it would be if every member of GNR past and present got up on stage for one show. 

So much talent between the different incarnations of the band .. wow. Adler AND Sorum back on drums , stinson and duff playing bass , ALL those guitar players. My lord. 

The Greatest reunuon ever
I think It may happen in 15yrs time...

[HK-47]

I was watching an allmans brothers video bootleg recently and upon seeing all those guys on stage what with two drummers I thought about how crazy it would be if every member of GNR past and present got up on stage for one show.?

So much talent between the different incarnations of the band .. wow. Adler AND Sorum back on drums , stinson and duff playing bass , ALL those guitar players. My lord.?

It would have to be an open air gig, putting that much ego under one roof would be a fire hazard 

[Axl4Prez2004]

My vote is for Richard Christy...of Iced Earth fame. (unfortunately, he'll be unavailable on Friday night gigs)   

[Madcap]

If Izzy, Axl, Slash and Duff would really got together I wouldn't care who's behind the drums.

drums are a major part of the band. and if you knew that, you say differently. as for the topic, i would have to go with phil rudd or the guy from zep, what's his name.

[Koskenkorvasieni]

My vote is for Richard Christy...of Iced Earth fame. (unfortunately, he'll be unavailable on Friday night gigs)   

Have any of you heard Richard Cristy's drumming in the band Death? Jaw-dropping shit, man. Well, i'ts progressive death metal, so i guess it would be too much for most of you...