No Rose

[the dirt]

What if all the current bandmembers (Robin, Richard, Tommy, Brain, and Pittman) had enough of the wait and current uncertainty of GNR and decided to kick Axl out of the band, and get another singer.
I'm not including Dizzy, cos hed probably stay faithful to Axl and continue doing Hookers n' Blow, whatever it's called.

Since Axl and all of them say what a collaborative effort it has been all the way through, they could say five sevenths of the album are their contributions and they're gonna put it out.

Imagine that they felt they gelled so well as a band that they could not put up with the "delays" anymore, and could'nt quell the desire to put out music together....

Then they go on to put out the album called Chinese Capitalism with a new singer and call their band No Rose.

People will always wonder how much of it was axl's ideas, and there will be mystery surrounding them until their second or third release, always good for a band

[thelostrose]

yawn...

[norway]

What if all the current bandmembers (Robin, Richard, Tommy, Brain, and Pittman) had enough of the wait and current uncertainty of GNR and decided to kick Axl out of the band, and get another singer.

whats it? kick axl? someone give us news, FAST? ?

funny thread dirty boy? ? ?been here long??

[ppbebe]

 
ha ha I?ll be popular here but possibly I?d be a fan if it had BH and a right singer. Oh and an original Album title and a proper Band name would help.

However that?s not happening.
Incidentally, The dirt, do you know the Yard Birds history?

[norway]

I?d be a fan if it had BH and a right singer. Oh and an original Album title and a proper Band name would help.

guess your'e all covered already then

this is pure fiction right?

[alternativemonkey]

On the surface, the idea is utterly ridiculous.

However, I've always wondered if Billy Howerdel and Josh Freese had stayed in GNR would the new GNR sound something like a Perfect Circle? Imagine a Perfect Circle with Axl as lead vocalist instead of Maynard Keenan.

[the dirt]

ha ha I?ll be popular here

Who cares, you'd be getting new music!

but possibly I?d be a fan if it had BH and a right singer.

The chances of buckethead rejoining may be greater with Axl out of the picture.

Oh and an original Album title and a proper Band name would help.

Sure. I just put in the album title and band name in for comedic purposes

However that?s not happening.

Neither is anything else.

Incidentally, The dirt, do you know the Yard Birds history?

No, I don't. But i suspect it's along the lines I've presented here...

On the surface, the idea is utterly ridiculous.

Why? You don't beleive they are highly creative players? hmm...

VR is 3/5 Classic GNR. And Izzy even jammed with them.

[norway]

VR is 3/5 Classic GNR. And Izzy even jammed with them.

pfft 2\3?

Chinese Capitalism with a new singer and call their band No Rose.

? fun

the fantasy is running wild lately, like if axl was born a woman (which was a funny thread too )...? ?
hence

However that?s not happening.

Neither is anything else.

whoah, suppose you have a point

sure i check out the disc

[Narcissa]

What if all the current bandmembers (Robin, Richard, Tommy, Brain, and Pittman) had enough of the wait and current uncertainty of GNR and decided to kick Axl out of the band, and get another singer.

that would be super-funny. As would their record sales.

[Nytunz]

On the surface, the idea is utterly ridiculous.

However, I've always wondered if Billy Howerdel and Josh Freese had stayed in GNR would the new GNR sound something like a Perfect Circle? Imagine a Perfect Circle with Axl as lead vocalist instead of Maynard Keenan.

 Yes, and maybe Maynard could concentrate on working with Tool only! huh, im a APC fan, dont get me wrong, but i guess the songs they have made, would never be, if it wasent for Maynard! The most intresting duo in the world, would be Axl Rose and Maynard James Keenan.