Would re-recording AFD be for the wrong reasons?

[providman]

Why stop with AFD? Axl should set his sights for bigger & better things - Maybe he should re-record "The Wall", "The Joshua Tree", "Abbey Road", "10", "Nothing's Shocking", Highway 61 Revisited", "Born in the USA", "Tommy", "Hotel California", Pet Sounds", "Paint it Black", "Joe's Garage", "Physical Grafitti", the possibilities are ENDLESS. And with such stellar musicians like Dizzy Reed & Tommy Stinson, surely they could improve on the originals, like they did with the AFD tunes they played live & supposedly, ahem, re-recorded.(no disrespect to TS & DR intended).

[Pandora]

Very funny providman. Keep your smart-ass remarks for yourself please.

[Eva GnRAxlRosette]

I'd love to hear a re-recorded version of AFD by the new Guns lineup.
 

[Drew]

A re-recorded version of AFD = 

I'd love it! Plus the idea of having the new versions of You Could Be Mine and Patience. That'd be sweet!

[Saul]

I'd buy it just for the new COVER!!!

Would axl's "skull" be sporting braids? Would robins skull have that mullet style hairdo? Would brain be wearing his buckethat? Would buckethead have a mask on or just a skull?!

OH MY GOD! 

 

[erose]

I think it would suck bigtime if they released that. No matter what the reason behind it is. If Steven, Duff, Axl, Izzy and Slash would re-record it I would consider buying it, otherwise it would just suck. Not because I hate the new line-up or what so ever, but AFD was made by 5 people, and if there would come a new version it should be by those 5 people. Otherwise it would be a remix album.

and a remix album kind of reminds me of that last bon jovi shit, this left feels right [puke]

as a hardcore fan i would buy it of course, but i don't think i would like it much like the greatest hits album which didn't have any of the members blessing. it would rip off the old members royalties and shit like that which would be really sorry.

the best thing would just to get a hold of a boot of the rerecorded afd so that we could hear it.. 

[Scabbie]

as a hardcore fan i would buy it of course, but i don't think i would like it much like the greatest hits album which didn't have any of the members blessing. it would rip off the old members royalties and shit like that which would be really sorry.

the best thing would just to get a hold of a boot of the rerecorded afd so that we could hear it..?

Or produce a limited edition official release to the fan club which doesn't currently exist!