Pick your album MVP's

[Fretzo]

Who do you think was the Most Valuable Player on each of the 4 major GNR releases?

Album? ? ? ? ? ? Player? ? ? ? ? ?Why?
AFD? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Slash? ? ? ? ? ? ?He created 2 of the most momorable riffs in rock history
Lies? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Izzy? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Where would that album be without "Patience"?
UYI1? ? ? ? ? ? ? Izzy? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?He was the main songwriter on that album, he made it rock
UYI2? ? ? ? ? ? ? Axl? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Not only did he write the lyrics on most of the songs but he also wrote alot of the music

To argue with my list make your own?

[SON OF A PREACHER]

AFD? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?AXL                  the extremely high pitch vocals, the look, the edgy look on his nutty face
Lies? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Izzy? ? ? ? ? ? ?     ?Where would that album be without "Patience"?
UYI1? ? ? ? ? ? ?Shannon Hoon   You aint the first ? ? ? ? ? ? ?     
UYI2? ? ? ? ? ? ? Axl? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?   estranged

[Agno]

No one in the band is more valuable than the others. It is a band that have made music together.

[Dave_Rose]

No one in the band is more valuable than the others. It is a band that have made music together.

True I think all players come together well Axl N' Slash on Sweet Child O' Mine from AFD for the loveable lyrics from Axl and the greatest guitar riff ever just my example of it.

[Ignatius]

Lies? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Izzy? ? ? ? ? ? ? ?Where would that album be without "Patience"?

How do you know Izzy wrote Patience?

[ktucker450]

Appetite = Axl
Lies = Izzy
Use Your Illusion 1 = Axl or Slash, give or take
Use Your Illusion 2 = Axl