Civil War from House of Blues rehearsals!

[0001001]

Some guy at the hub gave me the clip.
The original filename  was Guns N' Roses - Civil War (House of Blues Rehearsal).mp3

Since the new band has never played civil war live I wonder if this track is fake.
So everybody should listen to the track and we'll se if it's axl's voice and the new band playing:

www.8ung.at/karle34/gnr_civilwar_hob_reh.mp3

[Dave_Rose]

Axl voice is very faint sounds like him but dont know if its the new band or not

[RnT]

it?s him
no, wait, it?s not him
it?s him
no, wait, it?s not him...
it?s him
no, wait, it?s no...

[Neemo]

Its hard to say if its even gnr cause the vocals are so low but near the end of it the "Yeah" does sound like Axl but before that he's pretty sketchy on vocals but its supposed to be rehearsal right? and maybe at the time they hadn't had it down properly to play live (not enough practice?) But even so there is no solo in it (thats where it cuts off) so its hard to determine who the guitarist sound like (Slash, Robin or Bucket).  But thats only my opinion. Good find though!!!

[W 23 Axl]

r u guys kidding me?


this is probably some shit local band from the mid-west with too much time on their hands.

how in the world do any of you think this is actually something axl would be a part of? LOLOL This is horrible!!! the singer is also a bad Axl impersonator...

[littleredcorvette]

That is so blatantly New Axl at the end. Come on! It's a textbook 2000-2002 end of song 'yeeaahh'.

I'm not surprised they didn't do it. He sounds like shit on the chorus as he tries to force a the growl.

What REALLY bothers me was this was 2000 (or 2001?) and it's a reminder of how much his voice has changed again. I've written extensively on here in support of his new vocals on the road but OMG suggested heavily that the album was really meant to be due in 2000 at the latest. But now, four years on, how much might his voice have deteriorated since then? How much longer can he make a reasonable effort on songs he recorded in 1987?

[Voodoochild]

It's not newgnr. The guitar is so like Slash, guess it's some GNR cover band.

[jarmo]

Sounds like somebody took part of the old demo/rehearsal version from 1989 (?) and did something with it.



/jarmo

[nesquick]

BULLSHIT
the instrumental part is Karaoke. I have the same on my computer. the singer is amateur. Just a guy who tries to sing like Axl.
Jarmo, you can lock this thread.

[younggunner]

What REALLY bothers me was this was 2000 (or 2001?) and it's a reminder of how much his voice has changed again. I've written extensively on here in support of his new vocals on the road but OMG suggested heavily that the album was really meant to be due in 2000 at the latest. But now, four years on, how much might his voice have deteriorated since then?

To reiterate what Axl said in Rio....

Some people have really no idea whats goin on....

[jarmo]

the instrumental part is Karaoke.

If by karaoke you mean instrumental, then it's correct.

As far as I know, some tracks from the 1989 sessions were bootlegged and Civil War is one of the songs....



/jarmo

[DRUNK]

That is so blatantly New Axl at the end. Come on! It's a textbook 2000-2002 end of song 'yeeaahh'.

I'm not surprised they didn't do it. He sounds like shit on the chorus as he tries to force a the growl.

What REALLY bothers me was this was 2000 (or 2001?) and it's a reminder of how much his voice has changed again. I've written extensively on here in support of his new vocals on the road but OMG suggested heavily that the album was really meant to be due in 2000 at the latest. But now, four years on, how much might his voice have deteriorated since then? How much longer can he make a reasonable effort on songs he recorded in 1987?

You clearly understand nothing.

Axl's new voice is not deteriorating.

Oh My God had like 7 vocal effects.  You didn't know that?

[dave-gnfnr2k]

That is not even close to being axl just like my fave pillow wasnt.
Anyone who thinks this is Axl is being a fool

[nesquick]

If by karaoke you mean instrumental, then it's correct.

euhhh...don't you know what is karaoke?
Karaoke is Karaoke can't explain it. It's done by professional musicians and then you add your voice on it. It's not the band instrumental at all. karaoke of GN'R can be made by unknown australian or french or spanish or whatever musicians. Do you see what I mean?

[jarmo]

If by karaoke you mean instrumental, then it's correct.

euhhh...don't you know what is karaoke?
Karaoke is Karaoke can't explain it. It's done by professional musicians and then you add your voice on it. It's not the band instrumental at all. karaoke of GN'R can be made by unknown australian or french or spanish or whatever musicians. Do you see what I mean?

I know what karaoke is. I don't think it's a karaoke version, I think it's an instrumental demo.

Here's the song with vocals.Do you think Axl's singing over a karaoke tape?

Civil War (Right Click & Save Target As)




/jarmo

[nesquick]

I know what karaoke is. I don't think it's a karaoke version, I think it's an instrumental demo.

I didn't know it was a real instrumental demo. I have it without the vocals. I can try to sing it in the futur.

[COLDHEARTBREAKER]

If by karaoke you mean instrumental, then it's correct.

euhhh...don't you know what is karaoke?
Karaoke is Karaoke can't explain it. It's done by professional musicians and then you add your voice on it. It's not the band instrumental at all. karaoke of GN'R can be made by unknown australian or french or spanish or whatever musicians. Do you see what I mean?

I know what karaoke is. I don't think it's a karaoke version, I think it's an instrumental demo.

Here's the song with vocals.Do you think Axl's singing over a karaoke tape?

Civil War (Right Click & Save Target As)




/jarmo

Cival War has not been released as a karaoke track yet on any of the cdg, dvd or laserdisc karaoke labels!