Just Curious....But where ........

[DaMaMaXiMuS]

Hi everyone,

I'm just curious to know where do you rank CD songs you've heard (bootlegz) among the old GNR stuff? Heck, I'd even like to read if anyone would throw any of the Hollywood Rose tracks into the their mix of top songs.  So let's see them people?  Give us your top 10, or top 15.

D

[justynius]

My top 15 with the CD songs (no covers)...

1. The General, hopefully
2. Estranged
3. November Rain
4. The Blues
5. Patience
6. Sweet Child O' Mine
7. Chinese Democracy
8. Welcome to the Jungle
9. One in a Million
10. Civil War
11. Don't Cry
12. You Could Be Mine
13. It's So Easy
14. Nightrain
15. Yesterdays

If you want to include Velvet Revolver too, I'd probably put Slither in the 7/8 range. Madagascar and Oh My God would probably make the top 20.

[YouCouldBeMine]

Madagascar is higher then 20 bro..

[axl_rose_700]

Madagascar is higher then 20 bro..

Obviously in HIS opinion it's not!

[Nytunz]

 1 WTTJ
 2 Silkworms
 3 Coma
 4 Madag.
 5 Nov R.
 6 ChinesD.
 7 The Blues
 8 Breakdown
 9 Get In The Ring
10 Back Of B.
11 Dont Damn Me
12 Paradice C
13 Dont Cry
14 Mr. Brownst.
15 Locomotive
16 Civil War

and so on! Thats my list for today! But this Change every day! nr. 16 can become nr one in a couple of days! But i got faith in the new songs! And i like what i have heard! And thats why theyre on the top of the list! Remember we havent heard the Studioversions yet! Im Sure Silkworms is will KickASS! Silkworms!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Izzy]

I'd put Madagascar, Chinese Democracy and the Blues in my top 10 - with OMG at no.2 (no.1 is 14 years, and always has been)

[HoldenCaulfield]

1. Madagascar
2. The Blues
3. Coma
4. November Rain
5. Chinese Democracy
6. Welcome to the Jungle
7. Paradise City
8. Sweet Child O'Mine
9. Oh My God
10. Riyadh and the Bedouins
11. Mr. Brownstone
12. Silkworms
13. Civil War
14. Nightrain
15. Out ta Get Me

[Fuckin' Gunner]

01. November Rain
02. Breakdown
03. Estranged
04. Welcome to the Jungle
05. Sweet Child O' Mine
06. Rocket Queen
07. Madagascar
08. You Could be Mine
09. Coma
10. Perfect Crime

On my TOP 20 - Oh My God, Chinese Democracy and The Blues

Hopefully 'The General' and 'This I Love' will be on my TOP 10. I like the ideas the songs seems to have (well, pure imogination of mine, anyway)

[justynius]

Hopefully 'The General' and 'This I Love' will be on my TOP 10.

I'm guessing "This I Love" might be one of those songs we never hear because of legal complications.

[jungleman_83]

1 Estranged
2 Paradice City
3 WTTJ
4 SCOM
5 November Rain
6 Civil War
7 Dead Horse
8 The Blues
9 Brownstone
10 Nightrain
11 Rocket Queen
12 Don't Damn Me
13 Yesterdays
14 Coma
15 One In A Million

Fuck I love them all.  Out of the new songs that I've heard, The Blues and Madagascar are really great.  They get stuck in my head at work and I just have ta go home and pop in one of the concerts and watch them.

[Izzy]

Hopefully 'The General' and 'This I Love' will be on my TOP 10.

I'm guessing "This I Love" might be one of those songs we never hear because of legal complications.

Either give some kind of info to back this up or stop bringing guesswork to the board disguised as insight

'This i love' is written soley by Axl - therefore unless he is sueing himself how can there be a legal complication with the song that would prevent it from being released?

[Mr Cowbell ?]

I never heard of IS THIS LOVE? Which article was it mentioned in?

[DJM]

1 Its so easy
2 Nightrain
3 Sweet child o mine
4 The Blues
5 Live & Let Die
6 Welcome to the Jungle
7 Rocket Queen
8 Coma
9 Pretty tied up
10 Cival War

[Walk]

This love is an awesome Pantera song.  

[SlashFan]

 1.WTTJ
 2.SCOM
 3.OH My God
 4.Noverber Rain
 5.The Blues
 6.Paradise City
 7.Anything Goes
 8.You're Crazy(Live)
 9.Civil War
10.Reckless Life

[99 Problems]

1. Sweet Child O' Mine
2. November Rain
3. Patience
4. Estranged
5. Welcome to the Jungle
6. Paradise City
7. Civil War
8. The Blues
9. Coma
10. It's So Easy
11. Madagascar

I think Chinese Democracy (the song) would rate after any AFD stuff......Oh My God before any live like a suicide stuff and silkworms probably one of the last 3 fav.

[YouCouldBeMine]

1. Estranged (Life era)
2. Yesterdays
3. November Rain
4. Madagascar
5. Oh My God
6. Rocket Queen (life era)
7. Chinese Democracy
8. Sweet Child of Mine
9. You Could be mine
10. Paradise City
11. Patience
12. Move to the City
13. Welcome
14. Knockin on Heavens Door
15. MY Michelle

[justynius]

Hopefully 'The General' and 'This I Love' will be on my TOP 10.

I'm guessing "This I Love" might be one of those songs we never hear because of legal complications.

Either give some kind of info to back this up or stop bringing guesswork to the board disguised as insight

'This i love' is written soley by Axl - therefore unless he is sueing himself how can there be a legal complication with the song that would prevent it from being released?

"This I Love" was around during the Illusions era - we have articles to back that up. Considering this fact, it is not out of the realm of possibility that legal implications prevent anyone - Axl included - from releasing it unless there is a reunion. Remember, legally the Guns N' Roses of today is an entirely different band, just with the old name. Any work done with Old GN'R (regardless of whether its released) is probably out of bounds.

Also, out of all of the New GN'R interviews, Axl rants, etc. we haven't seen it mentioned once. If "This I Love" is the epic as was initially hyped as, don't you think it would receive some kind of mention (ala "Catcher in the Rye" and "The General")?

[ktucker450]

Well my favourite Guns N' Roses song is Knockin on Heaven's Door but I remember reading somewhere no covers so here's my all GNR original list.

1. Sweet Child O' Mine
2. Welcome to the Jungle
3. Rocket Queen
4. November Rain
5. Don't Cry and Don't Cry [alt. lyrics]
6. Mr. Brownstone
7. Patience
8. Estranged
9. My Michelle
10. Breakdown
11. Paradise City
12. Rhiad and the Bedouins
13. It's So Easy
14. One in a Million
15. Chinese Democracy