Who thinks Axl is cool?

[Izzy]

As you can see, I dont disagree with the frontman thing, its the greatest musician deal that is ludicrous.  

In YOUR OPINION its ludicrous

Why the fuck would ur opinion be worth more than mine?

Also if we want to make this really really nasty

Axl was given credit for 41% of AFD, the largest stake...........

Don't see why u have a problem with me saying i greatly admire Axl as a musician.......GNR was a group effort and i see all their roles as vital. I just admire Axl most.

[Doc Emmett Brown]

huh... isnt point 1 and 2 just about the same thing? and the third for that sake, jeez, just say it! you want axl to play on time... yeah?  

hey, atleast, when he blew of philly show axl was in the same country, he didnt decide to be in another country for some longer 'cuz he may like it..... *caugh-france-norway-caugh*

now, that is worse than that deal....

Finally! a reply with some humor!

Yeah, the Norway France thing was just fucked up.  Did he ever give an explanation for that either?

People attend GNR concerts knowing full well that he's gonna be late. I know it's not ideal, but nobody forces anyone to buy a ticket.

[Captain P?l]

huh... isnt point 1 and 2 just about the same thing? and the third for that sake, jeez, just say it! you want axl to play on time... yeah?  

hey, atleast, when he blew of philly show axl was in the same country, he didnt decide to be in another country for some longer 'cuz he may like it..... *caugh-france-norway-caugh*

now, that is worse than that deal....

Finally! a reply with some humor!

Yeah, the Norway France thing was just fucked up.  Did he ever give an explanation for that either?

People attend GNR concerts knowing full well that he's gonna be late. I know it's not ideal, but nobody forces anyone to buy a ticket.

i never heard any exuce... but if someone know of it, please post it?  

[Doc Emmett Brown]

If u don't like Axl Rose.....why post on this site?

Izzy, it's time I confess,

I only post on this site b/c I like Chris Pittman...

[Izzy]

If u don't like Axl Rose.....why post on this site?

Izzy, it's time I confess,

I only post on this site b/c I like Chris Pittman...

 

A fellow Member of the Order of Chris Pittman!

I will not rest till i have atleast seen evidence this man is real.....i still don't believe he exists!

[the dirt]

Axl was given credit for 41% of AFD, the largest stake...........

And this monetary squabbling of who put in most was a major reason things fucked up for them.........

[madagas]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

[Izzy]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

Booker will get ya for that......

He is clearly the most important member......but it was Axl, Slash, Steven, Duff and Izzy that made GNR.

[Doc Emmett Brown]

He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

huh? you're assessing his musical contribution to the band based on the band's name?  

He was/is the most famous member of the past/present GNR, but the music came from all of them.

[madagas]

Please read the post again....Axl is responsible for 41% of the music/writing as agreed upon by the band-testified to in court and apparently Slash came up with the system. If you couple that 41% with the fact that Axl image wise is the most recognizable of the members, he can easily be said to be half of the Gnr brand. Contributions from Gilby-Steven-Matt-even Duff are no where near as important as that of the singer and main lyric writer of the group. I was just using a play on words....

[Doc Emmett Brown]

Contributions from Gilby-Steven-Matt-even Duff are no where near as important as that of the singer and main lyric writer of the group. I was just using a play on words....

What was Izzy Stradlin's percentage contribution as agreed upon by the band? Does anyone know?  He was also a main lyric writer and musician for the group.

It seems like Mr. Rose took your play on words seriously and replaced all the old Guns with new ones.  But I guess he can do that seeing as he is 41%.

[John Daniels]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

well here we have a nice little post..we have these nice numbers also, I guess the person who has more percent counted is the most important hit machine.. the fact is no one really knows except the ex-members and Axl who made that riff and how did that melody got done.. and I don't really see any logic with this 'making Appetit' one when someone throws these percents to the game..does everyone know how many percent is the riff of Jungle..and what about the riff of SCOM..umm, it would be nice to know how many percents snatches the solo of PC...fuck that...Axl is very talented and was very important figure in making Appetite like others were..for fuck sake's, little bit credit for Izzy, Duff and Slash also..let's just leave these percents out of the game.

[POPmetal]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

well here we have a nice little post..we have these nice numbers also, I guess the person who has more percent counted is the most important hit machine.. the fact is no one really knows except the ex-members and Axl who made that riff and how did that melody got done.. and I don't really see any logic with this 'making Appetit' one when someone throws these percents to the game..does everyone know how many percent is the riff of Jungle..and what about the riff of SCOM..umm, it would be nice to know how many percents snatches the solo of PC...fuck that...Axl is very talented and was very important figure in making Appetite like others were..for fuck sake's, little bit credit for Izzy, Duff and Slash also..let's just leave these percents out of the game.

[Booker Floyd]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

well here we have a nice little post..we have these nice numbers also, I guess the person who has more percent counted is the most important hit machine.. the fact is no one really knows except the ex-members and Axl who made that riff and how did that melody got done.. and I don't really see any logic with this 'making Appetit' one when someone throws these percents to the game..does everyone know how many percent is the riff of Jungle..and what about the riff of SCOM..umm, it would be nice to know how many percents snatches the solo of PC...fuck that...Axl is very talented and was very important figure in making Appetite like others were..for fuck sake's, little bit credit for Izzy, Duff and Slash also..let's just leave these percents out of the game.

Thats right, youve got nothing to say...

Good post John.

[POPmetal]

I believe it was 41% of the catalog, not just AFD. I would say that Axl is about half of the whole (old) Gnr picture.....image and writing mixed together. He is and was the voice of the band and the most famous/notorious of the members. He was the Roses and the rest of the band was the Guns. To say Axl is one fifth of the group is silly.

well here we have a nice little post..we have these nice numbers also, I guess the person who has more percent counted is the most important hit machine.. the fact is no one really knows except the ex-members and Axl who made that riff and how did that melody got done.. and I don't really see any logic with this 'making Appetit' one when someone throws these percents to the game..does everyone know how many percent is the riff of Jungle..and what about the riff of SCOM..umm, it would be nice to know how many percents snatches the solo of PC...fuck that...Axl is very talented and was very important figure in making Appetite like others were..for fuck sake's, little bit credit for Izzy, Duff and Slash also..let's just leave these percents out of the game.

Thats right, youve got nothing to say...

Good post John.

No, actually I didn't think it needed explanation since I figured most poeple with an IQ of 80 or higher can see how pathetic the post was. Apparently I was wrong. Saying that Axl did 41% of the writing is not taking all the credit form the other members. It leaves 59% of the credit to Izzy, Duff, and Slahs, that's more than "a little bit credit." Also, its funny how people want to "leave out" things that don't mesh well with their "argument."

[Izzy]

It leaves 59% of the credit to Izzy, Duff, and Slahs, that's more than "a little bit credit." Also, its funny how people want to "leave out" things that don't mesh well with their "argument."

Haha...what about Steven?

Funny how people want to leave things out  

[POPmetal]

It leaves 59% of the credit to Izzy, Duff, and Slahs, that's more than "a little bit credit." Also, its funny how people want to "leave out" things that don't mesh well with their "argument."

Haha...what about Steven?

Funny how people want to leave things out  

Well, even if you include Steven, that's still more than a little bit of credit so it has no bearing on my argument. I didn't include him only because all reliable sources say he didn't write almost anything.

Oh yeah, and before someone corrects me again, I better mention that, according to himself, Tracii Guns wrote the entire AFD album and the other members are nothing. So don't ya'll jump on me for leaving that out.

[Thumper]

Hmmmm...no.  No thank you I'd rather not.

Note to POPmetal please do not post smiley only posts.  

[Dave_Rose]

Well all I can say is that we dont know Axl State of mind he could be trying to get this album and get everything fact is we dont know nothing about GN'R I mean by saying is whats gonna happen in the next 6 months? Axl is great and Axl has changed his attitude in some ways but turning up the shows would be a thing that I dont think he has changed on. Well I dont know nothing!

[Chief]

ummm YEAH