Richard Fortus 'I Have No Idea What's Going On' With Guns N' Roses

[Lord Stan]

GNR is definitely a band , stupid non-argument 

Of course it's a band. I absolutely hate that incorrect perception that a couple without kids is not a family. Of course it's a family.

However, in this Guns' situation I believe they are a band but none of them have current contracts. It's a bit like sometimes sportsmen train off-season with their old teams while looking for their next appointment.

[EmilyGNR]

GNR is definitely a band , stupid non-argument 

Of course it's a band. I absolutely hate that incorrect perception that a couple without kids is not a family. Of course it's a family.

However, in this Guns' situation I believe they are a band but none of them have current contracts. It's a bit like sometimes sportsmen train off-season with their old teams while looking for their next appointment.

I can appreciate and respect that view.

What gets me are the people that blindly insist that GNR is "not a band" or that "It is not GNR" they are in error on both counts- it IS a band and they can choose to like it or not, support it or not-  but they absolutely do not get to determine what is GNR and what is not.

[Wooody]

At least Tommy admitted it months ago and multiple times....he hasn't contradicted himself. I would lean heavily towards none of the modern lineup knowing what is going to happen next. They have been paid for the work they did and now have to wait to see if they get another job offer. Simple as that.

Yup, they were hired for the job. The job is over. Maybe contracts are up. They have no say. It's not truly a band as Axl calls ALL the shots. Cold hard truth as much as we want to think it's a "band". Sorry if that offends anyone but that's the way I see it. 

It offends nobody that you are incorrect, it just makes you look dumb.

band
[band]
noun
[C] (MUSICIANS)
? a ​group of ​musicians who ​play ​music together, esp. ​popular ​music:
a ​jazz/​rock band
a ​marching/​military band

GNR is definitely a band , stupid non-argument 

I don't think it makes him look dumb. Its an opinion.

[HBK]

GNR is definitely a band , stupid non-argument 

Of course it's a band. I absolutely hate that incorrect perception that a couple without kids is not a family. Of course it's a family.

However, in this Guns' situation I believe they are a band but none of them have current contracts. It's a bit like sometimes sportsmen train off-season with their old teams while looking for their next appointment.

I can appreciate and respect that view.

What gets me are the people that blindly insist that GNR is "not a band" or that "It is not GNR" they are in error on both counts- it IS a band and they can choose to like it or not, support it or not-  but they absolutely do not get to determine what is GNR and what is not.

The True Hurts