Who wants Brain out?

[the dirt]

People have been replaced so many times over now. Chances are slim to none it was fan orchestrated.

[jeorose]

everybody bitches and moans.."i want this dude out out, i want this dude in blahblahblah fucking blah", peopl never can know what that or this would sound like with different people,be happy with what u got in guns and hey its really pretty damn good what we have so shut the fuck up and jerk your i have too much time on my hands i want brain out bullshit or mother fucker we can get in the ring,,...nothing personal .....

Dont get mad dude just relax and have fun, we all giving our opinions. Just remember this is america  (freedom of speech),
you could get in the ring anytime you want to go in the ring,you could shit anytime, and you could talk shit about me. I dont give a fuck.

[VolcomStone]

who cares.  this is pointless.  nobody cares if your dream theater or (vinne whatever the shit his name is) is a good drummer or is better drummer than brain.  brain is an excellent drummer for gnr.  it would be retarded to replace him with either of those lame-asses.  we get it - some people can play things others can't.  maybe there is a little more to being a musician than just being able to everything under the sun.  some people think dave grohl is the best drummer out there, others think john frusciante is the best guitarist.... it's not all about technicalities... a lot is about style and how good the music is that those musicians create.  stop posting links of old drummers' videos... i'm not impressed

[jeorose]

who cares.  this is pointless.  nobody cares if your dream theater or (vinne whatever the shit his name is) is a good drummer or is better drummer than brain.  brain is an excellent drummer for gnr.  it would be retarded to replace him with either of those lame-asses.  we get it - some people can play things others can't.  maybe there is a little more to being a musician than just being able to everything under the sun.  some people think dave grohl is the best drummer out there, others think john frusciante is the best guitarist.... it's not all about technicalities... a lot is about style and how good the music is that those musicians create.  stop posting links of old drummers' videos... i'm not impressed

good job you are giving your opinion

[JDA]

Quit making these threads.   It is so dumb to keep putting the newer guys down.  I love the new songs and he's apart of that so I like him.  I think he is a good drummer and I don't want another new guy.  Let's try to make this GN'R a band.  That means being together for a while. 

[the dirt]

who cares.? this is pointless.? nobody cares if your dream theater or (vinne whatever the shit his name is) is a good drummer or is better drummer than brain.? brain is an excellent drummer for gnr.? it would be retarded to replace him with either of those lame-asses.? we get it - some people can play things others can't.? maybe there is a little more to being a musician than just being able to everything under the sun.? some people think dave grohl is the best drummer out there, others think john frusciante is the best guitarist.... it's not all about technicalities... a lot is about style and how good the music is that those musicians create.? stop posting links of old drummers' videos... i'm not impressed

Read the thread and why I mentioned the things I did. I actually agree with a couple of things you barked on about there.