Greatest Movie Survivor? Genres and Decades discussion

[Neemo]

so would it maybe be better then to just go decades and do the top 15 of each decade instead of top ten and forget about genres? then take top 3 or 4 of each decade and throw them in a big elimination thread at the end?

or do we stick with genres and then if a movie has 2 or more genres then it's considered eligible for both? i still think if we do genres that we find a way to break it down and go Major genres and Sub-genres

I really do like the concept of the genres though and if a movie makes it in once then it can't be nominated again...if possible i wanna go this route

[supaplex]

maybe we can go with genres and decades. we would have 4 big genres and 4 "decades" which means 16 rounds of voting and one big final with maybe 4-6 wildcards. and we could decide what movie belongs to what genre in the nominations part of the voting?

[Neemo]

maybe we can go with genres and decades. we would have 4 big genres and 4 "decades" which means 16 rounds of voting and one big final with maybe 4-6 wildcards. and we could decide what movie belongs to what genre in the nominations part of the voting?

or if a movie is voted into the final portion it is no longer eligible

[Genesis]

I'd go with the genre and decade format as well. There are too many different types of movies to ignore genres. That would be like comparing a RnR song to a pop song. Won't work.

Genre should be the main type of classification. Decade should be included just to make things more managable.