Here Today... Gone To Hell!

do you think , there`s a possibility to see COMA live again some day ?

just a question ...... just for fun !

with the new line up  !! OF COURSE

Well, we've got Estranged now, so I guess anything's possible.... but I can't see it happening

I've always felt removing the Live and Let Die's and Heaven's Doors and replacing with Epic Gnr numbers would be a good way to go

yeah youre right !!


cmon uncle AXL ,  we want COMA !!!    maybe better next time  ;)

 THANX for an awesome TOUR !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Something weird happened last night in Rosario.


There was this girl with a piece of paper with "Coma" on it. Axl read it, the girl throwed him the paper and Axl kicked it.



I don't know if this means something...I don't think so...but it was something related with 'Coma' that happened yesterday...

intersting !!

Knockin On Heavens Door really showcases Axl's singing ability so I never want that to go

I thought about this and I would really like to see it but I really doubt it as its considered a Slash song

Yeah, it's a Slash song. Not happening.  :no:

Whilst I love the inclusion of Estranged in the current set and hope I get the chance to experience it live, I'd prefer to hear more tracks from CD before adding in further old songs.  Although, if the option to extend the set and include new and old was there, I'd really like to hear what this band makes of Breakdown and Civil War.

I thought that myth that Slash brought "Coma" to the band as a finished song was debunked years ago....

+ 1,000 to this one.  I think there is so much great material off of the "Illusions" that gets looked over for these 2 songs.  The thing is both of those songs were very popular radio hits for the band, so a generic rock crowd would much rather hear those songs instead of "Breakdown" or "Locomotive."

I thought I read that Slash had brought in the music, or most of, but no lyrics.
Who knows.
Regardless, it's a Guns N' Roses song.
It's obviously guitar driven, but it's not the epic it is without the brilliant lyrics Axl put down.

The last 2 minutes of Coma are some of my favorite lyrics of all time.
In my opinion, it's one of the songs where Axl went from being a good, to amazing lyricist.

That said, Axl referred to Coma as Slash's baby in an old Kurt Loder interview if I'm not mistaken, so not sure he's chomping at the bit to revisit it anytime soon.

I recall it being called girth as a working title. N' I think Axl said he passed out while writing lyrics to it..
I't's a very dramatic song that I don't think translates well live..

I don't think it matters what form of contribution former members have done, in terms of "new gnr" performing any of the old songs.
I used to think so, and Estranged was one of the songs I thought they'd never play again, basically because of "Slash"'s guitarparts.
Axl even credited him in the liner notes for the killer guitarsolos on that song. But then, BOOM, we got blown away the last couple of weeks when they decided to bring it back... and it sounded amazing...

Coma is an amazing song too, so if they feel like playing it one day, I welcome it with open arms  : ok:

-Eirik

just a matter of us fans teaming up, and when Bumble wants solo input next.....the answer should be COMA....
all the solos Bumble have played involving the earlier works of Guns N Roses has lead up to a performance, however rare and far apart shit has still been performed live....
so, get Bumble to incorporate Coma into a solo, and sooner or later we'll get the whole thing!

this would be awesome but i dont see it happening 1 its a slash song 2 they hardly ever played it 3 its a really hard song to sing

you never know :hihi:

but. i think breakdown could be possible i dont know why but i just have that feeling ... also pretty tied up cameo ???

anyways illusinos are my fav thing ever in anything  :rofl: so now when i think about it anything would be possible. anything

That's "crap".


Yes Slash was in Guns and on Jungle (and the whole I came to him for his riff is as much crap as him saying he brought Locomotive and Coma in as complete songs) and he has rights to perform it but not to be represented in this context in association with Guns. And since they weren't granted the license it'll take some sorting.

Slash brought the song to the band. No one said it was completed. I think Axl had something to do with arrangement.

Coma would be amazing!

coma is the best GNR song ever@ in my opinion. And the last 2 minutes and Axl lyrics and voice, MADE that song. Its incredible! :o

Is as much an Axl song as it is Slash's... On the Making of Estranged he says that Estranged and Coma were the heavieast song he's ever written. At least til that point. Idk how he feels now...
And of course i would love Coma. But, I remember me asking for just one "new" song(old or new) so now that its happened im not gonna be expecting/demanding another one. At least til Next year  :hihi:
Im fine with the current setlist that includes Estranged.  Btw, Coma is the greatest song ever...

We need to start a "Coma" campaign like we did Estranged


Nonsense he wouldn't play it cause its a Slash song.. Hell SCOM intro is all Slash and one of the most famous guitar riffs of all time and they still play it every night.

Hey folks, I'm new here but I think i agree with most fans choosing Breakdown or coma.  That said, Get in the Ring with entirely updated lyrics as a one time shout down to the current detractors out there would be pretty awesome as well.  There's have to be something for all those folks that have only negative things to say about Axl but are at loss to explain just why in the hell they run to read every effin' article written about the guy.  Maybe something about Cobain not being man enough to handle his smack(hey, it's been long enough) and an ass-stomping to all those pathetic bloggers that can't seem to get their facts/dates/hairstyles/weights correct.  But in the meantime Coma and Breakdown should suffice.

It would be cool if they did Dead Horse too!

I don't see it happening.  Even back in the day, the band played Estranged a lot more than Coma.  They aren't just gonna learn the whole song to play it once or twice, let alone ever play it regularly.   I'd rather hear TWAT at this this point or Catcher. 

I agree. Altho Coma is my all time fav, on this tour I would rather hear TWAT or Prostitute... i say this but once the come on stage i dont really care what song they play  :smoking:

If I remember correct, the music to Coma was written by Slash and the Lyrics by Axl, so its kinda fifty-fifty. However, I don't think that song will make it to the setlist as a regular, since it wan't played that often even back in  the UYI tour. Dead Horse would be cool, however at this point I'd be more interested in hearing new stuff, unreleased stuff from the forthcoming successor to CD.

No.

Classic..Short, Sweet N' to the Point!!!

I think Prostitute is the song most symbolic of CD.  Consider how many people have said CD is an excellent album that must be given a chance.  AFD was the kind of album where you just knew, CD just grows and grows on anybody willing to take the time.  When it was released Prostitute was the ultimate WTF song so far as fans were concerned, myself included.  I must have listened to the album 30 times and Prostitute was always that song playing in the background when i wasn't paying attn.  Then one day I found myself singing it at work.  My point, and relevant to this thread.  I think if GNR played Prostittute live those casual fans in attendance would suffer a major WTF moment.   BTW, Rhiad rocks live.

I would love to hear it live as well,but i must agree with some of you guys saying you want to hear new unreleased songs, but i love the fact that Axl isnt against the whole idea of trying out some older songs he hasnt played with these guys yet

Well, at least no one can even begin to try to say that this band wouldn't be skilled enough to perform it. Especially after ripping Estranged a new arse, and performing it better than the 91-93 band ever did.

As long as we have Ron, GN'R have the possiblilty to perform any song I feel.  :)

Exactly, I'm 100% positive Estranged was brought back because of customer feedback. All those banners were so cool and promptly noticed :peace:

It could happen but I wouldn't count on it.  I'd rather have Civil War make the setlist, not that there's anything wrong with the current.

To me Coma is top-10 songs from GN'R and it'll always be there with Estranged and Civil War for example. If they play Coma (or Civil War) someday live, i'll be veeeery happily surprised and blown away. This lineup would totally kick ass with Coma, i'm 100% sure about that  : ok:

I think we'll see a Civil War again someday. Coma maybe, but it has always been rare. I would also like to see Locomotive or Breakdown one day. I think this lineup would kill Locomotive  : ok:

I think some day they might but Breakdown is a song that I can see this band doing a great rendition of. Lets hear some Breakdown :)

Estranged this tour has been an absolute gift to the fans & I don't mind saying that Ron has nailed the groove and feel of the song. That being said, I would still doubt that they would play Coma any time soon.

What would be pretty cool though, would be for one of the players to change up their solo spots a bit, and include a portion Coma in there for a bit, to test the waters. Perhaps, losing Ron's Pink Panther  :confused: routine ... or have the band do a semi-kind of jam at some point leading into one of the consistently played tunes

Btw...Civil War needs to make an appearance again as well :yes: