|
Title: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on August 08, 2009, 06:22:50 PM There both great songs and I cant decide which is better what do you guys think???
Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: jarmo on August 08, 2009, 07:37:21 PM I think you're funny.
A Guns N' Roses classic compared to a generic ballad. Seriously? What's next, Sweet Child O' Mine compared to Be The Ball? /jarmo Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on August 08, 2009, 08:44:41 PM I think you're funny. Both are great songs in my opinion but your right November Rain dose have the upper had in the match up...A Guns N' Roses classic compared to a generic ballad. Seriously? What's next, Sweet Child O' Mine compared to Be The Ball? /jarmo Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: estebanf on August 08, 2009, 10:02:23 PM You're making a comparison between one of the greatest GNR tracks ever, and a 4 minute piece of cliche shit ...
In fact, I'm very surprised an extremely talented musician like Axl said he showed ''some interest'' in that garbage... The only positive thing about VR's existance is showing us what a GNR without Axl would be= an uninspired, mediocre act. Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: seely on August 08, 2009, 10:37:51 PM well i love both GN'R and VR
bu here, i go with No ember Rain, for Slash's epic outro solo alone But FallTo Pices is, IMO, an amzizing tune Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on August 08, 2009, 11:18:47 PM well i love both GN'R and VR jarmo and estebanf dont get it but u do im not supprised by Jarmos comment though he has no love 4 slashbu here, i go with No ember Rain, for Slash's epic outro solo alone But FallTo Pices is, IMO, an amzizing tune Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: estebanf on August 09, 2009, 01:10:17 AM it has nothing to do with Slash, at least its not personal: its about the musical aspect. That FTP song is just crap. It could have been a decent song with Axl's vocals and Axl's lyrics, but it could not have been anything more than that
It will lose anyway, and by far, but if you want to do a better comparison, use ''You Got No Right'' November Rain should be compared with other immortal clasics like Stairway To Heaven, High Hopes or, from the same band, There Was A Time or Estranged Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on August 09, 2009, 02:28:55 AM it has nothing to do with Slash, at least its not personal: its about the musical aspect. That FTP song is just crap. It could have been a decent song with Axl's vocals and Axl's lyrics, but it could not have been anything more than that I ment jarmo when i was taliking about no love 4 SlashIt will lose anyway, and by far, but if you want to do a better comparison, use ''You Got No Right'' November Rain should be compared with other immortal clasics like Stairway To Heaven, High Hopes or, from the same band, There Was A Time or Estranged Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: jarmo on August 09, 2009, 05:08:57 AM it has nothing to do with Slash, at least its not personal: its about the musical aspect. That FTP song is just crap. It could have been a decent song with Axl's vocals and Axl's lyrics, but it could not have been anything more than that I ment jarmo when i was taliking about no love 4 SlashIt will lose anyway, and by far, but if you want to do a better comparison, use ''You Got No Right'' November Rain should be compared with other immortal clasics like Stairway To Heaven, High Hopes or, from the same band, There Was A Time or Estranged He plays on November Rain which I prefer. Take your assumptions, put them in that pipe and smoke them. /jarmo Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on August 09, 2009, 05:52:26 AM :smoking:
it has nothing to do with Slash, at least its not personal: its about the musical aspect. That FTP song is just crap. It could have been a decent song with Axl's vocals and Axl's lyrics, but it could not have been anything more than that I ment jarmo when i was taliking about no love 4 SlashIt will lose anyway, and by far, but if you want to do a better comparison, use ''You Got No Right'' November Rain should be compared with other immortal clasics like Stairway To Heaven, High Hopes or, from the same band, There Was A Time or Estranged He plays on November Rain which I prefer. Take your assumptions, put them in that pipe and smoke them. /jarmo Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Genesis on August 09, 2009, 10:19:22 AM I think you're funny. A Guns N' Roses classic compared to a generic ballad. Seriously? What's next, Sweet Child O' Mine compared to Be The Ball? /jarmo What he said. Kids these days... Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Drew on September 01, 2009, 04:10:45 PM November Rain! For me, it's not even a contest.
Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on September 02, 2009, 08:59:01 PM I should have made it Fall to Pieces vs Last Fight that would have been a better thread than this
Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jim Bob on September 02, 2009, 11:26:49 PM is this supposed to be a serious question? :-X
Title: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: Jdog0830 on September 02, 2009, 11:31:31 PM is this supposed to be a serious question? :-X more like a mistake on my partTitle: Re: November Rain Vs. Fall to Pieces Post by: jacdaniel on September 03, 2009, 09:28:50 AM Fall to pieces is awesome! prefer November rain though! The cheesy video never gets old!!!!! :beer:
Lets not forget there was also a thread called November rain vs This i love. Why not merge them and vote on all 3. My vote would be 1) November rain 2) Fall to pieces 3) This I love |