|
Title: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: The Catcher on December 01, 2008, 04:48:18 AM Personally I think This I Love is the most mind-blowing piano ballad of the three and that is why I would compare it to November Rain, but Street of Dreams definately has a positive vibe and feel like November Rain has, so I think that one too constitutes a logical comparison. I'm undecided. What do you think?
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Drea Post by: elmir on December 01, 2008, 05:16:07 AM I think This I Love is the one which in terms of quality and "size" can be compared to NR....Street of Dreams for me is a bit weak overall....also, TWAT is up there in terms of "epic value" as well....
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: The Catcher on December 01, 2008, 05:17:54 AM Yeah, There Was A Time and Catcher in the Rye are songs I would place up there with the "epics" (God I hate that expression) and so is Estranged and Coma, but you gotta stop somewhere, so I think it's only natural to narrow it down to piano ballads about love.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Alfie Bones on December 01, 2008, 05:19:33 AM TIL.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Drea Post by: wells on December 01, 2008, 05:21:49 AM Street of Dreams (it is better song in 2008. than November Rain, but it is equivalent to November Rain in 1991. - if You know what I mean).
This I Love is in the other league and class of it own... above almost everything out there. IMHO. Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Drea Post by: elmir on December 01, 2008, 05:24:14 AM Street of Dreams (it is better song in 2008. than November Rain, but it is equivalent to November Rain in 1991. - if You know what I mean). yes, if it was released in 1991, it would have been perfect for the time....its not a bad song, but This I Love and TWAT are that much more superior.... Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: western_chaos on December 01, 2008, 05:50:42 AM This I Love.
TIL and November Rain are really both songs that are clearly axl's creation... Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Billo on December 01, 2008, 05:51:20 AM Id say street of dreams but the slow piano part in SOD allways reminds me of Estranged..LOL
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Agno on December 01, 2008, 06:04:02 AM I like November Rain best, Street of dreams is the second and This I Love has a bad guitar solo that ruins the song for me :/ otherwhise it's great song.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: damnthehaters on December 01, 2008, 06:41:35 AM This I Love for me easily!!!
Bad guitar solo... ??? Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Drea Post by: kingcanute on December 01, 2008, 07:18:45 AM I don't think TIL even comes close to NR. Street of Dreams is a damn good song, but NR is a classic.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Sillything on December 01, 2008, 07:46:56 AM This I Love, followed by Street of Dreams and then November Rain, superior vocals on the first tw0 :smoking:
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: metallex78 on December 01, 2008, 08:12:56 AM I always considered Street of Dreams as a "mini" November Rain, a little more compact and to the point version, but equally as epic in it's execution. The guitar solos alone make it deserving of that.
And as great as it is, I don't consider This I Love as an epic, if that makes sense? Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Drew on December 01, 2008, 09:16:02 PM For me, neither song comes close to what November Rain is.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: ShotgunBlues1978 on December 03, 2008, 02:21:28 PM This I Love reminds me a lot of the piano-only demo of NR, so I'll take that one. Both are great songs to me
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Smoking Guns on December 03, 2008, 03:58:53 PM November Rain, its not even close.
Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: ShotgunBlues1978 on December 03, 2008, 04:12:22 PM November Rain, its not even close. In your rush to praise the old band, you misunderstood the post :hihi: It's about which song is a better comparison to NR: This I Love or SOD. Not which song of the 3 is best Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: Smoking Guns on December 03, 2008, 04:29:22 PM November Rain, its not even close. In your rush to praise the old band, you misunderstood the post :hihi: It's about which song is a better comparison to NR: This I Love or SOD. Not which song of the 3 is best wooops, street of dreams, only because I could see finck on top of the piano with his guitar. Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: The Catcher on December 03, 2008, 05:52:49 PM November Rain, its not even close. In your rush to praise the old band, you misunderstood the post :hihi: It's about which song is a better comparison to NR: This I Love or SOD. Not which song of the 3 is best wooops, street of dreams, only because I could see finck on top of the piano with his guitar. rofl, yeah duplicating November Rain is the most important thing... :rofl: Title: Re: Which song is a better comparison to Nov Rain: This I Love or Street of Dreams? Post by: GNRreunioneventually on December 03, 2008, 11:33:57 PM This I Love is in its own category away from both of those songs even thought those songs are good too.
its a close call and i really like all three songs but it goes This I Love>Nov. Rain> Street of Dreams imo :peace: |