Here Today... Gone To Hell!

In his unreleased album "Beautiful Disease" (from 1999) there's a song called "Who's To Blame" wich, in Duff words: "It's about the breakup of guns." What do u think about it? or 'bout the lyrics? Though that maybe this is the first impression of the "breakup" of Gn'r from Duff (at least "musical impression") 'coz maybe thsi song was written the year after he left Gn'r... also interesting that he talked about "a breakup" of Gn'R not about he leaving the band... what do u think? Here are the lyrics... (though is a cool song)


Duff McKagan
Who's To Blame


What did I do today?
Some people think I went and threw it away
But that was yesterday
I can't remember much of that anyway

I wonder who's to blame?
Or does it really matter much anyway
Or if we stayed the same?
If anyone of us would be here today ... yeah

I don't care about it anymore, so tired
of thinking it through
I don't care about it anymore, who's to
blame me or you?

I had so much fun, was going to live so fast
and die very young
But I was 21, i'm so glad i'm here to sing this song ... yeah

I wonder who's to blame?
Or does it really matter much anyway?
Or if we stayed the same?
If anyone of us would be here today ... yeah
I don't care about it anymore, so tired of
thinking it through

I don't care about it anymore, who's to
blame me or you?
I don't care about it anymore. So tired of
thinking it through
I don't care about it anymore, who's to
blame me or you?

I think that Duff has a good perspective on things.  He doesn't seem to blaming Axl completely like Slash has done time and again.  He at least seems open to the possibility that there were multiple factors at play.

Ali

[/quote]

I think that Duff has a good perspective on things.  He doesn't seem to blaming Axl completely like Slash has done time and again.  He at least seems open to the possibility that there were multiple factors at play.

Ali
[/quote]

Yeah, U're right... I think the song critices the common place of lookin' one to blame... n' how stupid is it... "who's to blame me or you? I don't care about it anymore..."

wow good catch...sounds like it is

i think this song from 5 O'Clock is about Axl

Did Slash write the lyrics for that song?  If so, I don't see how Axl follows trends.  That's bullshit.

Ali

I seem to recall Zakk Wylde saying that Axl was obsessed with following musical trends.

we prolly shouldnt get into it in this section

but the rumors of the industrial influenced 2000 intentions with Chris Vrenna and Robin Finck and OMG spawning from that era....then there was Axl's fascination with Hip Hop in the 90s and the subsequent Nirvana/Grunge movement, which rumors say axl was also into until Cobain reportedly turned down the offer to open for guns


yeah there was an interview with him that said that Axl wanted to do something like Pearl Jam was doing

anyway slash talks about 5 O'Clock in his book and he mentions some stuff..i've thought that song was about Axl for a while...slash book kinda confirmed it for me though he never out and out specifically named it.

Mmmm... I don't think that snakepit talked 'bout Axl... but anywyas that seems off topic  : ok:

Listen to the new tracks.  They say otherwise.  The proof is in the pudding, as they say.

Ali

The new tracks are not really relevant to this discussion.

i didnt mean to run your thread off topic..  :peace: i just  thought that i'd post what i felt was another ex gnr members version of that particular time frame

considering that Slash had songs about it in 95 and duff had songs about it in 99...you could say they have moved on, and i consider the band to have broken up considering there was only one orig member left....as for axl carrying on the name whatever he has the rights to it so he can do whatever he wants

That's O.K. man  : ok: just the difference is that Duff was explicit saying that the song was about "the breakup of guns", n' 'bout the sankepit song we could just especulate...

can someone upload an mp3 of this song.

this is my favorite song on Beautiful Disease

Yes, they did.  Slash confirms it in his book and says some of the lyrics were bitter and directed at Axl.

wow... I didn't know it, actually I didn't read slash book yet... but? wasn't the first snakepit material supossed to be written for Gn'R? n' Axl rejected it? that's maybe a reason  :hihi:

i said in my post above that Slash said so in his book but whatever....

its a good read i recommend it  : ok:

as for why he directed the lyrics at axl...things were falling apart at the seams man...anyway he talks about it in depth in his book  ;)

I'm pretty sure the Snakepit music was written for GNR, without lyrics.  Slash went back and did those after Axl rejected it.  I think that was in the book but don't have it in front of me. Someone correct me if I'm totally off base there.

Yeah that's true. Some of the songs on Snakepit's first cd were Gn'R roughs.

Like the guitars... so that is what Slash wanted Gn'R to sound like, and I would of loved to hear that too!