Here Today... Gone To Hell!

it is performed by sherel crowe in the film, but at the end credits, there is a Guns version, and it sounds like its live, or done for something like this

but says its performed by slash steven, duff, axl and izzy, so unless they have it wrong, then i guess its a live thing

does any one know what show it was from?

or any help on this? some bits have been edited in the song, but it still sounds cool  : ok:

yes the first half of it is a live version of the old GNR line-up playing it...midway through the song in the middle of the guitar solo it "morphs" into a studio version of the new line-up playing it in 1999....the "where do we go" part and on is Axl and the new line-up at some point in the late 90's...im assuming 99 because that is when Big Daddy came out....I am not sure who the players are on it though...its probably similiar to the "Oh My God" line up with Freese on drums and what not...I am actually curious now as to who the line-up was on the second half of "Sweet Child"...also it sounds to me like Axl overdubbed his vocals on the live portion of the song but im not sure.....anyone know anything about that?


on a side note....this is the only reason I saw Big Daddy in the theaters..I actually brought in a TAPE recorder and recorded the end credits....I wish I still had that tape....but i have the DVD now anyway... :)

I'm sure you can find the song in the AFC section :yes:

Got the MP3 of it.
 I believe it was probably done around the time when Axl started talking about how he had the new band record a new never to be released
re-recording of APPETITE FOR DESTRUCTION.

If ya want me to upload the file let me know and I will post it on the board

i don't think axl said it was to be never released though : ok:

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=49248.0

hmm i just listened to it and that's not the 99 original version right ? where's robin's guitar ?

the good one : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mtovs6HhFO8

That version is quite cool,it's the 1st time i've heard it.

Its annoying on itunes that you can only buy the sheryl crow version, anyone know why ?

because the GNR version wasn't included on the official soundtrack

i would love to know who is playing that guitar solo. maybe robin?

I assume it is finck yes, i really enjoy the solo and guitarplaying :)

It's Robin Finck for sure. The line-up was Robin, Tommy, Paul Tobias, Dizzy, Josh Freese and some guy singing. :P

IMO Robin just tortures that solo. 'If I can't play that fast, might as well screech on the wah and make if go off-key'. Terrible. Why Robin? Why must you bend everything out of whack? :P

you must be kidding, that's the best part of this version.

check this live version, awesome.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1FMrxf4aW8g

he can play it with eyes closed and as speed as anybody.

I know he can play fast. It must be his 'version' of the SCOM solo or whatever... I just dislike it. Not to mention his talent for bending everything out of tune.

that's what is interesting, he's not a slash's clone or a karaoke guitarist, he has his own style and sound.

Whatever. Each to his own, I guess. I'm not going to discuss this further.

Tell me when exactly he's out of tune on this recording.

it sounds like its Finck playing when the song switches, the way he stresses the solo live sounds similar, but who really knows ..........

its robin, 100% and it's great. he makes the solo his own and makes it much better than slash's.....much....

the movie sucks but i think its is robin but how the hell would i know

Peace

Why people even have doubts if it's Robin when we all know for sure it's him? Despite the obvious common sense (because his playing and tone is 100% recognizable), I'm pretty sure there is a lot of articles on HTGTH main page stating it is indeed Robin. :P

3:17 and 3:18 , the bends are real nasty.

LOL, just because he bends slowly you think he's out of tune?

rock n'roll is nasty, anyway.

much better than slash`s?????  WTF?????
I can not believe this...

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw
;)

That is the sound of The Slash.  : ok:

And that sucks! : ok:

From what I hear NR Slash is the best

BH is really good , but doesn't fit the song , his note choice.

Bubmlefoot is by far the lower of the 3 to me , the tone is off , and its random shredding.


Nightrain.........Sorry but come on Slash OWNS that solo. Once again BH comes 2nd , very close second at that though , it's his note choice that throws me off I favor the blues'y style of Slash compared to BH note choice , his tremolo picking is bad ASS though.  'Foot is once again last to me , he is just hitting stuff at least BH made it into his own creation.

I didn't see YCBM anywhere there?

Buckethead owns them ALL, especially NT! Go listen to Rio 2001 and HOB 2001.......Slash 2nd, Ron distant 3rd...

I think BH and Slash have such different styles it's really what appeals to your ear , if you like BH note choice you chose him if you like Slash's you chose him.

totally agree with that! im just blown away with bh's work ....

I just love how nearly EVERY discussion here turns into a Slash vs. Robin or Bucket vs. Robin.

 :rofl:

where's the bucket vs Robin one? I haven't seen it for ages.

Nah, it's mostly robin x slash and bucket x ron.

meant to say Ron.

but regardless, nearly every conversation ends up with one of them.

Yeah guys, you're both right.

It just amuses me how the same person who said Robin was out of tune on the studio re-recording of SCOM (and was obviously WRONG) just ignored Slash being waaaay out of tune on that live clip of Nightrain. Talk about being biased. ::)

You said listen to "listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine" which wasn't on there......

I didn't say that and it was kinda obvious that Bruno Poeys made a mistake....

Regardless, you still talked about Slash's solo on Nightrain and "forgot" to mention he being out of tune.

WAIT. You're right! Just to quote Beta: Everyone knows that

Now listen to his Nightrain solo, feel the burn. ;)