Here Today... Gone To Hell!

The local classic rock station did an online poll of the top 104 rock albums of all time.? GN'R made the list 4 times, coming in at #2 for Appetite.? Here's the list:

http://www.q104.ca/default.asp?mn=1.80&sfield=content.id&search=2187

1. Back In Black AC/DC
2. Appetite For Destruction Guns N? Roses
3. The Wall Pink Floyd
4. Dark Side Of The Moon Pink Floyd
5. Bat Out Of Hell Meat Loaf
6. A Night At The Opera Queen
7. Led Zeppelin IV (?runes? album) Led Zeppelin
8. Metallica (black album) Metallica
9. Hotel California Eagles
10. Abbey Road The Beatles
11. 1984 Van Halen
12. Toys In The Attic Aerosmith
13. Wish You Were Here Pink Floyd
14. And Justice For All Metallica
15. American Idiot Green Day
16. Black Sabbath Black Sabbath
17. Use Your Illusion II Guns N? Roses
18. Master Of Puppets Metallica
19. Use Your Illusion I Guns N? Roses
20. Highway To Hell AC/DC
21. Led Zeppelin II Led Zeppelin
22. For Those About To Rock We Salute You? ?AC/DC
23. Led Zeppelin Led Zeppelin
24. Nevermind Nirvana
25. Paranoid Black Sabbath
26. The Joshua Tree U2
27. Boston Boston?
28. Van Halen Van Halen
29. Sgt. Pepper?s Lonely Hearts Club Band The Beatles
30. Rumours Fleetwood Mac
31. Dirty Deeds Done Dirt Cheap AC/DC
32. All The Right Reasons Nickelback
33. 2112 Rush
34. Against The Wind Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band
35. Dr. Feelgood Motley Crue
36. Blizzard Of Oz Ozzy Osbourne
37. Animals Pink Floyd
38. Achtung, Baby U2
39. Hysteria Def Leppard
40. Are You Experienced The Jimi Hendrix Experience
41. Eliminator ZZ Top
42. Girls, Girls, Girls Motley Crue
43. Billion Dollar Babies Alice Cooper
44. Synchronicity The Police
45. Breakfast In America Supertramp
46. Up To Here The Tragically Hip
47. Born In The U.S.A. Bruce Springsteen
48. Crime Of The Century Supertramp
49. Blood Sugar Sex Magik Red Hot Chili Peppers
50. Slippery When Wet Bon Jovi
51. Brothers In Arms Dire Straits
52. Californication Red Hot Chili Peppers
53. Aerosmith Aerosmith
54. A Momentary Lapse Of Reason Pink Floyd
55. American Woman Guess Who
56. A Farewell To Kings Rush
57. Destroyer Kiss
58. Fully Completely The Tragically Hip
59. Whitesnake Whitesnake
60. Shout At The Devil Motley Crue
61. Who?s Next? The Who
62. Ace Of Spades Motorhead
63. Road Apples The Tragically Hip
64. G N? R Lies Guns N? Roses
65. Houses Of The Holy Led Zeppelin
66. Volume One Traveling Wilburys
67. Welcome To My Nightmare Alice Cooper
68. Electric Jewels April Wine
69. A Day At The Races Queen
70. The Doors The Doors
71. The Long Road Nickelback
72. Goodbye Yellow Brick Road Elton John
73. The Razor?s Edge AC/DC
74. Abacab Genesis
75. The Division Bell Pink Floyd
76. The Number Of The Beast Iron Maiden
77. American Fool John Mellencamp
78. 5150 Van Halen
79. Diary Of A Madman Ozzy Osbourne
80. High Voltage AC/DC
81. Pyromania Def Leppard
82. The Beatles (white album) The Beatles
83. No More Tears Ozzy Osbourne
84.? Sticky Fingers Rolling Stones
85. Let There Be Rock AC/DC
86. Revolver The Beatles
87. Bad To The Bone George Thorogood
88. Permanent Vacation Aerosmith
89. Band On The Run Paul McCartney & Wings
90. The Tragically Hip The Tragically Hip
91. After The Goldrush Neil Young
92. Machine Head Deep Purple
93. Ten Pearl Jam
94. Let It Be The Beatles
95. Frampton Comes Alive Peter Frampton
96. Powerslave Iron Maiden
97. Born To Run Bruce Springsteen
98. Tommy The Who
99. Copperhead Road Steve Earle
100. Rubber Soul The Beatles
101. Imagine John Lennon
102.? Harvest Neil Young
103.? A Rush Of Blood To The Head Coldplay
104. A Hard Day?s Night The Beatles

ok. that's a nice list of nice albums but the order is far from how it should be imo .. AND WTF is Green Day doing there?

15. American Idiot Green Day
101. Imagine John Lennon  ::)

It says "ROCK ALBUM" though

How rock is Lennon's album?


Ive heard the Imagine album and outside of imagine I think most of it sucks personally.

I think people get too caught up in "Its John Lennon"

Where is this "local" radio station out of curiosity?  I am pleasantly surprised to see a couple of Tragically Hip albums on the list...so I am assuming it is a Canadian station.

Yeah Green Day American Idiot...ugh...and I am not sure I would have put Meatloaf that high, or even on the list.  But the rest of the list looks okay.

Straight out of Halifax, Nova Scotia!

Q104 plays Guns atleast once a day...and the DJ yesterday even mentioned Chinese Democracy and hoping it comes out soon!

Pretty cool that all original Guns albums made the list

Your point is correct but also these lists are just debatable forever ya know?

Q104 have done this type of thing Multiple times and every time GNR comes up BIG. A few years ago on a weekend they did the top 104 Rock Bands and GNR came 3rd right ahead of The Rolling Stones.

Halifax LOVES GNR. But thats obvious by how the concert turned out last November.

Who cares.  I am sick about hearing about a 20 yr old album (even if it is one of my fav.)  Where is the new shit?

Cool!
Nice to see so many GNR albums on the list :)
But anyway.. GNR should top AC/DC

So this is the "latest" GN'R news, eh?  Just checking...

I missed some Judas Priest song in the list, could be "You've got another thing coming" or "Metal gods", or "Braking the Law", or ...

That's a pretty crap list.  No Piece of Mind?  No Seventh Son?

These albums ranked near each other make me laugh (and cry...inside):

15. American Idiot Green Day
16. Black Sabbath Black Sabbath

32. All The Right Reasons Nickelback
33. 2112 Rush

Why the fucks is Girls, Girls, Girls ranked 18 spots higher than Shout at the Devil?  For most Crue fans, that one's just common sense.

I would never take any of these polls seriously . The only opinion when it comes to stuff like this that should matter is your own.