Here Today... Gone To Hell!

title pretty much says it all. he was beaton my king freddie himself.

Can't argue with that.

I can :)

Forget the rest, Axl's the best!

Ali

Axl is no way near Freddie and will never be.

Now that's an accurate list. You REALLY can't argue with that.

Well anyone but Freddie winning that wouldn't have been correct, Axls a great front man but in terms of stage presence, crowd communication and vocal ability Freddie is miles ahead of anyone else.

So he's the best front man alive. : ok:


still the same magazine diss him? ???


I'm not that big on freddie either.

To quote Matt Sorum, "Axl is the best frontman ever."

You can disagree if you want, but for me, Axl is the best rock n' roll frontman.  I don't consider Queen to be an out and out rock band like GN'R or AC/DC or Aerosmith.

Ali

freddie has always been my second favorite frontman and vocalist to the one and only w. axl rose


but this list unlike others sounds alright

Is this in the magazine?

Voted by the readers?




/jarmo

I don't consider Queen or GNR as a out and out rock band like AC/DC or Aerosmith. :-X they are more diverse than that.

im taking a guess that it was on Kerrang TV, they tdo top 10 / 20 stuff all the time

That's fair enough really. It's so hard to rank them but he is up there with the best. I do agree that Freddie isn't really a rock n' roll frontman but his skill is unquestionable.

Just out of interest where did Plant, Morrisson, Jagger etc. all come. Kerrang's lists are usually very poor.

thank god shitty cobaine didnt beat axl like nirvana usually do with smells like teen boredom

At least Axl didn't get beaten by Kurt Cobain.

Where is Scott Weiland on this list btw?? :hihi:

Just the way it should be, no one will ever be a better frontman than Freddie...

pls dont turn this into a Kurc Cocain sucks thread.

I think Freddie Mercury is a wonderfully, energetic and charming frontman.

Axl was never really a charming rock n' roll frontman - HE IS A BAD-ASS FRONTMAN!
I bet if you made Freddie do on stage what Axl did in his prime performing peakness, he wouldn't have the strength or the balls to keep up.

Long Live AXL
 :smoking:
MNW

I think Axl would appreciate coming in 2nd to Freddie, since Queen is such a big influence.

Axl being #2 to Freddie Mercury is really like just saying Axl is #1. Freddie sort of transcends these lists and is his own... thing. Axl is my favorite singer and GN'R is my favorite band, but Freddie Mercury is the definitive frontman. Fuck Robert Plant. Sabbath was more influential and Queen more accomplished. Anyway, being behind Freddie isn't really being behind. You can't beat him. Axl beat everyone else on the list, obviously he can't beat Freddie. No one should. Kurt Cobain should be #1 on the worst frontmen of all time list. He was a shit singer. Shit lyricist. Shit guitarist. Shit person junkie asshole who blew his goddamn pussy brains out and if he didn't he'd be as washed up today as the rest of the shit grunge scene (except Eddie Vedder, he's cool).

I love Freddie, but I prefer Axl. Rawer, more dangerous!

What I meant was, that Axl sucks a donkeys ass compared to Freddie Mercury.

Freddie was the best singer, one of the best songwriters and the best front man ever.

If anybody beat him, I can accept Freddie, no problem.

i have always said freddie #1 and Axl #2.
you just dont beat freddie, so if hes not at the top the list is BS

sigh

You better resolve those issues you have or it could very well lead to you becoming a "Shit person junkie asshole" .

BTW , I never saw Queen live so I have to go with Axl .

did i get deleted brining up robert plant.what a joke really ?
dammmmmmmmmm ,that sucks can't even give my opinions.whats up with that jarmo ?

It's called splitting a topic. Since you people want to discuss other artists besides GN'R, do so in the right section.

Dammmmmmmmmmmmm  ::)




/jarmo

so delete me an not them ,is that fair ?
it's ok to talk about freddie mercury and not anything else.ok gotca,makes alot of sense ,cencership is what it seems like.

Yes, censorship, nazis, geeks, nerds, drool, LOLZ! etc etc.

Are you done?

Go ahead, delete yourself if you can't deal with the fact that we don't discuss Robert Plant in the GN'R section.


/jarmo

no i believe axl is #1 ok !
but other people were discussing other singers is why i brought up robert plant.just in conversation,that is all.

Hey, my post was deleted, as well.  Guess, since this is under GnR, we're supposed to keep it at talking about Axl, only, and Freddie is ok because, um, I guess because he's the only one ahead of him in the list.  Guess if we want to discuss any other front men, we have to take it out of the GnR section.   

Same here!  :yes:  Axl was the best, but unfortunately he doesn't have the same huge discography as the others. He's No.2 position with 3 full albums tells how huge he was (and is).  8)

yes i have to agree with that i guess.im hotheaded sometimes though.sorry jarmo it was a ruff night.

U know what I dont understand.

Its hypocritical as fuck to say Kurt Cobain is overrated cause he died but yet give Freddie Mercury a pass.


isn't Mercury technically overrated cause of the way he died of Aids?

I tend to think so.


Freddie isnt better than Axl or Steven Tyler in my opinion.

Gimme a break....

let's see 20 something hugely succesfull albums for Freddie prior to his death, playing to millions and millions of people being named best frontman several times even before he died....

What you said is just blasphemy.... ;)

And Freddie was not only a great performer, songwriter and frontman, he also had a very unique voice and noone in the rock business could touch him technically.  :yes:



It still ain't change that Axl is my favourite  :P

Oh God here we go with the Technical shit again.

Jesus Christ I hate that word.

There are marching band drummers who are "Technically" better than John Bonham so does that mean they are better drummers.

That shit drives me crazy when people talk about "Technical ability"


I know a guy that I went to high school who can "Technically" sing way better than Axl but guess what he isnt a Better singer or anywhere close to Axl Rose.


Dont get me wrong Freddie deserves to be high on the list but Im not so sure about number 1.

Your posts haven't been deleted. Go check Bad Obsession.