|
Title: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: big_machine on April 02, 2007, 02:23:31 AM i heard sometime ago CTR won`t be on the album......so i want tht song to make it .......john lennon tribute, right ?
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Mike McKagan on April 02, 2007, 02:28:09 AM I'd be happy to see it on there. Catchy damn song. : ok:
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Janabis on April 02, 2007, 02:35:12 AM Wish it was, but backstage at MSG '02 Axl said it'd be on the third album. That was the first time anyone heard about follow ups to CD.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: axleu on April 02, 2007, 02:39:14 AM Awesome song! I want it on the album!
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Bodhi on April 02, 2007, 02:44:24 AM I sure hope not....its by far the weakest of all the leaks..I LOVE all the other songs...they are on the level of the old ones...even better in certain ways..but im not feeling CITR
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Grouse on April 02, 2007, 03:12:04 AM I really hope it's on CD it's one of the strongest new songs imo...
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: grog mug on April 02, 2007, 03:18:22 AM 3rd album..lol I love when people mention the "3" album theory. It's been talked about for years and years, and we still don't have CD. Axl changes his mind more than anyone...JUST STICK WITH ONE PLAN FOR GOD SAKES!!
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: gunns1 on April 02, 2007, 03:20:03 AM catcher is a great fckn song,
and deserves to be on the first album, if omg gets on it instead of that, i will be very fckn :rant: :rant: :rant: for days, perhaps, if im up 2 it, weeks :rant: :rant: :beer: Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Angelrose on April 02, 2007, 04:50:22 AM This song got a fucking potential as same way of Don 't cry!
I want it to on the the album. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: Skeletor on April 02, 2007, 04:52:29 AM I definitely think it's the best one out of all the new songs.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: DaNutz on April 02, 2007, 04:59:01 AM NO...I like it..I mean its OK, but I hope it doesnt make the cut..I havent been waiting 10 years for it.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: CAFC Nick on April 02, 2007, 05:01:00 AM Not too bothered either way.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: whiny on April 02, 2007, 05:03:53 AM I definitely think it's the best one out of all the new songs. yeah. it HAS TO BE ON THE ALBUM... since i heard about catcher (around 2000) i have been dying to listen to that song... then the leak was more than promising... so maybe we will be happy soon... but if the 3 cd concept is gnr reality, it might take some more time till we hear catcher, that already is a classic song for me. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: November_Rain on April 02, 2007, 05:55:33 AM That?s one of my favourite of all the new songs we?ve heard. I?d definitely love it to be on the record! :love:
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Scabbie on April 02, 2007, 06:12:34 AM I like the song, but I think its definitely the 'diffrent' one of the bunch we have heard so far and not sure how it would fit in. Maybe as a stand alone single or if there are any more songs like this include it in another album down the line
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: stivbator on April 02, 2007, 06:51:19 AM i think citr is the best of the new songs,and to me one of the best songs i have ever heard :peace: :peace:
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: AxlsMainMan on April 02, 2007, 09:00:45 AM Id absolutely love for it to be on the album.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: JDA on April 02, 2007, 09:04:18 AM Hope so. My favorite of all the leaks and live songs we have heard.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Wooody on April 02, 2007, 09:11:44 AM Wish it was, but backstage at MSG '02 Axl said it'd be on the third album. That was the first time anyone heard about follow ups to CD. nah , already mentioned on an intervieuw from 2001 somewhere in Latinamerica Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: ChrisPittman on April 02, 2007, 09:23:00 AM i heard sometime ago CTR won`t be on the album......so i want tht song to make it .......john lennon tribute, right ? To be honest you won't know until the album comes out. Personally I love this song because its the nearest thing I'll ever get to my two favourite bands (Guns N Roses and Queen) linking up in a studio and recording a song together. I'm not sure if Brian wrote his own parts for this song but I hope he did because he sounds great on there with Axl and it should, as a tribute to him, defo be on the album Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: quarky on April 02, 2007, 10:51:52 AM I think I will be happier if it isn't on the album.. Save me having to keep skipping it. :-X
Funny how it divides people isn't it. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: thenextslash on April 02, 2007, 11:29:20 AM its a good song i hope so
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: whiny on April 02, 2007, 11:44:59 AM I think I will be happier if it isn't on the album.. Save me having to keep skipping it.? :-X Funny how it divides people isn't it. yeah, funny, cause not seeing that this is a masterpiece and THE potential HIT-Song (along with better) is hard to understand; it may not be your genre or whatever; but not seeing that the melodies, harmonies and hooks are sooo damn strong and that there is so much passion to it, is a thing i don't quite get. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: ChrisPittman on April 02, 2007, 02:17:02 PM I think the version we have heard is crappy audio quality, and simply put I think that if the track was ever released on the album, we'd have a much better (fuller) sounding song
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: Layne Staley's Sunglasses on April 02, 2007, 02:28:27 PM It's my favorite song from the new era.
And Axl said last year at the KORN party that there would be some songs people liked, and some that people didn't like. But that the album had something for everyone. It's funny how Better and The Blues are SOOO popular amongst us fans, but songs like Madagascar and Catcher are very divisive. You either love 'em or hate 'em. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: Mauve_All on April 02, 2007, 02:38:49 PM I'd love it to be on the album, from the demo I've heard so far
It features this "mmmmmmmmmm catcher in the ryeeeee again" by Axl, it's just killing me :yes: Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Voodoochild on April 02, 2007, 02:47:54 PM I guess not. And the song must be now way far from what he heard.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: michaelvincent on April 02, 2007, 02:56:01 PM I never get sick of this topic. Even after it's 5000th appearance on HTGTH. You'll find out when the album comes out.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: ppbebe on April 02, 2007, 03:20:49 PM Then you will never get sick of the topic about whether it will be on the 2nd or the 3rd either. :yes:
Quote But that the album had something for everyone. Yep he said everyone would find at least a few songs they like in it. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: Dont Try Me on April 02, 2007, 03:26:58 PM Yep he said everyone would find at least a few songs they like in it. yeah, but that's Axl beeing modest and all.... ;D he's actually saying every song is gonna kick ass. 8) ;) Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: ppbebe on April 02, 2007, 03:59:21 PM Yep he said everyone would find at least a few songs they like in it. yeah, but that's Axl beeing modest and all.... ;D he's actually saying every song is gonna kick ass. 8) ;) sure thing. :yes: and yet, I think, at the same time he knows that music is subjective and every fan has their taste. For instance, look at the posts in this thread. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: markpeterhughes73 on April 02, 2007, 04:26:59 PM That?s one of my favourite of all the new songs we?ve heard. I?d definitely love it to be on the record! :love: me too! luvin it Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: thelostrose on April 02, 2007, 05:00:11 PM according to richard and tommy CITR is on CD.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: wharfy11 on April 02, 2007, 05:00:23 PM I adore the outro of catcher, the whole song is awesome but that ending. wow. it should go on for longer though.
You were the instrument You were the one How a body took the body Gave that boy a gun Took our innocence Beyond our stance :) Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: crash on April 02, 2007, 05:45:10 PM its the best of the new songs, has to be on the cd
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: bigcash2002 on April 02, 2007, 09:16:12 PM I really hope so, I love this tune! Very different as well for Guns :peace:
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: GnFnR87 on April 02, 2007, 10:06:03 PM I adore the outro of catcher, the whole song is awesome but that ending. wow. it should go on for longer though. You were the instrument You were the one How a body took the body Gave that boy a gun Took our innocence Beyond our stance :) completely agree, i adore the outro, especially when the guitar comes in right after "instrument", i also dig the synth work. it would be a shame if this wasn't on the album, but who knows, it could very well be. and if it isnt we could still see it in the form of a b-side/bonus song or on the *gasp*, next album? :hihi: Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: HoldenCaulfield on April 02, 2007, 10:50:25 PM Yeah, it would be a crime if it's no on the new album. It's an absolutely fantastic song and probably the best all-around "new" song. Everything is brilliant: the lyrics, the vocals, the melody, the guitars, everything. It could end up being the best song the world never heard...
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: gnrbacik on April 02, 2007, 10:54:07 PM Definitely one my favourite leaks! I hope its on!
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: whiny on April 03, 2007, 04:38:42 AM according to richard and tommy CITR is on CD. where and when did tommy say this? Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: waxlrick on April 03, 2007, 06:12:01 AM I'm betting it will be. It is a masterpiece. One of the best songs ever. Axl's vocal performance is incredible and the best he has ever sounded imo.
W Axl Rick. :hihi: Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: Scabbie on April 03, 2007, 07:22:21 AM I'm betting it will be. It is a masterpiece. One of the best songs ever. Axl's vocal performance is incredible and the best he has ever sounded imo. W Axl Rick. :hihi: Not sure about best songs ever but it is good. I'm not too fussed if it doesn't make an appearance cos I don't see how it fits with the other songs at the moment, but then again we don't know too much about these other songs that Axl referred to at the Korn party. Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: justynius on April 03, 2007, 12:13:51 PM I definitely hope it to be on the new album. It's the best of the new songs we've heard and the awesome end part reminds me of the end to Coma. It would also seem to be an appropriate fit to the album, since you can apply the song to the breakup of the old lineup. I will be very, very disappointed if CITR gets cut.
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you want i Post by: GeraldFord on April 03, 2007, 12:32:07 PM I sure hope it is. If it's on the follow-up, God knows how long we'll have to wait to hear it!
Title: Re: do you think catcher in the rye on will be on the album? vote here if you wa Post by: Crowebar on April 03, 2007, 12:40:15 PM If it's on the follow-up, God knows how long we'll have to wait to hear it! That's the thing that I actually have nightmares about, every night and I feel like I've been waiting forever for this 1st release already..... :nervous: :'( |