Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Guns N' Roses => Guns N' Roses => Topic started by: GNFNR on March 30, 2007, 09:30:38 AM



Title: .
Post by: GNFNR on March 30, 2007, 09:30:38 AM
.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: WARose on March 30, 2007, 09:33:53 AM
depends on the quality of the music ::)


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: BlowUpYourVideo on March 30, 2007, 09:37:20 AM
By the fans: probably.
By most others: I doubt it.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: younggunner on March 30, 2007, 09:46:57 AM
Wait so now Im not allowed to say the album is going to be great because Madagascar is a masterpiece?

HAvnt they played Maddy Live? We have been able to tlak about Madagascar,CD etc since friggen 2000.

Now all of a sudden I cant speak of it when some1 starts a thread of a question thats been asked 1 zillion fukin times because we cant talk about anything else here?

Makes no sense\


lol i really hope something special is in store for this site. jarmo  I love you but I mean now its really getting crazy here. Cant even discuss Madagascar despite it being out for 7 yrs.....All i said was how chilling it was.....

unreal


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: JDA on March 30, 2007, 09:52:50 AM
Lock


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Axlrose4eva on March 30, 2007, 10:32:00 AM
It will always be regarded as the greatest waste in music history.

It could be the most amazing music, it wont matter, Axl's 45 years old...Im going to buy the album, I love the songs ive heard but seriously how many 45 year old rock stars sell 10 million cd's of new music.  Even if the album sold well, which it most likely wont, but if it does it still will be considered a waste, maybe even more so if its accepted.  People will say things like Chinese Democracy is so great that it shows how much it sucks that Axl spent the majority of his prime working on just this, instead of performing and recording more music etc... 


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: estrangedpaul on March 30, 2007, 10:51:16 AM
It will always be regarded as the greatest waste in music history.

It could be the most amazing music, it wont matter, Axl's 45 years old...Im going to buy the album, I love the songs ive heard but seriously how many 45 year old rock stars sell 10 million cd's of new music.?
U2? Bono and Adam were 44 and The Edge and Larry were 43 when How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb was released. It was average compared to their older stuff and still sold approx 10 million worldwide in 2 years apparently.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Luigi on March 30, 2007, 10:57:30 AM

Makes no sense\


lol i really hope something special is in store for this site. jarmo I love you but I mean now its really getting crazy here. Cant even discuss Madagascar despite it being out for 7 yrs.....All i said was how chilling it was.....

unreal

I'm with you on that one!


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: von on March 30, 2007, 11:24:21 AM
It will be regarded as such. It's not just something the fans are gonna say. Fuck the jaded DJs who want to play demos and spin lies. This is gonna blow the anal-crusted music scene wide the fuck open. Oh ye who have little faith. The reason the album's not out yet is because how do you market something so big, so expensive, so elaborate, and so crucial? Give it time. They've tested the waters with touring, and this thing is gonna hit us real soon. There's going to be a media onslaught. People want this band and this sound back. Nobody gives a shit if Slash is in the band or not, no disrespect. You think only the fans will praise it and nobody else will want to hear it because it's a "new" band? Let me tell you, that's something ONLY the diehards will be bitching about. This album's gonna rule the world. GN'R are legends now. This will make them something else. Now they are Queen.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: MotherGooseLuvR on March 30, 2007, 12:08:39 PM
I think the more you know about Axl, the better the album will be. 

If you're just a casual fan of GnR, and don't know much about what's happened in Axl's life over the last 14 years, it might be a little hard to get into.



Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: redx on March 30, 2007, 12:17:42 PM
What do you think?

I cannot anwser that question until the albums out  :peace:

Although for an album to take this long, does not mean it will be great, it could just mean the people behind it lack motivation. I think their getting off on having something the rest of the world doesn't, an un finished Gn'R album  :hihi:


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Africa on March 30, 2007, 12:22:39 PM
It will always be regarded as the greatest waste in music history.

It could be the most amazing music, it wont matter, Axl's 45 years old...Im going to buy the album, I love the songs ive heard but seriously how many 45 year old rock stars sell 10 million cd's of new music.? Even if the album sold well, which it most likely wont, but if it does it still will be considered a waste, maybe even more so if its accepted.? People will say things like Chinese Democracy is so great that it shows how much it sucks that Axl spent the majority of his prime working on just this, instead of performing and recording more music etc...?

And negative people like you who pass themselves off as fans are a waste of life.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Grouse on March 30, 2007, 12:24:58 PM
And negative people like you who pass themselves off as fans are a waste of life.

Keep talking like that in every post and I'm sure you'll be banned soon enough.....again...


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Africa on March 30, 2007, 12:36:24 PM
I bet that would give you some excitement in life.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Grouse on March 30, 2007, 12:38:10 PM
nah believe me I've got better things to do  :yes:


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: COMAMOTIVE on March 30, 2007, 12:39:39 PM
I'LL MAKE THIS SHORT AND SWEET

YES....FUCK YES....ABSOLUTELY.... ?IT IS GONNA BE THE MOST FANTASTIC ROCK ALBUM TO COME ALONG IN A LONG TIME..... THERE WILL BE CLASSICS ON THIS RECORD AND THEN AXL IS GONNA DISSAPEAR INTO THE SUNSET : ok: : ok:


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Mark7955 on March 30, 2007, 12:42:18 PM
The media will have a huge impact on what happens with the album. ?Also, the "GNR is nothing without Slash" people will probably shoot down the album no matter how great it is. ?Either way, Chinese Democracy will be big, only time will tell how big though.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Krispy Kreme on March 30, 2007, 01:04:35 PM
Wait so now Im not allowed to say the album is going to be great because Madagascar is a masterpiece?

HAvnt they played Maddy Live? We have been able to tlak about Madagascar,CD etc since friggen 2000.

Now all of a sudden I cant speak of it when some1 starts a thread of a question thats been asked 1 zillion fukin times because we cant talk about anything else here?

Makes no sense\


lol i really hope something special is in store for this site. jarmo? I love you but I mean now its really getting crazy here. Cant even discuss Madagascar despite it being out for 7 yrs.....All i said was how chilling it was.....

unreal


Did I miss something? There seems to be a part of the conversation that is missing, or is it me?


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: COMAMOTIVE on March 30, 2007, 01:29:45 PM
Wait so now Im not allowed to say the album is going to be great because Madagascar is a masterpiece?

HAvnt they played Maddy Live? We have been able to tlak about Madagascar,CD etc since friggen 2000.

Now all of a sudden I cant speak of it when some1 starts a thread of a question thats been asked 1 zillion fukin times because we cant talk about anything else here?

Makes no sense\


lol i really hope something special is in store for this site. jarmo? I love you but I mean now its really getting crazy here. Cant even discuss Madagascar despite it being out for 7 yrs.....All i said was how chilling it was.....

unreal


Did I miss something? There seems to be a part of the conversation that is missing, or is it me?

Yeah, he's all fucked up. I answered anyways, because I knew what he was saying. Which probably means I'm all fucked up too :yes:


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: DunkinDave on March 30, 2007, 04:16:53 PM
It could be great, it could suck, it could be somewhere in between.

We won't know until it comes out.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Razor on March 30, 2007, 04:24:49 PM
ITs gonna be huge? wether people like it or not. Think about how much press has been written about this album already and it has not even been released. Publicity is good no matter whats said.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: COMAMOTIVE on March 30, 2007, 04:28:58 PM
ITs gonna be huge? wether people like it or not. Think about how much press has been written about this album already and it has not even released. Publicity is good no matter whats said.


Yeah...what he said


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: norway on March 30, 2007, 04:51:18 PM

I think it's dependant solely on the music, it just have a tendency to succeed on it's own


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Axlrose4eva on March 30, 2007, 05:10:14 PM
Lots of press have been written about a lot of things that arent considered great.  Gigli and Michael Jackson's new album had a ton of press written about it...that means nothing.  The press isnt saying "We are still eagerly anticipating the masterpiece of the genius Axl Rose and the wonderful musicians he has put together to for Guns N' Roses." The media is saying "In other wha-a-a-a-cky news, fat and bald Axl Rose...remember him he started that riot in St. Louis and bit a security guard last year...has missed the deadline to Chinese Democracy...people in China are very sad, people in the United States don't give a damn."  That is an exact quote from the radio station where I live, complete with the elongating the word whacky.   That is not the hype albums that are considered "great" usually get.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: GNRforever10 on March 30, 2007, 06:40:16 PM
 I think it will blow our minds! I just hope he keeps putting out music after this classic.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Smoking Guns on March 30, 2007, 08:09:03 PM
Younggunner, what the hell happened?  Did you start a thread about Madagascar and Jarmo delete it?  Hmmmm.....


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: vietnow138 on March 31, 2007, 12:27:59 AM
Based on what we have already heard there's no chance, but I dont know what the rest of the album's going to sound like so I guess its possible, but i honestly doubt it.


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: November_Rain on March 31, 2007, 05:21:38 AM
I think we?ll have to wait untill we listen to it to see if it is considered one of the greats. I have faith in this band and for all the leaks I?ve heard I don?t know if people will consider it one of the greats but for me it will. :love:





Off topic:W,I need to pm you,it?s important. :yes:


Title: Re: Will Chinese Democracy Be Regarded As Of The Greats
Post by: Axl4Prez2004 on March 31, 2007, 09:30:28 AM
In my eyes, yes. 

By the mass media?  Who cares.

Axl is a fucking genius.