|
Title: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: ChrisPittman on March 21, 2007, 12:53:13 PM Appetite for Destruction
Every song from this album except the track 'Anything Goes' which was co-written by Chris Gardner GNR Lies Patience, Used to Love Her and You're Crazy Use Your Illusion 1 Live and Let Die (albeit reworked), an Instrumental version of Don't Cry and November Rain Use Your Illusion 2 Knocking On Heavens Door (albeit reworked) and You Could Be Mine The Spaghetti Incident Down on the Farm Of the tracks that the band have performed from the classic era, every one of them was either written prior to the recording of Appetite for Destruction or its a cover version. At that, the cover versions have all been in some way reworked to suit the new band. Doesnt that strike anyone as slightly odd? Isn't any label interested in the band performing some more tunes from UY1 or UY2? Are the band forbidden to play tunes from Use Your Illusion? Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Africa on March 21, 2007, 01:01:22 PM Forbidden to play tracks from Use Your Illusion? :confused:
Um, ever thought that the band plays the songs they want to play? The recent addition of Lies and TSI tracks is very positive, they play what the public wants to hear. Besides, in an online interview recently Bumblefoot (I think it was him, could have been richard though) said that it's not impossible that the band will play Estranged (or was it Civil War? Don't remember, but it was one of those) in the future. I think the setlist so far has been perfect, and I can't wait for them to add more new songs when Chinese Democracy is out! :peace: Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: AdZ on March 21, 2007, 01:03:30 PM Classic era? What the fuck?
Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: ChrisPittman on March 21, 2007, 01:15:10 PM Forbidden to play tracks from Use Your Illusion? :confused: Besides, in an online interview recently Bumblefoot (I think it was him, could have been richard though) said that it's not impossible that the band will play Estranged (or was it Civil War? Don't remember, but it was one of those) in the future. I'm afraid you'll have to come back and tell me who that actually was and what song they were actually speaking about Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: COMAMOTIVE on March 21, 2007, 01:16:39 PM I think the setlist so far has been perfect To each their own :peace: .. but I would'nt go that far Once the album comes, I'd like to see them stand behind the new material to the point where they play some of the classics BUT concentrate heavily on the new album's stuff Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: babydolls on March 21, 2007, 01:18:30 PM I dont think there is any way of preventing any artist or any band from playing or covering any song in a set. I dont think it would be possible for GnR to not be allowed to play songs from UYI as mentioned. I could be wrong - but I doubt it.
still hoping to hear locomotive live one these days though - that would be special. Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: ChrisPittman on March 21, 2007, 01:18:50 PM Classic era?? What the fuck? Lets recap, the band last released a studio album on Nov 23rd 1993 They played no public concerts between July 1993 and Dec 2000, and they have not released any official material containing any members of the band who joined from 1994 onwards. I think it would be right to call the songs played by the Guns N' Roses 85-93, the Classic Era of the band, since Classic denotes something which has past us and matured over time, but cannot be fully recreated to the expectations of the memories created when it originally happened Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Krispy Kreme on March 21, 2007, 01:19:01 PM I think it is an interesting idea, maybe these are the nebulous legal problems that are always alluded to. ?
Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Apollon on March 21, 2007, 01:19:05 PM I had a similar thought...
Perhaps (just perhaps) there is a lawsuit which forbids Axl to play all after-Lies songs... Maybe this lawsuit was intended by Slash & Duff... Maybe Not... Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Africa on March 21, 2007, 01:24:22 PM Forbidden to play tracks from Use Your Illusion? :confused: Besides, in an online interview recently Bumblefoot (I think it was him, could have been richard though) said that it's not impossible that the band will play Estranged (or was it Civil War? Don't remember, but it was one of those) in the future. I'm afraid you'll have to come back and tell me who that actually was and what song they were actually speaking about I would if I could! Perhaps someone could help me out? It was an online interview conducted by a fan, posted on this site not long ago. Ring any bells? If so, post up the interview. Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Jonx on March 21, 2007, 01:27:23 PM If you look at it this way, Dont Cry, You Could be Mine, November Rain were all around during the Appetite Era, i know for certain Dont Cry was recorded as a demo back then, and a version of You Could be Mine was done during the Appetite era but didnt come out sounding right. November Rain was Axl's baby so i would say its highly probable he made damn certain he owned everything that went on with that song.
As for Knockin on Heavens Door and Live and Let Die, they are covers so he effectively has free reign over how and when he plays them! Same with Down on the Farm, he can skip old Guns legal arrangements and go right back to the original source! In other words we really have no idea whats going on behind the scenes, but the above does make sense! Jonx Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: CheapJon on March 21, 2007, 01:47:04 PM where does november rain fit in with that logic about UYI tunes would be forbidden unless they are covers, same goes with YCBM, that shit about the time they were written is down right bullcrap : ok:
u know what i mean they play what they wanna play and 75% (probably more) of the crowds wanna hear Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: Jonx on March 21, 2007, 01:54:50 PM where does november rain fit in with that logic about UYI tunes would be forbidden unless they are covers, same goes with YCBM, that shit about the time they were written is down right bullcrap : ok: u know what i mean they play what they wanna play and 75% (probably more) of the crowds wanna hear Read above, they were all around during the appetite era and had been recorded in one form or another, therefore in order to protect them they are most probably part of the Appetite package! Jonx Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: don_vercetti on March 21, 2007, 02:55:33 PM where does november rain fit in with that logic about UYI tunes would be forbidden unless they are covers, same goes with YCBM, that shit about the time they were written is down right bullcrap : ok: u know what i mean they play what they wanna play and 75% (probably more) of the crowds wanna hear Read above, they were all around during the appetite era and had been recorded in one form or another, therefore in order to protect them they are most probably part of the Appetite package! Jonx But there are several other tunes recorded before AFD that they don't play, for example, Back Off Bitch, Bad Obsession, Yesterdays, all fairly popular tracks with the fans. I can see the link, but it's slightly tenuous. Nonetheless, I'd love to hear the band do some Izzy numbers, stuff like Dust N Bones, 14 Years, Pretty Tied Up and DTJ. Title: Re: Since 2001, What Songs Have The New Guns N Roses Played from the Classic Era Post by: CheapJon on March 21, 2007, 03:50:04 PM where does november rain fit in with that logic about UYI tunes would be forbidden unless they are covers, same goes with YCBM, that shit about the time they were written is down right bullcrap : ok: u know what i mean they play what they wanna play and 75% (probably more) of the crowds wanna hear they were all around during the appetite era and had been recorded in one form or another, therefore in order to protect them they are most probably part of the Appetite package! yeah they were around before.. but they are part of the "UYI package" on not the "appetite package" (not knowing wtf i mean :hihi:) but they (the songs) as we all know were on UYI and not AFD. there are several other tunes recorded before AFD that they don't play, for example, Back Off Bitch, Bad Obsession, Yesterdays, all fairly popular tracks with the fans. I can see the link, but it's slightly tenuous. Nonetheless, I'd love to hear the band do some Izzy numbers, stuff like Dust N Bones, 14 Years, Pretty Tied Up and DTJ. exactly.. and yeah i'd love to hear "14 years" n' PTU also, and duffs "so fine" but the reason that they don't play those songs are not because they are not allowed to play 'em, they can play whatever fucking song they wanna play.. as i said before they play what they wanna play and what the majority of the crowds wanna hear |