|
Title: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: CAFC Nick on February 10, 2007, 10:48:28 AM I was just thinking about it, listening to Rock in Rio III...
Does the clean-tone voice suit some of the songs better? I think it does... I think Madagascar and The Blues are perfect example of where the clean-tone voice suits the song better. The older songs are more suited to his raspy voice but I think these two songs are definitely better with the clean-tone. What do you think? Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: Robman? on February 10, 2007, 12:10:23 PM Yeah, I can see where some people are coming from when they say they like his voice on maddy and the blues in '01-02. His clean voice certainly suited those songs. I don't see why he couldn't put on the clean voice to sing it, but the clean voice may have been due to bad vocal habits.
I think both song sounds good now though and Axl still does an amazing job. Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: EFISH on February 10, 2007, 12:10:59 PM Deffinetly Madagascar.
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: jimb0 on February 10, 2007, 01:36:02 PM If I had never of heard it, I wouldn't have thought so, but kinda.
SHHHHH WE DON'T NEED HIM TO READ THIS AND RE-RECORD TO FURTHER PUSH BACK CD. Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: Dr_Sweden on February 11, 2007, 01:52:47 PM NO...
the "clean" 01/02 voice sucked big time ... now hes back with POWER in his voice. ... ... Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: vietnow138 on February 12, 2007, 04:44:16 PM I think it did for a few of the songs like Madagascar and The Blues, but other than that I think it actually butchered some of the songs such as nighttrain.
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: CAFC Nick on February 17, 2007, 12:29:15 PM I think it did for a few of the songs like Madagascar and The Blues, but other than that I think it actually butchered some of the songs such as nighttrain. So true. I think that song needs the raw power to the vocals. Although, Axl's shout was more powerful in '02 on Madagascar than it is now IMO. Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: misterID on February 17, 2007, 02:19:25 PM His 02 voice was pretty bad... I think mainly because he really didn't want to be singing at that point and he was just going through the motions... But the 01 voice was really fucking good.
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: novemberparadise23 on February 17, 2007, 02:48:38 PM the 02 voice wasnt horrible in my opinion but in no way was it better than his voice now 06 voice kicks ass :peace:
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: Chris Axl on February 17, 2007, 02:49:52 PM His 02 voice was pretty bad... I think mainly because he really didn't want to be singing at that point and he was just going through the motions... But the 01 voice was really fucking good. How can you say that hes voice in 02' was really bad, when hes vocie in 01' was fucking good?? Myself, I like hes 01'/02' voice, but I like hes 06' alot more Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: misterID on February 17, 2007, 07:43:24 PM Because his 01 voice sounded better than his 02 voice?
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: Irish gunner II on February 17, 2007, 07:56:28 PM IMO the 2002 voice wasnt bad it was just so so different from what we as fans are used to hearing.
Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: Chris Axl on February 18, 2007, 05:34:48 PM Because his 01 voice sounded better than his 02 voice? Their almoust the same dude.....Title: Re: Did the clean tone voice suit some songs better? Post by: EFISH on February 18, 2007, 06:26:21 PM Actually, there was a pretty signifigant difference between 01 and 02. 01 was still that clean tone but he actaully kept it cool, in '02 it was just all over the place, a big mess.
|