|
Title: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: axlrosehunny on December 10, 2006, 05:49:02 PM Guns N Roses stole the Mellody for Cival War, from.... The Ants go marching.
Sing it. The ants go marching one by one, hurra hurra. The ants go marching one by one, Hurra! Hurra! Now, wistle the start of Cival War...... They sound exactly the same!!!!! Fuck. I wounder what band wrote the Ants Go Marching? This is probably why GNR release Cival War on the charrity album, so they couldnt get sued Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: mdttkk on December 10, 2006, 05:52:11 PM yeah im s ure the ants go marching is a great song that is worth a listen. just because a tiny bit of the song sounds the same (which i dont even know because i havent listened to it), doesnt mean that they copied. im sure all 7 minutes and 42 seconds of civil war sound the same and have even worse lyrics than The Ants Go Marching (u can already tell its a great track because of the name) :yes:
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: Pingouirose on December 10, 2006, 05:52:59 PM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZPl1IATUd9U
Just imagine this song opening UYI2 ;D :rofl: Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: LittleFly on December 10, 2006, 05:56:27 PM Isn't the Ants Go Marching taken from an old Civil War marching tune? So in effect then...... ?GNRs Civil War was stolen from the Ants Go Marching, which was taken from the Civil War. ?
It really only goes around in circles huh? :hihi: Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: Jimmy? on December 10, 2006, 05:59:00 PM I really think some people read too much into things....
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: Mr. Nik™ on December 10, 2006, 06:03:00 PM pathetic
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: cody6977 on December 10, 2006, 06:03:42 PM ok? ::)
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: jarmo on December 10, 2006, 06:05:13 PM So how does this work? That is just proof that GNR stole that song and made it there own.. Whistling a wellknown song from the Civil War during the intro of a song called Civil War is hardly stealing the song. ::) /jarmo Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: axe on December 10, 2006, 06:06:01 PM Fuck, this has to be one of the stupidest threads ever - again. They really should release a new album, so maybe - just maybe - we could get rid of these kind of topics.
"They stole a song and made it their own"... I never use those stupid yellow ball thingys, but this one sure leaves me rolling on the floor. By the way, you should wait 50 years (or is it even longer in USA?) before "stealing" Better. GNR waited long enough so they wouldn't get sued for copyrights! Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: cody6977 on December 10, 2006, 06:06:36 PM gotta love GNR fans ::)....maybe we do have too much time on our hands....
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: GNR4L on December 10, 2006, 06:09:18 PM who cares im waiting for Chinese Democracy !!!!! guess what its coming Wink Wink :hihi:
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: Jimmy? on December 10, 2006, 06:10:20 PM I am counting all the little action things here, that are eye rolling-------------> ::) Total fucking geeks Total fuckin twat Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: LittleFly on December 10, 2006, 06:12:10 PM So how does this work? That is just proof that GNR stole that song and made it there own.. Whistling a wellknown song from the Civil War during the intro of a song called Civil War is hardly stealing the song. ::) /jarmo Really? Even if the whole mellody, that is based on the intro whistle, comes from an other song? So you are telling me that if I put out a record at whistle the SCOM mellody and use it as my own throughout the song, I wouldnt be sued or anything? It is fucking stealing Do you pay royalties every time you sing Happy Birthday? ?Same concept. ?Its not copywrited any more so anyone can use it. ? Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: gokken on December 10, 2006, 06:12:27 PM Guns N Roses stole the Mellody for Cival War, from.... The Ants go marching. Sing it. The ants go marching one by one, hurra hurra. The ants go marching one by one, Hurra! Hurra! Now, wistle the start of Cival War...... They sound exactly the same!!!!! Fuck. I wounder what band wrote the Ants Go Marching? This is probably why GNR release Cival War on the charrity album, so they couldnt get sued Is this a joke? :) Of course they did and its not like they were hoping no one would notice. This thread is a joke, right? Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: axlrosehunny on December 10, 2006, 06:13:06 PM Guns N Roses stole the Mellody for Cival War, from.... The Ants go marching. Sing it. The ants go marching one by one, hurra hurra. The ants go marching one by one, Hurra! Hurra! Now, wistle the start of Cival War...... They sound exactly the same!!!!! Fuck. I wounder what band wrote the Ants Go Marching? This is probably why GNR release Cival War on the charrity album, so they couldnt get sued Is this a joke? :) Of course they did and its not like they were hoping no one would notice. This thread is a joke, right? No fucking kidding... Kiddy Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: cody6977 on December 10, 2006, 06:13:40 PM I'm afraid to say it's not...
Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: jarmo on December 10, 2006, 06:13:48 PM So how does this work? That is just proof that GNR stole that song and made it there own.. Whistling a wellknown song from the Civil War during the intro of a song called Civil War is hardly stealing the song. ::) /jarmo Really? Even if the whole mellody, that is based on the intro whistle, comes from an other song? So you are telling me that if I put out a record at whistle the SCOM mellody and use it as my own throughout the song, I wouldnt be sued or anything? It is fucking stealing Do you know when the American civil war was? Do you know when Appetite For Destruction was released? Do you need an explanation? ::) Maybe you can write a song based on Happy Birthday and your national anthem as well. /jarmo Title: Re: GNR stole Cival War! Post by: Skeba on December 11, 2006, 03:30:29 AM I know this is locked, but this is kind of interesting:
http://www.snopes.com/music/songs/birthday.asp But traditional songs that have no known composers, or are more than x (not sure of the figure here) years old are not protected by copyright. |