|
Title: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: HamsterDemocracy on October 04, 2006, 11:49:16 PM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OsViIu9SLo
Holy fucking shit that is absolutely amazing! I mean Axl's vocals are really really raspy but it works here, gives the song a hard-edged sleaze. I haven't seen this one posted before, I put it in the YouTube thread but decided more people might see it in Dead Horse too, and I wanted to know what YOU think the best YCBM of all-time is and also, does anyone have audio of this whole show? I can't get over how awesome that performance is. I like when he says ''I'll leave you lyin' on the beeed'' - it sounds different than usual and kind of nasal-y. Awesome stuff. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Alina on October 05, 2006, 10:29:20 AM yeah cool link , never saw this before
you can download the whole show on GNR BANNED : ok: Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Slipdisc on October 05, 2006, 10:51:39 AM I always appreciate it when people discover something they're passionate about and decide to share it with others. So thank you for that. Having said that, I don't agree with this being an ace performance of the song. To me the instrumental section sounds generally weak and too sloppy at times, whereas Axl's vocals sound very shot/ worn out.
-PEACE- Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: kaasupoltin on October 05, 2006, 10:56:32 AM I know better versions.. Paris 1993 for example.
Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: TheMole on October 05, 2006, 10:58:45 AM I always appreciate it when people discover something they're passionate about and decide to share it with others. So thank you for that. Having said that, I don't agree with this being an ace performance of the song. To me the instrumental section sounds generally weak and too sloppy at times, whereas Axl's vocals sound very shot/ worn out. -PEACE- Agreed on the voice-thing. Concerning the sloppyness of the band: well, that's old skool kick ass rock n' roll for ya man, either you dig it, or you don't. To each his own. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Slipdisc on October 05, 2006, 11:14:07 AM Lol, don't try to make this look like I'm not into old-school RnR.
I too started as (solely) a fan of the old band and have seen practically every show worth mentioning of them. This performance to me, instrumentally, doesn't live up to the old band's status quo in those days. I'm not comparing this to the new band: I'm only comparing the old band to itself at other moments times ? and in this context (instrumentally) this isn't "kick ass" or "old school" at all IMHO... -PEACE- Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Skinflick on October 05, 2006, 11:55:02 AM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OsViIu9SLo Holy fucking shit that is absolutely amazing! I mean Axl's vocals are really really raspy but it works here, gives the song a hard-edged sleaze. I haven't seen this one posted before, I put it in the YouTube thread but decided more people might see it in Dead Horse too, and I wanted to know what YOU think the best YCBM of all-time is and also, does anyone have audio of this whole show? I can't get over how awesome that performance is. I like when he says ''I'll leave you lyin' on the beeed'' - it sounds different than usual and kind of nasal-y. Awesome stuff. Dude, I usually agree with most of the things that you post.....especially when talking about Axl's voice....but there are a MILLION better performances of YCBM....a million......his voice was a bit gone during most of this show....I have this at home as well as a million others that are better.....does it suck?...no....but it is hardly good..... :peace: Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: luciano on October 05, 2006, 12:42:33 PM *********
In my book the best performance ever of You Could be Mine was in Rio de Janeiro, January 23, 1991. Axl misses some lines because he has got problems with his microphone, and Izzy sings them. And he also misses some lines because (probably) he still hadn't memorized all the lyrics (it was only the second ever live performance of the song). But since Axl is great, he manages to make it sound even better. And, most important, the passion. This version has IT, loads of. Band was happy onstage. Band was actually crazy onstage, that was the biggest show of Guns n' Roses to date. They were in heaven that night. Please try and listen to it. And please watch the video. You will love it. Luciano ********* Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: HamsterDemocracy on October 05, 2006, 04:25:27 PM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OsViIu9SLo Holy fucking shit that is absolutely amazing! I mean Axl's vocals are really really raspy but it works here, gives the song a hard-edged sleaze. I haven't seen this one posted before, I put it in the YouTube thread but decided more people might see it in Dead Horse too, and I wanted to know what YOU think the best YCBM of all-time is and also, does anyone have audio of this whole show? I can't get over how awesome that performance is. I like when he says ''I'll leave you lyin' on the beeed'' - it sounds different than usual and kind of nasal-y. Awesome stuff. Dude, I usually agree with most of the things that you post.....especially when talking about Axl's voice....but there are a MILLION better performances of YCBM....a million......his voice was a bit gone during most of this show....I have this at home as well as a million others that are better.....does it suck?...no....but it is hardly good..... :peace: See, I think his voice sounds raw - in a good way. It fits the song. Compare his current "Yow" (which sounds like a high-pitched squeal) to the lion's roar he lets out here, it's amazing. Right after he says "Think we've seen that movie toooo - OOWWWWW!" That's awesome IMO. And yeah the rhythm section doesn't sound as perfect as at other performances or as perfect as it is today, but that's just straight-up gritty rock n' roll - messy and NOT perfect. If anything I think the new band's flaw is that they sound too perfect at times - it works for the newer songs but some of the old songs benefit from being played kind of sloppy. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: jimb0 on October 05, 2006, 06:22:06 PM I loved the days when the drums were played right. :yes:
Yes its gritty and evil though. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: TheMole on October 06, 2006, 02:48:42 AM Lol, don't try to make this look like I'm not into old-school RnR. I too started as (solely) a fan of the old band and have seen practically every show worth mentioning of them. This performance to me, instrumentally, doesn't live up to the old band's status quo in those days. I'm not comparing this to the new band: I'm only comparing the old band to itself at other moments times ? and in this context (instrumentally) this isn't "kick ass" or "old school" at all IMHO... -PEACE- Nonono, don't get me wrong. I'm not saying this is a smashing performance, and I didn't think you were comparing to the old band. Sorry if it came accross like I was diminishing your love for the old band, not at all. All I was saying was: it's rock n' roll, not rocket science, there's bound to be some sloppy playing and some rougher sounding performances. As long as the musicians are into it, it's ok for me, it's fun to watch. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Skinflick on October 06, 2006, 08:51:27 AM ********* In my book the best performance ever of You Could be Mine was in Rio de Janeiro, January 23, 1991. Axl misses some lines because he has got problems with his microphone, and Izzy sings them. And he also misses some lines because (probably) he still hadn't memorized all the lyrics (it was only the second ever live performance of the song). But since Axl is great, he manages to make it sound even better. And, most important, the passion. This version has IT, loads of. Band was happy onstage. Band was actually crazy onstage, that was the biggest show of Guns n' Roses to date. They were in heaven that night. Please try and listen to it. And please watch the video. You will love it. Luciano ********* Then you need to see more live versions of YCBM because the one in RIO 2 was probably the worst.....without a doubt Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Skinflick on October 06, 2006, 08:54:14 AM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OsViIu9SLo Holy fucking shit that is absolutely amazing! I mean Axl's vocals are really really raspy but it works here, gives the song a hard-edged sleaze. I haven't seen this one posted before, I put it in the YouTube thread but decided more people might see it in Dead Horse too, and I wanted to know what YOU think the best YCBM of all-time is and also, does anyone have audio of this whole show? I can't get over how awesome that performance is. I like when he says ''I'll leave you lyin' on the beeed'' - it sounds different than usual and kind of nasal-y. Awesome stuff. Dude, I usually agree with most of the things that you post.....especially when talking about Axl's voice....but there are a MILLION better performances of YCBM....a million......his voice was a bit gone during most of this show....I have this at home as well as a million others that are better.....does it suck?...no....but it is hardly good..... :peace: See, I think his voice sounds raw - in a good way. It fits the song. Compare his current "Yow" (which sounds like a high-pitched squeal) to the lion's roar he lets out here, it's amazing. Right after he says "Think we've seen that movie toooo - OOWWWWW!" That's awesome IMO. And yeah the rhythm section doesn't sound as perfect as at other performances or as perfect as it is today, but that's just straight-up gritty rock n' roll - messy and NOT perfect. If anything I think the new band's flaw is that they sound too perfect at times - it works for the newer songs but some of the old songs benefit from being played kind of sloppy. He does that ooowww howling thing (that only he can do) the same or better in 92 and ESPECIALLY 92 versions of that song...I have a ton of them....I do see your point....but I wasn't talking about how he does it now...I really don't think that the song has the same bite now as it used to live...... :peace: Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Wolfpac on October 06, 2006, 06:35:48 PM I like the video 'welcome to mcdoogle's' that's on the side link..... Never seen it before...
Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: Irish gunner II on October 06, 2006, 07:37:09 PM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SoRRH_WODuI&mode=related&search=
This is the rio performance that was mentioned above. Title: Re: The absolute BEST performance of You Could Be Mine - ever! Post by: IzzyDutch on October 07, 2006, 01:40:20 PM ^ hehe the reactions on that link... it was Axl's fault the mic broke, that's what you get when you drop it :P? It dropped when he was taking off his jacket and he let go of the mic standard too soon. And Slash/Izzy/Duff saw it falling too.
Izzy singing is cool like the usual 8) |