Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Guns N' Roses => Dead Horse => Topic started by: Christian on August 04, 2006, 09:06:54 AM



Title: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: Christian on August 04, 2006, 09:06:54 AM
Hey.
First of all, i like so much this "new" guns n' roses.
I like so much each new member of this band.

But, i was thinking about one thing:
And if chinese democracy has other players than Robin, Fortus and Buckethead doin' the guitar parts?
I'm not talking about like the work of Brian May, special participations and etc, but if it has some Paul Tobias stuff. A lot of songs has been working for since 2000, and Fortus is in the band since 2002 only
And if the CD has a lot of work with a lot of different people (orchestration, for example)?
I mean, axl has worked with a lot of people, and i know Robin has been in the band since 99, but i wouldn't like to see in the song credits people that really doesn't make part of the band now, except for Buckethead.

I hope you can understand what i'm trying to say..
sorry for the bad english too



Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: A Private Eye on August 04, 2006, 09:11:14 AM
Aside from Ron the current lineup has all been there long enough to have recorded their own parts for CD. Other than Ron I would expect to see all the current players be credited with the music.


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: Christian on August 04, 2006, 09:15:37 AM
Aside from Ron the current lineup has all been there long enough to have recorded their own parts for CD. Other than Ron I would expect to see all the current players be credited with the music.

yeah, i hope that too.
I want to see then and ONLY then, that's exactly what i'm tryin to say.
Just buckethead, or brian may, nobody else.
CD has to be a solid stuff, not a bunch of songs mixed from 99 too 2006 with different players on it.


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: b0b0 on August 04, 2006, 09:21:53 AM
Hey.
First of all, i like so much this "new" guns n' roses.
I like so much each new member of this band.

But, i was thinking about one thing:
And if chinese democracy has other players than Robin, Fortus and Buckethead doin' the guitar parts?
I'm not talking about like the work of Brian May, special participations and etc, but if it has some Paul Tobias stuff. A lot of songs has been working for since 2000, and Fortus is in the band since 2002 only
And if the CD has a lot of work with a lot of different people (orchestration, for example)?
I mean, axl has worked with a lot of people, and i know Robin has been in the band since 99, but i wouldn't like to see in the song credits people that really doesn't make part of the band now, except for Buckethead.

I hope you can understand what i'm trying to say..
sorry for the bad english too




Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: ryan_of_lax on August 04, 2006, 10:26:55 AM
Let's say the CD has 14 songs.
Ron could easily record all those parts in a week. It's just guitar work, you really can't get into too much studio magic with it. So, it doesn't take long, unless he can't play the parts well enough.

Unless the CD is mixed and mastered already....

But I really don't think Paul will be on this CD. He's like the forgotten member...


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: michaelvincent on August 04, 2006, 11:18:43 AM
I have a feeling there will be all sorts of interesting little things from a wide array of people on this album.


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: slashisvr on August 04, 2006, 12:00:34 PM
i dont think ron could do BH's parts


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: Christian on August 05, 2006, 10:18:39 AM
i dont think ron could do BH's parts

Why not?
Fortus, who has another player style, could do, why not ron, who is similar to buck?
I think he can do, but i think he won't do.


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: slashisvr on August 05, 2006, 01:05:46 PM
i dont think ron could do BH's parts

Why not?
Fortus, who has another player style, could do, why not ron, who is similar to buck?
I think he can do, but i think he won't do.

i just dont think he has the ability and the style BH did/has, i mean its like its hard to get someone who can play like slash, its hard to get his unique sound!i think BH had that same unuique sound, not the same as slashs you understand but  his own unique style  : ok:


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: mikegiuliana on August 07, 2006, 04:56:02 AM
It's so stupid to think someone who's not even in the band had major roles in the songs and he's out of the band before their debut album...

Also fortus probably had little to do with many of these song, they were done before he even walked through the door.. Tinkering is hardly creating


Title: Re: One thing that i wouldn't like about CD
Post by: Six Strings on August 07, 2006, 07:44:17 AM
There won't be Buckethead in the album. If there was...the album might be out already!