|
Title: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: bc2013 on July 13, 2006, 09:27:23 AM i like bother you can find the vr one here and the other at newgnr.com. i cant decide. so what do you guys think?
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: makane on July 13, 2006, 10:29:07 AM VR one obviously 'cause it's playd by Slash & Duff.
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: MarioGunner on July 13, 2006, 10:52:24 AM Since Axl?s voice is not that particular there, scott sings it well, and when it comes to the music, for some reason i feel like VR plays it more solid, the solo sounds just right, like it is and and it sounds more full, the rhythm is also more heard, i like it better.
It only lacks the screaming of Axl in " I ain't got no money but it goes to show" after that it?s definitely cooler. : ok: Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: slashisvr on July 13, 2006, 11:27:05 AM VR's version for many reasons
1.slash and duff are playing it 2. slash's unqu sound fits better with the song 3.scott does the song alot of justice 4.the solo by slash is just awsome basically i prefer it because slash is playing it, along with mr brownstone : ok: Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Locomotive98 on July 13, 2006, 02:21:25 PM Same as that, Slashisvr
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: chineseblues on July 13, 2006, 02:29:31 PM gnr's obviously. Scott should never sing any gnr song with his crappy voice. 8)
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: slashisvr on July 13, 2006, 02:33:43 PM gnr's obviously. Scott should never sing any gnr song with his crappy voice.? 8) they have as much right to play those songs as axl, scott does the song alot of justice!!!! Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: makane on July 13, 2006, 03:53:31 PM gnr's obviously. Scott should never sing any gnr song with his crappy voice.? 8) Why did you have to insult Scott? No one insulted Axl or hes band here? Oh yeah, you're Chineseblues. Go put your Axl pics in your diary.Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: JAC185 on July 13, 2006, 03:55:30 PM VRs version, it has the total attitude of the song down to a tee, i do miss the screaming at the end though
Axl pretty much seems to talk the lower parts now from what i've seen Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: slashisvr on July 13, 2006, 04:00:25 PM scott doesnt have a great singing voice like axl, both diffrent styles but the way axl sung it makes scott do the song a whole lot of justice as iv said many a time, the first time i heard it live i was scared scott would wreck the song, but i was blown away, he also gives the song a new energy live
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: mrlee on July 13, 2006, 08:10:23 PM VRs version, it has the total attitude of the song down to a tee, i do miss the screaming at the end though Axl pretty much seems to talk the lower parts now from what i've seen listen to his donnington 2005 performance of it, he(scott) does scream the ending. Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: mikegiuliana on July 14, 2006, 05:04:47 AM shit I've heard this song live between both bands 6 times
I think hearing it from new gnr has really lost it's magic.. it doesn't have any of the musicians that made it playing it.. I find it easier to hear it from vr because it's supposed to be a cover, when you hear it from new gnr it's suppose to be gnr.. Doesn't work for me Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Jim Bob on July 14, 2006, 05:59:05 AM GNRs version anyday. Scott sounds better on this one than Mr Brownstone ::) But without Axl it just doesn't sound right and I like Robin's leads. 8)
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: tomass74 on July 14, 2006, 11:51:46 AM VR by a mile....
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: slashisvr on July 14, 2006, 12:08:33 PM shit I've heard this song live between both bands 6 times I think hearing it from new gnr has really lost it's magic.. it doesn't have any of the musicians that made it playing it.. I find it easier to hear it from vr because it's supposed to be a cover, when you hear it from new gnr it's suppose to be gnr.. Doesn't work for me my thoughts exactly Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Krispy Kreme on July 14, 2006, 12:50:11 PM old gnr over vr
vr over new gnr Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: slashisvr on July 14, 2006, 01:23:57 PM Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Slashead on July 16, 2006, 01:37:32 PM VR version is way better.
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Locomotive98 on July 16, 2006, 01:40:03 PM Yup VR for me too. New GNR have tarnished it beyond belief.
Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: Origen on July 16, 2006, 02:11:24 PM VR.
Vocally Axl is superior to Scott singing it, but then again Scott is singing a cover song and Axl is singing his own song, so it's difficult to compare. Musically, Slash/Duff/Matt (and even Dave) do it far better then NuGnR. When VR does it it sounds like Rock N Roll, you can hear all the instruments clearly, it sounds rough and that is how it's ment to sound. When GnR do it now it sounds too polish, too much noise and you can't identify any sound individually in it. Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: tomass74 on July 18, 2006, 10:08:05 AM VR. Vocally Axl is superior to Scott singing it, but then again Scott is singing a cover song and Axl is singing his own song, so it's difficult to compare. Musically, Slash/Duff/Matt (and even Dave) do it far better then NuGnR. When VR does it it sounds like Rock N Roll, you can hear all the instruments clearly, it sounds rough and that is how it's ment to sound. When GnR do it now it sounds too polish, too much noise and you can't identify any sound individually in it. I hate they way Axl's band plays the old songs.. There is no need for keyboards in Appetite songs.. Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: mikegiuliana on July 21, 2006, 03:07:58 AM VR. Vocally Axl is superior to Scott singing it, but then again Scott is singing a cover song and Axl is singing his own song, so it's difficult to compare. Musically, Slash/Duff/Matt (and even Dave) do it far better then NuGnR. When VR does it it sounds like Rock N Roll, you can hear all the instruments clearly, it sounds rough and that is how it's ment to sound. When GnR do it now it sounds too polish, too much noise and you can't identify any sound individually in it. I hate they way Axl's band plays the old songs.. There is no need for keyboards in Appetite songs.. well with a setlist of 10 afd songs the band would have to sit off to the side.. AFD only needs 5.. :smoking: Dizzy plays the bongos too during wttj Title: Re: which version of its so easy live do you like is best? Post by: MarioGunner on July 21, 2006, 02:32:02 PM Since Axl?s voice is not that particular there, scott sings it well, and when it comes to the music, for some reason i feel? like VR plays it more solid, the solo sounds just right, like it is and and it sounds more full, the rhythm is also more heard, i like it better. It only lacks the screaming of Axl in " I ain't got no money but it goes to show" after that it?s definitely cooler.? : ok: VR. Vocally Axl is superior to Scott singing it, but then again Scott is singing a cover song and Axl is singing his own song, so it's difficult to compare. Musically, Slash/Duff/Matt (and even Dave) do it far better then NuGnR. When VR does it it sounds like Rock N Roll, you can hear all the instruments clearly, it sounds rough and that is how it's ment to sound. When GnR do it now it sounds too polish, too much noise and you can't identify any sound individually in it. That's the basis, the music, VR plays it better, no doubt about it. GNRs version anyday. Scott sounds better on this one than Mr Brownstone ::) But without Axl it just doesn't sound right and I like Robin's leads. 8) How can you like robin's leads? damn!!! i'm getting tired of robin fucking up the songs, really... he's not good enough for GN'R, not even this version of GN'R I'm Sorry for any offense taken, just my opinion :smoking: |