|
Title: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: 14 Years Estranged on June 22, 2006, 08:26:14 PM Someone asked me a question two days ago that made me think about this: "If you could create your own line-up for Guns N' Roses keeping Axl Rose as the original remaining member of the 1987-1996 line-up... who would you pick for the line-up?"
Mine was this: Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) - Vocals, Rhythm Guitar Tim Skold (Marilyn Manson, KMFDM) - Lead Guitar Christian O. Wolbers (Front Line Assembly, Fear Factory) - Lead Guitar Robin Finck (Nine Inch Nails, Guns N' Roses) - Lead & Rhythm Guitar Al Pitrelli (Suicidal Tendencies, Megadeth) - Lead & Rhythtm Guitar Sean Yseult (White Zombie) - Bass John Tempesta (White/Rob Zombie, Scum Of The Earth) - Drums Dizzy Reed (Guns N' Roses) - Keyboards Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: saint seiya on June 22, 2006, 08:29:20 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Stradlin Duff Dizzy Matt Sorum Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: 14 Years Estranged on June 22, 2006, 08:40:13 PM Bah... Mind you that Axl had to be the only original member of the 1987-1996 line up... ::)
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Evolution on June 22, 2006, 08:50:19 PM Is it too predictable to name the current line up? ;)
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: KILLYOURIDOL on June 22, 2006, 08:56:03 PM Axl
Dimebag Darrell (Pantera,Damgeplan)Lead Guitar(R.I.P the man was a god) Jerry Cantrell(AIC)Lead/Rythm Guitar Angus Young(AC/DC)Lead Guitar Jason Newsted(Metallica)Bass Dave Grohl(Nirvana,Foo Fighters)Drums Teddy Zig Zag Keyboard and a fucking kick ass harmonica Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: bazgnr on June 22, 2006, 09:40:27 PM Is it too predictable to name the current line up?? ;) Nope. That'd be my choice. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Niko on June 22, 2006, 10:18:31 PM Axl
Joe Perry Gilby Clarke Jason Newsted Dave Grohl (whoaaa this line-up would kick ass) !! Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: EFISH on June 22, 2006, 10:22:11 PM the current line-up!
IF anything could change, slash gets in there instead of Bumble. but, that'd be a little much.. finck is pretty much the new slash and i dont want finck to go. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: johnnythunders24 on June 22, 2006, 10:30:25 PM Axl - Lead Vocals
Robin - Lead Guitar Ron Thal- Guitar Richard Fortus- Guitar Tommy- Bass Brain- Drums Dizzy- Keyboards Chris Pitman- Synth : ok: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Niko on June 22, 2006, 10:38:56 PM Axl - Lead Vocals Robin - Lead Guitar Ron Thal- Guitar Richard Fortus- Guitar Tommy- Bass Brain- Drums Dizzy- Keyboards Chris Pitman- Synth : ok: come on guys!!! the idea of the thread is for you to be creative, not to show that you like the new band or the old band, beacause we are always getting back to that old dead horse Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Stonerose on June 22, 2006, 10:51:32 PM Sorry but.....
Axl Rose Vocals Izzy Stradlin Rythem Guitar Duff Mckagen Bass Slash Lead Steven Adler Drums Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Mattattack on June 22, 2006, 11:11:30 PM Under the assumption that everybody is in their prime.
Vocals Axl Rose Guitar Jimmy Page Bass John Paul Jones Drums John Bonham Axl fronting Zeppelin would have been the best. I like Plants voice but I don't relate to his Lord of The Rings style lyrics. The new Gnr's sound, especially on Madagascar, reminds me a lot of Zeppelin. The fact Axl is so willing to experiment with any style of music is something i'm sure he picked up from Zeppelin and other acts like Queen. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Carlos_f_Rose on June 22, 2006, 11:26:46 PM Sorry but..... Axl Rose? ?Vocals Izzy Stradlin? ?Rythem Guitar Duff Mckagen? ?Bass Slash? ?Lead Steven Adler? ?Drums Same here... Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: mikepatton on June 22, 2006, 11:29:12 PM stupidest question ever.........the 1987 lineup..............axl, slash, izzy, steven and duff...miek clink as the producer..case closed.............
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: SOH on June 23, 2006, 12:22:30 AM Axl - Vocals
Les Claypool - Bass "Weird Al" Yankovic - Accordian Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: AXL 20 on June 23, 2006, 12:36:50 AM 87 for sure
even 92 but if we have to (all living) Axl- Vocals Brian May- Lead/Rythm guitar Jeff Beck- Lead Guitar Joe Perry- Lead/Rythm guitar Billy Sheehan- Bass Roger Taylor- Drums John Paul Jones- Keyboards, Piano That would be a killer group. Joe Perry's bluesy tone combined with Brian May's unmistakable sound backing a Jeff Beck Solo with a Billy Sheehan bassline and Roger Taylor and John Paul Jones laying down some rythm and AXL fronting it all!!!!! List 2 (deceased) Axl- Vocals Freddie Mercury- Vocals Duane Allman- Lead Guitar Jimi Hendrix- Rythm guitar Randy Rhoads- Lead/Rythm guitar Jaco Pastorious- Bass John Bonham- Drums Freddie Mercury- Keyboards, Piano Axl and Freddie in one band together on stage is a dream of mine that will never come true. My 2 favorite singers. Duane Allman would but the blues into it with Randy Rhoads doing a rythm would almsot compensate for slash and Jimi Hendrix, well hes not as great as they say whihh is why i put him on rythm. And Jaco and John fuckin' Bonham? is there anything left to say? Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: AXL 20 on June 23, 2006, 12:41:05 AM Someone asked me a question two days ago that made me think about this: "If you could create your own line-up for Guns N' Roses keeping Axl Rose as the original remaining member of the 1987-1996 line-up... who would you pick for the line-up?" Mine was this: Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) - Vocals, Rhythm Guitar Tim Skold (Marilyn Manson, KMFDM) - Lead Guitar Christian O. Wolbers (Front Line Assembly, Fear Factory) - Lead Guitar Robin Finck (Nine Inch Nails, Guns N' Roses) - Lead & Rhythm Guitar Al Pitrelli (Suicidal Tendencies, Megadeth) - Lead & Rhythtm Guitar Sean Yseult (White Zombie) - Bass John Tempesta (White/Rob Zombie, Scum Of The Earth) - Drums Dizzy Reed (Guns N' Roses) - Keyboards you contradicted yourself. If Axl was the only remaining guy from 87-96, Dizzy shouldn't be in there Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Locomotive98 on June 23, 2006, 02:08:44 AM Sorry but..... Axl Rose? ?Vocals Izzy Stradlin? ?Rythem Guitar Duff Mckagen? ?Bass Slash? ?Lead Steven Adler? ?Drums Same here... Same again!! Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: supaplex on June 23, 2006, 03:30:37 AM i'll play along
axl ian scott (antrax) - guitar dan donegan (disturbed) - guitar dave grohl (foo fighters) - drums jason newsted - bass pianos and aditional guitars and effects you find someone Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: gandra on June 23, 2006, 03:32:36 AM Axl - Lead Vocals yes man,totally agree with youRobin - Lead Guitar Ron Thal- Guitar Richard Fortus- Guitar Tommy- Bass Brain- Drums Dizzy- Keyboards Chris Pitman- Synth : ok: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: mikegiuliana on June 23, 2006, 04:21:51 AM axl
zakk wylde dave navarro flea dave grohl real list would be of course afd gnr the one and only Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: supaplex on June 23, 2006, 04:44:24 AM axl that's a nice list. it seems a lot of people who actually got into playing this game prefer dave grohl on drums althogh he's not the most technical drummer.zakk wylde dave navarro flea dave grohl real list would be of course afd gnr the one and only and how could i forget about flea man? :nervous: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: nesquick on June 23, 2006, 04:49:11 AM After seeing the new band at the Paris show, I would say:
Axl Slash Fortus Duff Brain Dizzy Richard impressed me as much as Slash, and Brain impressed me more than Matt Sorum when I saw VR. Duff blew me away with VR, I couldn't think he was so great and look so good, what a Rockstar! However, I barely didn"t even pay attention to Tommy. Duff is a fantastic bass player and I miss his background vocals. I miss him in GNR. Dizzy is the old good Dizzwald Reed, love the guy, and he is a great musician! Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: makane on June 23, 2006, 06:14:08 AM Scott
Slash Duff Matt Dave Axl (plays piano behind the curtains) This thread is retarded. You can just throw any guy you want +Axl and it's Guns N' Roses? blah. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Locomotive98 on June 23, 2006, 06:46:21 AM 'This thread is retarded. You can just throw any guy you want +Axl and it's Guns N' Roses? blah.'
Well thats what Axl has done isnt it?! Unfortunately.... Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: CD2006 on June 23, 2006, 07:10:44 AM the current one.
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: dub05 on June 23, 2006, 07:21:54 AM Axl & phillo fronting the greatest guitar band of all time THIN LIZZY............SIMPLE.
What a ridiculous post :rofl: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: mrlee on June 23, 2006, 07:26:31 AM other than illusions line up (gilby era).
obviously Axl ZAKK WYLDE :D (in his old days though, not his new beerified leathers) John Bonham on the drums of course. Cliff burton on the bass Dave Mustaine lol i think ive turned gnr into a metal band :rofl: :rofl: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: estrangedpaul on June 23, 2006, 09:19:56 AM W. Axl Rose = vocals
Steve Vai = Lead Guitar Jimmy Page = Rhythm Guitar Cliff Burton = Bass Guitar Dave Grohl = Drums A rock band doesn't need a keyboardist although Rose can easily do them anyway. I'd love to hear Vai's epic melodic style of guitar playing coupled with the epic style of songwriting of Page and Rose. That could produce some amazing stuff. I love Jimi Hendrix but don't think he and Rose could perform together! Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Tonrey on June 23, 2006, 11:38:40 AM Woah, so many third guitarists. I stills don't get how that works out in the live shows. Do they switch around lead or add extra parts or what?
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: tomass74 on June 25, 2006, 09:07:59 AM Axl
Slash Izzy Stradlin Duff Dizzy Adler or anyone but Sorum Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Locomotive98 on June 25, 2006, 09:11:24 AM Same here Tomass, minus Dizzy though!
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: 14 Years Estranged on July 12, 2006, 08:20:47 PM My thing is that I do not consider Dizzy Reed a member of the 1987-1996 lime-up... even though he was listed as an official member of the line-up during the Use Your Illusion Tours he was and is nothing more than the man who plays the piano when Axl doesn't feel like playing the keys himself so he can jump around the stage.
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: EFISH on July 13, 2006, 12:47:27 AM Axl Rose-Vocals
Slash-Lead Guitar Richard Fortus-Rhythm Guitar Duff Mckagan- Bass Brian Mantia-Drums Dizzy Reed-Keyboards AND... i'm questioning about Pitman and the synth. it's cool, i cant decide if I'd want it if I could actually pick the lineup. I just don't really like tommy that much.. i love The Replacements but i just can't get to liking him in GNR. I don't hate him in GNR, but deffinetly would prefer duff in the allstar lineup! Finck is cool, I'm glad he's in the band these days, but he's a little sloppy. Brain kicks ass over Sorum and Adler too. And, you gotta have Dizzy! There ya have it. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Mandy. on July 13, 2006, 08:57:22 AM Axl - Vocals
Tommy - Bass Izzy - Rhythm Guitar Ron Thal - Lead Guitar Nicko McBrain - Drums Dizzy - Keyboards Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Slashead on July 13, 2006, 10:33:54 AM Slash
Izzy Axl Duff Steven Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: slashisvr on July 13, 2006, 12:25:37 PM ill play too
axl nikki sixx tommy lee ady smith ace freely or axl steve harris Mike Portnoy Yngwie malmsteem izzy stradlin Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: 14 Years Estranged on July 25, 2011, 01:52:40 AM Scott Slash Duff Matt Dave Axl (plays piano behind the curtains) This thread is retarded. You can just throw any guy you want +Axl and it's Guns N' Roses? blah. You do realize that when Axl & Izzy formed Guns N' Roses with Tracii Guns, there was no Slash, Duff or Steven Adler? It was like this: W. Axl Rose: Vocals, Acoustic Guitar & Piano Izzy Stradlin': Rhythm Guitar & Backing Vocals Tracii Guns: Lead Guitar & Backing Vocals Ole Beich: Bass Guitar & Backing Vocals Rob Gardner: Drums Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: AxlsMainMan on July 25, 2011, 01:46:52 PM W. Axl Rose (Guns N' Roses) - Lead Vocals, Piano, Guitar, Percussion
David Gilmour (Pink Floyd) - Lead Guitar, Backup Vocals, Steel Guitar, Synthesizer, Saxophone, Banjo, Mandolin, Harmonica, Talk Box, Programming, Percussion Robin Finck (Nine Inch Nails) - Lead & Rhythm Guitar, Backup Vocals, Ukelele, Mandolin David Knopfler (Dire Straits)- Rhythm Guitar Simon Gallup (The Cure) - Bass Ray Manzarek (The Doors) - Keyboards, Backup Vocals, Organ, Keyboard Bass, Marxophone Danny Carey (Tool, Pigmy Love Circus, VOLTO!, ZAUM, Green Jell?) - Drums, Percussion Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: HBK on July 25, 2011, 04:03:14 PM AXL
IZZY DIZZY ROBIN BUCKY TOMMY PITMAN BRIANIAC Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: duga on July 28, 2011, 02:25:55 PM The UYI line-up (minus Civil War).
Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: rebelhipi on July 28, 2011, 03:05:49 PM The UYI line-up (minus Civil War). agree!Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: D on July 31, 2011, 09:16:02 AM Axl
slash Izzy Duff Steven Dizzy for the UYI stuff Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: One.In.A.Million on August 02, 2011, 03:29:21 PM Axl Rose - Vocals
Robin Finck - Lead Guitar Buckethead - Lead Guitar as well as fills (e.g the third guitar track on some appetite tracks) Bumblefoot - Rhythm Guitar Tommy Stinson - Bass Guitar Dizzy Reed - Keyboard, Percussion Brian "Brain" Mantia - Drums Chris Pitman - Sound FX, Synth, Keyboards This would cause an earthquake, because of how epic it would be... 8) :beer: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: new gnr fan on November 21, 2011, 09:01:00 AM Axl
Buckethead - lead guitar of course Steve Vai - lead guitar Viggo Mortensen - lead guitar Tommy Stinson - bass John Bonham - drums Brian - drums Dizzy Reed - keys Chris Pitman- keys Travis Dickerson - keys sorry, i'm a pitman fan, so he have to stay^^ Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Trist805 on November 22, 2011, 11:45:41 PM Realistically...lol...
AXL, Duff, Adler, and the new guys for a few songs. I would really like to see Adler show up and jam. It would probably appease him about the whole reunion lol Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: new gnr fan on November 23, 2011, 10:20:24 AM Realistically...lol... Its a dream line up, so i can do whatever i want...lol... Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Alfie Bones on November 23, 2011, 10:50:34 PM Axl Rose - lead vocals, piano
DJ Ashba - co-lead guitar Ron Thal - co-lead guitar Izzy Stradlin - rhythm guitar Duff McKagan - bass guitar, backing vocals Dizzy Reed - keyboards, backing vocals, synth, etc. Bryan Mantia - drums, percussion No outsiders needed. If I had to bring in a non-Gunner, I'd say Zakk Wylde as sole lead guitarist. I feel him and Axl would be able to work together fantastically. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: RocketQueenGNR on January 22, 2012, 04:04:29 PM Axl slash Izzy Duff Steven Dizzy for the UYI stuff Totally agree with this line-up ;) Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: One.In.A.Million on January 22, 2012, 06:55:17 PM Axl Rose - Vocals Robin Finck - Lead Guitar Buckethead - Lead Guitar as well as fills (e.g the third guitar track on some appetite tracks) Bumblefoot - Rhythm Guitar Tommy Stinson - Bass Guitar Dizzy Reed - Keyboard, Percussion Brian "Brain" Mantia - Drums Chris Pitman - Sound FX, Synth, Keyboards This would cause an earthquake, because of how epic it would be... 8) :beer: I still stand by this line-up but if we was going to make this as good as it could be, then there's going to have to be a 4th guitarist. And that ladies and gentlemen is going to be Mr Fortus, the best rhythm guitar player GN'R has ever had. I shouldn't have left him out in the first place, as Ron and Bucket are both lead guitarists, who can handle fills as well. The Best Guns N' Roses Line-Up Ever!!! Axl Rose - Vocals Robin Finck - Lead Guitar Buckethead - Lead Guitar as well as fills (e.g the third guitar track on some appetite tracks) Bumblefoot - Rhythm Guitar, Lead Guitar Richard Fortus - Rhythm Guitar Tommy Stinson - Bass Guitar Dizzy Reed - Keyboard, Percussion Brian "Brain" Mantia - Drums Chris Pitman - Sound FX, Synth, Keyboards Now this ladies and gentleman is now the best Guns N' Roses line-up EVER!!!!!!!!♥♥♥♥ :beer: :beer: :beer: Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Sosso on December 14, 2015, 11:29:52 PM Axl - Vocals, Piano
Robin Finck - Lead Guitar, Backing Vocals Buckethead - Lead Guitar Dave Navarro - Lead & Rhythm Guitar, Backing Vocals Richard Fortus - Rhythm & Lead Guitar Tommy Stinson - Bass Guitar, Backing Vocals Brain - drums, Percussion Frank Ferrer - drums, Percussion Dizzy Reed - Keyboards, Piano, Percussion, backing vocals Chris Pitman - SFX, Synth, Sub Bass, Keyboards, Bass Guitar backing vocals Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: D-GenerationX on December 15, 2015, 10:41:51 AM The "Dead!" picture in the booklet of the UYI albums. Those guys.
The only new line-up guy I think merits a mention is Buckethead. But we all know you can play all their classic material without him. He would be a luxury item, not a necessary one. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: rebelhipi on January 02, 2016, 09:01:43 AM My all star lineup would be
Axl Rose Robin Finck Bumblefoot Richard Fortus Tommy Stinson Dizzy Reed Chris Pitman Josh Freese Would be really interested to see how that would work. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: JAEBALL on January 02, 2016, 10:59:39 AM Since there is even a chance of this now... the perfect touring and writing GNR lineup is
Axl, Slash, Izzy, Richard, Duff , Matt and Dizzy/Chris handling the necessary keyboard work. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Thorned Rose on February 03, 2016, 04:38:37 PM I'm not sure about the actual poster's lineup. I'd have to think about that for awhile.
My favorite lineup woul dbe the UYI Line Up with Steven Adler and Matt splitting duties or something. Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: EmilyGNR on February 03, 2016, 04:51:54 PM Since there is even a chance of this now... the perfect touring and writing GNR lineup is Axl, Slash, Izzy, Richard, Duff , Matt and Dizzy/Chris handling the necessary keyboard work. I would be interested in this lineup if you swap out Matt for Frank. :) Title: Re: Your All-Star Guns N' Roses Line-Up? Post by: Thorned Rose on February 03, 2016, 04:54:16 PM I never thought 4 guitars were necessary though.
lead, rhythm and a bass was always good I thought. |