Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Ok this thread is going to be a poll for which song you like the best of the four and give a little reason why. Do not be negative against a song you dont like.. just positive to the one you do like...

I don't know how to make a poll so just reply to this with which one you like i guess.. and if someone can help me to getting an actual Poll grafic on here... that'd be great.



My vote is for Better.?  8)

The Blues. But it's a hard choice.

I was talking about the 4 leaks...

Hmmm.. if you include all of the "new" ones...

I'd probably go with The Blues also!

Owww... hard choice.

At first it was Catcher, then Better but its now TWAT. I think even though its far too long for its own good, its a damn fine song. Trim out the last 2 minutes and its a winner. As it stands, its catcy, dark and going in a new direction that I like a lot (well, so does Better and IRS).


Sorry IRS, Ive always liked you, but your turn as favourite hasnt come yet  : ok:

I wish this was an actually poll so we could see how maybe 500 people vote

Better hands down ,the name of the song is perfect since it's better then the others

better, the changes in the song blow me away in the one time iv heard it live

Post you're  favourites number in the beginning of you're post, then we can count the vites afterwards..?  ;D

1. Catcher in the rye
2. Rhiad & the bedouins
3. IRS
4. TWAT (1)
5. Silkworms
6. The Blues (2)
7. Oh My God
8. Chinese Democracy
9. Better (3)
10. Madagascar

My vote goes to 9.

Votes so far in in parenthesis.  : ok:

I think better will win hands down.... I've never started a poll here before, is there any reason we can't have one?

Oh yes, you were. I just woke up when i replied. Sorry. Then it will be TWAT. Soory, again.  :nervous:

Better, it's the best. None of the others even come close.

At first, I would have said IRS. But I have found a new liking to Better, so my vote goes to number 9, Better!

does anone know how to make a poll on here?

Better,this song is so unique and ahead of any thing out there in rock in the last ten years

If I had answered this a couple days ago I would've said "The Blues." Of all the "new" songs, I've only heard "Better," "The Blues," and "Madasgacar" (I've heard "OMG," "Silkworms," and "Rhiad" but I don't think any of those will be on the album). I heard "Better" during the live broadcast of Rock in Rio or whatever it was, and it was awesome. But it wasn't until a couple days ago that I heard the demo that leaked and I was absolutely blown away. I'm addicted to it now, and I can't get that intro out of my head. I've been walking around for the past two days muttering "No one ever told me when I was alone, they just thought I'd know better, better . . ." My friends asked me today what the heck was I singing. I smiled and said "you'll see in a couple months."

So, to answer your question, "Better" is my favorite.

i agree gilee.. better is simply amazing

but i dont think its fair for u to say Better when u havent heard TWAT/IRS/or CITR when thsose r the 4 i was talking bout in this thread  :hihi:

this is crazy for me cuz my fav's changed a few times already. right now my fav. is irs.

i agree my fav changes on a weekly basis also.

this week my favorite is IRS also.. but overall my favorite would be Better

First you went with "Better" then changed to "The Blues", then "IRS", now back to "Better" :hihi:

I really like all of the songs but T.W.A.T. is my favorite with Better being a very close second, I agree with Tomorrows that the song is a bit too long but once they finalize it i'm sure that it'll sound amazing.. not that it already doesn't

No question about it, Better all the way, everyfin about blows me away, u cant get bored of it, even the cheesieness in some parts seems to work.

Okay, I answered this before I had ever even heard "TWAT" or "IRS" or "CITR." I heard all three for the first time last night, and I have to say that my favorite new GNR song is "CITR." I had heard bad things about it, most people didn't seem to like it, but I absolutely love it. The song totally wasn't what I was expecting. I wasn't sure about "TWAT" when I first heard it, but it's quickly growing on me. "IRS" is good, but probably my least favorite of the new songs (still haven't heard "Chinese Democracy).

So, I now vote for "CITR." It looks like it's on its way of being one of the most underrated/under-appreciated GNR tracks of all time. I really, really, really hope its on the CD.

T.W.A.T.

...and you can't create polls, btw...

better is so much better then any of the songs

Better

IRS

Better

seems like Better wins for sure.




I dont know if this needs a new thread but anyway my LEAST FAVORITE of the 4 leaks would be TWAT.. dont get me wrong, i love all 4... but T.W.A.T is nowhere near as good as the other 3.  :P

my least favourite is Catcher...
and I actually love TWAT!
such a nice song...why don't you people like it?
please do! please! please!!!  :crying:

 :hihi:

i went a week without listening to Catcher.. i dont why

i put it on last night, and was blown away just like the first time i listened to it.. what an amazing sound!

Better is just soo amazing, deffinetly number 1.
IRS, is such a good rockin' song.
Catcher, soft and awesome.
TWAT, good but doesnt give me goosebumps.