Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Im really feeling the demo studio version more than the live version.  Don't know what you guys think.

if you talk about leaked demo go here: http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=25392.0

if you are looking for live from recent shows go here: http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?board=6.0

He wasn't asking for the leaked demo or the live version of the song, he was asking our opinion on which version we prefer.

I like them both, but i'll always take a live song over a studio recorded one because there is more emotion in a live song and although it may not sound "perfect" it's much much better.. see what I did there? :hihi:

i prefer this version more
http://media.putfile.com/Better-Music-VIdeo---RIR5
ya know? :hihi:

You should look at the time he edited his post.   : ok:

hmmh...not cool to edit post... I wish I quoted... as Amish said you should look at the time he edited post

Yeah I see that now, my mistake

The leaked studio version is better then the version played live. Having heard the version played at Hungary the really cool guitar part towards the end (that is on the studio leak) simply isn't played live? -wonder why not?

Better the Bootleg from Hungary:
http://www.critical-solution.com/310506-budapest/videos/

Because Finck needed to pee so he left the stage? :hihi:

you're joking right? mind you he isn't on the stage  :hihi:

The studio version is incredible, but Axl sounds like shit every time he tries to sing it live.

 :rofl: ... Finck had some roadie, mic stand and sound problems in the beginning of that show... anger management. You can hear Ron playing the ending of Better (doesn't sound that good/out of tune? :P? as when Finck plays it, but it shows Ron is great talent and master of improvisation/quick learner)...

edit: just watched the video again (refreshing live memories)... uh, oh... it was a moment of... I have noticed Robin has slammed his guitar and left the stage and was like WTF? And now on video it is like Axl is a bit of confused like looking for Robin: "Did that bastard go stage diving again or he really left the stage?"... ahh those precious moments, but all cool

The guitar into to Better at Hammersmith blew my mind, it was super loud, it seemed to burrow into my brain!

I've been humming that fuckin' intro ever since :crying:

Some songs sound better live than studio. I think it's different for everyone. Nighttrain was not one of my favorite off of Appetite untill I heard them do it in concert now it's one of my favs. Better live sounds pretty good, but the vocals are not up to par with the leaked track. The guitars sound pretty solid though, especially the jam in the middle

I always thought that WTTJ, SCOM sounded great in the studio, not so great live.  RQ, Nightrain, PC I think sound better live then in the studio.  The new songs are 10x more lyrically complex then the old songs, so they are hard to pull off live sounding great, but the still sound good nontheless.

I love the way the part "Now I know you better..." sounds with backing vocals. I think that part sounds better than the demo.

I think it's awesome either way, I just wish the "hard part" was a bit heavier when they play it live. It comes off a we bit flat, IMO. That's about my only gripe with the live versions...

Axl can't sing the verses live unfortunately. He does a good job on the screaming in the middle but that's it. IRS and TWAT he can pull off live but Better he can't seem to do.

Dude that was probably the dumbest thing I've ever read.  He can't sing it live? Please offer some support as to why Axl is incapable of singing his song live..

I've heard him try and sing it live at the Hammerstein, in person,  and he couldn't do it. I've heard bootlegs of him trying to sing it live at other shows and he hasn't been able to do it.

While I havn't heard them play live, I have heard a few bootlegs of this song and I totally disagree with you. There is only one, don't know right now which show it was, he sounded a little off.. and a little off is still great mind you : ok:

The best version, atleast in my opinion, is from RIR5.. the sound kept screwing up at the show but worked fine for this song and he sounded great

Man, I know when people say something negative about Axl, they get questioned about how much of a GNR fan they really are.  I am a true fan that can admit the truth, and for anyone to say that "better" sounded great at Rio, is out of their mind. 

Make excuses about sound or whatever.  I heard the voice, and it was bad.  Real bad.  You're kiddin' yourself if you think otherwise.  The first minute or so of that song is painful to listen to.

So i'm out of my mind, fuck off loser : ok:

I have no idea what the fuck you are talking about because the song sounded fine, maybe you have a crappy version of the Rio performance or you just have horrible hearing.. but i'm sure others would agree that it sounded fine, if not great.

I'm sorry, I guess that i'm not a "true fan that can admit the truth" :hihi:

MoRoN

Admitting your problems, is the first step to beating your problems.

Reading this was like reading a "poetic" masterpiece.  You have such elegance and intelligence. 

Hey, while your 15 mentality gets the better of you, go listen to the first minute or so of "better" from Rio, and then tell me he sounds "awesome". 

I was as excited as anyone here to watch the Rio performance.  But I wasn't so "starstruck" to see him that my ears didn't work.

Ok, this is my last response to this fucker as it's starting to border on spamming..

For you information I listen to the Better performance all the time, and it sounds good every single time. I didn't say it was the greatest thing ever, I said I thought it was the best out of all the bootlegs of this song that I have heard and I always prefer the live songs to the stuidio ones for reasons I stated earlier in this thread

Now, you've had your moment of fun, so get back down and shine my shoes like a good lil biatch : ok:

Talk about spamming?  Look at your posts.  :yes:  Need I say more?  Shine your shoes?  :rofl: 

Who are you again?  Is that you "Internet tough guy"?  You gonna threaten to kick my ass next?

Oh well.  All I'm saying is that "better" didn't sound to sweet at Rio.  That's all.

Sorry man, but I've heard every recording of 'Better' from Rio that's out there and Axl's vocals are a complete disaster right from the start. I've heard about half a dozen live recordings of that song and the guitars have been great, but Axl has never sounded very good on it.

Axl really sings "better" awesome live (except in rir5, i really think he was trying to piss me off)

http://www.yousendit.com/transfer.php?action=download&ufid=59BB53A279E17D6B
he nails it^^

Yeah, the Madrid recording is the best I've heard by a long shot. Someone needs to put that shit on a DVD and get it online.

Hey buddy - shut the fuck up. Over here we respect people for their opinion. He thinks differently to you, grow up - no need to get personal.

And for the record, as a fan who can admit GnR's shortcomings, Axl sounded fine to me on Better. It was the mix that let us down, in my opinion.

I'm not gonna say it sounded great and I'm not gonna say it sounded awful

What I will say is that I was " a little dissapointed " in the live vocals of Better

But that may because the vocals on the demo sound so damn sweet!

I personally like the live version of 'Better' better than the demo studio one. I was at Hammerstein on May 14th and it was just so amazing to hear the opening. To me it was one of the best moments of the night.

It's a great song, one of the better (haha no pun intended) songs of the demos. I think this song will make it big.

does a full audio file of this performance exist? it sounds awesome.

On the performance of Better on May 15th, it appeared it was played a tune lower than the demo. This one didn't.

to me , the best one live is in budapest. there, better sounds awesome!  :peace:

i watched the video again. ah, so that's what happend. Seeing the video i was thinking, Axl's looking for Robin, Robin either A. Gone backstage for what ever reason (take a piss or sort out some issues with sound) or B. Has dived into the crowd, which is why a roadie is fixing the mic stand  :hihi:

from whay i have heard of the live versions so far, they are ok, although not as good as the studio version. The section that really fails to work like is the section near the middle, the section where Axl almost shouts out 4 lines of lyrics. Even on the studio version this area of the song really concerned me, although after some time i found it works ok, but live the shouting section seems like too much to pull off.

i just got to see the video of better from May17th. 2 different camera angles? pro shot? it is the best better i have seen so far  :beer: i think it is the only bootleg so far where i have hear the cool guitar part near the end. around about the middle section Bumble Foot does some great stuff, my estimation of him has just gone up  :)

Actually, Axl nails his part of the middle. He sounds just like the demo. It's just that the guitars and that awesome riff surrounding him isn't nearly as hard and as loud as it should be...

Better has a really produced sound and will never be as good live as it is studio.

Heard a partial leak and it was weird..  Saw the performance on AOL and it was terrible... seemed like a bad experiment gone wrong...

Hmmm...I know you. Didnt you use to terrorize the 2000 Intentions Forum with bitching and moaning? Maybe Im wrong though.

I have to agree. ?I don't understand how anyone thinks the RIR5 performance of Better was "great" or that Axl sounded "great". ?All sound problems aside, he sounded horrible. ?He was hoarse and out of breath and couldn't hit the notes the way he does in the studio version. ?I was embarrassed for him. ?

I think they need to tone down the concert schedule a little bit. ?Axl's voice sounded great at the Hammerstein shows from the clips I heard and now he sounds exhausted. ?I'm happy as hell he is back but seriously, they should make some type of adjustment in the schedule (or at least future schedules) to allow him enough time to recharge those pipes.

Yeah, the part that had everyone flipping out when the leak first surfaced is actually the highlight of the song when it is live.

Actually , when I used to go to that site I was still supporting Axl.. Maybe not at the end I dunno. I gave my opinion of Better... Deal with it.

The RIR performance sounded horrible, but having heard the song played live in person at Hammerstein and seen video footage of it live at Budapest it seems like that's an aberration.  It's a very difficult song to sing and play live, but Axl did very well on it at Hammerstein and the Budapest shows, the RIR one was the worst and from what I can tell not typical of the way they perform the song

After watching Axl perform Better at Donnington, I take back what I said about him not being able to sing the song live. If Axl has to stand still to sing Better live, then that's alright by me.

Ive allways said about Axl..He has the best studio voice ever ..His live voice isent as good but he makes up for it with his stage presence.....remember befor the UUillusions were released when  guns played the new songs like (14 years,garden of eden) and so on wernt that good live vocaly......but on the CDs he sounds great..
Just my Opinions..  :peace:I havent heard a good quality bootleg or better befor tonight....I downloaded the best ive heard so far from
http://www.critical-solution.com/310506-budapest/videos/   see for your self.. :peace: