Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Hi, when i was waiting for the tour to start the song i wanted to hear played the most was TWAT, but then thats it only for the first night. I dont know if anyone agrees with me but i think TWAT is the best of the leaks, but i love the other 2 as well. But instead of making this a whinging thread, why do you guys think axl stopped playing it? Cos its too emotional? Or cos hes saving the big guns for the album which surely twat is? Anyway i had a dream of holding a girls hand at nec birmingham while axl screamed "I Would do anything for you" i guess it aint gonna happen.

I dunno.... It?s very annoying indeed. I was so dissapointed not to hear my favourite CD song in RiR... :no:

Yep! Same here.  :-\

But I think they don't wanna play too many new songs until CD comes out.

yea i defintley miss TWAT, but i agree they may be holding off on playing too many new songs before the cd comes out

Wasn't it played in Madrid as well as New York. I don't think there is any reason why it isnt constant in the setlist.

You know, I was just wondering the same thing. It isn't like they haven't practiced to play the song, they have played it already twice, once in NYC and in Madrid... But I wanna hear more. I'm sure Bumble has had enough time to nail that Bucket solo already.

Come on Axl, all the new songs are great, but this is the best so far. At least play it once more on either one of gigs in Helsinki!  :D

I recall at the NYC show, Axl mentioned that they were going to try and ramble through this song, before launching into TWAT.

My personal feeling is that it's a difficult song to perform vocally.  Much like the end of coma, there are no breaks for Axl until the very long guitar bridges.  I remember at one concert during the Illusions tour, Duff started playing the intro to Coma, and Axl stopped him saying, if you want to play that song, you try and sing it.  If Axl's vocals are feeling a bit worn out, trying to sing this song isn't going to help.  My vocals are very similar to Axl's style, and I can usually get through almost all of GNR's tunes, with exceptions to Coma (that ending is very tough) and things start to get rough by the time Axl sings "... but there was a time."

Also notice that the only two times this song has been played (first night in New York and Madrid), the band more time to prepare and rest up.  Now that they're playing shows every two to four days, perhaps a six or seven minute opus isn't something they want to play every night (November Rain aside - though that's much easier to sing).

But you're right, this song rocks, and I always thought that this song of all the new ones would come off the best live (simply for the ending).  It is my favourite of the new songs and I was disappointed that I didn't get to hear it when I saw GNR on the 17th in NYC.  I'm going to see them in Paris on the 20th, and I was thinking of how I could get them to play it.  One idea was to bring a Canadian flag with me and spray paint the word T W A T on it and have my buddy and i hold it up.  Any other ideas?

Cheers,

Andrew

fuck knows why they dont play it, they have a sure fire hit on their hands, id bet that axl has his reasons and once CD comes out it will be a part of the set list, id expect that this current tour is a kind of farewell to old gnr music, and when CD drops we will have a new gnr setlist and just a few oldies.

simply put; HE IS SAVING IT BECAUSE IT IS A BIG GUN.

Having been there at the Hammerstein on May 12 I can say it is probably my favorite new song, but it sounded like one big mess live. Axl's vocals on it were less than desirable, and the guitars toward the very end were a little messy in the mix. Me thinks there needs to be some major practive done on it before they can play that live on a nightly basis as it sounded the worst live of all the stuff they played if for no other reason than it seems to have more going on than any of the other new ones.

I don't like any of the leaks/demos so I'm glad he's not playing them.

I saw the video and I didn't think it was that big a mess.  Axl sounded amazing and it was cool watching him and Tommy singing it together..  Robin and Ron both pulled off the solos pretty amazingly too.. I hope they add into the set permanent for CA.

same with Chinese Democracy. 

welll i heard it live  ;D lucky me i guess. it's a shame they're not playing CD as well, cuz the new version is sooooo sooo sooo powerful live, i think it's the best song they played in Madrid. the videos on the background are so strong, it's just amazing, the song as a great impact :peace:

I thought about the samequestion yesterday.

cheers guys i agree, concerning wolfpac.. GET THAT GUY OUT OF HERE! ARE YOU LISTENING TO ME MR ADMINISTRATOR MAN? YEAH GONE

Yup it sucks but its upto axl, anyways there isnt a girl to hold my hand.

i'll second that  : ok:

as for the topic, maybe they don't play it so much because out of all the leaks, TWAT's been getting the most mixed reviews. people either really seem to like or dislike the song. Better on the other hand, seems to appeal to most.

i personally think it's the best thing we've heard so far from Chi Dem... although The Blues is a close second for me.

I was at the may 15th show and they didn't play TWAT.  I was pissed at first because I love that song but the show still rocked and it didn't really make a difference in the end. I believe they'll play it when they're ready.

I love TWAT it's my fav of the leaks and I love Robin, however hearing him attempt to play the outro solo on the 12th boot makes me realise why they're not ready to play it on a regular basis yet.

He tries to replicate Buckets style but fails, why the fuck don't they let Bumblefoot handles Buckets parts?? I thought that's what he's there for and he is the shredder after all

Bumble does play the outro on it live, you just can't see it on the video that is floating around. Anyone who saw the show saw that is was Ron playing all of that, not Finck.

Really? My bad.
I still satnd by my statement that he doesn't do it justice though, unfotunately  :(

Because the chorus blows.

Axl thinks it's 1987 and he's still promoting Appetite. No point in promoting an album that doesn't have a release date. TWAT did sound good when I heard it live at Hammerstein. 

Thats what I was thinking, and perhaps, its been picked as the first single. You couldn't pick a better title than There Was A Time as a first single for this band.

I think that song represents the band perfectly.

TWAT is a bong hit single for the hardcore fans, not a radio hit single for the masses!

seems to me like it would be a tough song to perform live...so i think that is the reason

This isn't a scientific poll, but every "non" gnr fan I played the leaks for loved TWAT the best.

I think it would be a mistake not to release as a single, just like Audioslave not releasing Shadow Of The Sun as a single and opting for What You Are instead was a mistake.

I wish they'd play it more as well, but that's their choice. With the right mix, and a radio edit, the song has the potential to be this band's "November Rain". Great, great song. I loved watching Robin playing his solos in it...

It's possible that nobody in the band can pull of Buckethead's outro  :yes:

 Buckethead plays for well over a minute straight on the outro and it's not easy to replicate, it was a major part of the song so if no one can do it yet that might be why they don't play it

Who knows, I think if it is a big gun, they don't want to screw it up live. I soooo want to hear this song, but not as a jumbled mess

Get practicing boys!

it seems the song is a bit harder to get right in a live setting. i def. think it will be played more in the future. it needs a little practice imo. the version from hammerstein is reason enough for me to believe the potential of a VERY powerful song is there and eventually it will be a staple.

not sure if this has been suggested, but...


axl's last few notes in the outro are amazing, but also...i imagine....are killer to pull off on the vocal cords, maybe even more damaging then the intro to jungle. and w/o the last few notes, that outro wouldn't be as perfect. maybe thats why they're not playing it....???